American
Caramelized Banana Pudding Pie
Popular on Food52
7 Reviews
Wequedad
January 18, 2022
Written recipe calls for a layer of wafers after 1/2 of the pudding. Mille did not do in video. And, are these whole wafers?
Shan
December 25, 2021
I really enjoyed this banana pudding pie! I read some of the other reviews about the sweetness and thickness of the pudding so I actually only used 1/2 cup plus 1 tbsp of sugar and 3 and 1/2 tbsp of cornstarch in the pudding. This ratio worked out well in terms of sweetness. I also had to wisk the pudding for 15-18 minutes not 10 like the recipe called for. The written directions are confusing so I followed along with Millie’s video on instagram and had no problems. Although, I noticed that in the video she forgot to add the salt to the bananas but I didn’t ;)
Shan
December 25, 2021
I have a gas stove so maybe that’s why I had to wisk longer. I also used a pie dish for this. I would definitely make this again!
Marianna
October 11, 2021
Good pie also made in a glass pie plate. Very sweet would reduce sugar
and custard is very loose would add another T of corn starch. Everyone like the crust.
I topped it with fortified whipped cream added 2 T of cream cheese to heavy cream and powdered sugar
and custard is very loose would add another T of corn starch. Everyone like the crust.
I topped it with fortified whipped cream added 2 T of cream cheese to heavy cream and powdered sugar
Pudding
October 3, 2021
I just made it and waiting to cool. I was confused by ingredient list to steps as well. Almost used too much butter in crust. I Simplified to a baking dish instead of spring form. We have been making different banana pudding recipes for the past month. The banana foster twist is fun.
Serena
September 21, 2021
No review yet since I'm making it now. Directions are confusing or I'm misreading them. Does 1/4 cup sugar get added to crust? And when caramelizing bananas, it says to add remaining tsp. of vanilla but only 1 tsp. used to make pudding and recipe calls for 3 tsp? Also, pet peeve; when listing ingredients, if it will be used in divided fashion for recipe, that should be listed following the ingredient (i.e. 3 tsp., divided).
Serena
October 3, 2021
Update after making it: it was good but my husband thought it was too sweet (and he likes sugar a lot). I would reduce the sugar next time, maybe not caramelize the bananas to reduce sweetness.
See what other Food52ers are saying.