Make Ahead
Goodnight Rose: Pistachio-Cardamom Cake with Rosewater Frosting
Popular on Food52
68 Reviews
Haleh
June 28, 2024
Made these cupcakes and they turned out alright. Cooking time ended up being closer to 30 mins. The cupcake part was great and I doubled the cardamom based on other reviews. The icing turned out so horribly that I just bought a jar of buttercream icing from the store and added the food coloring and rosewater (plus a little extra). The icing just tasted like sweet butter, it was pretty gross, not sure where I went wrong.
Lmar
June 28, 2024
Something must have gone wrong with the frosting- it was delicious and light and perfect when I made it and I am not the most experienced cook. Try again! Worth it!
Lmar
May 9, 2022
I made this cake, having wanted to for years, for my daughters 50th birthday. I made 6x the recipe for the cake, and 4x for the frosting, and it was perfect. Everyone loved it very much. Delicious and a sensuous experience to see it and eat it. We were 14 people for the party, and there was a nice amount of leftovers for the next day. I am sure it would be even better with butter and flour and milk as per the original recipe but for our crowd, I made it with almond and paleo flours, and earth balance butter and oat milk. Divine. It will be requested from now on and I will be happy to make it.
Lmar
May 9, 2022
I should add to the above note that I made 6x the recipe in two batches. And that we felt that the rose water in the frosting could have been a tiny bit stronger. Also 4x the recipe made an ample, abundant even, amount of frosting but did not leave enough for piping on additional decorations. And not being able to find rose petals anywhere, next time I'd order them online in advance, and not have to use the tiny pink hearts that were the substitute decoration.
Elizabeth M.
April 4, 2021
Fantastic. My meringue turned to water (carton egg whites to blame probably) so I tossed the mixture and made a rose whipped cream frosting instead. It was deliciously light with the super moist sponge.
Kerilyn M.
May 1, 2019
My mother and I made this cake and it was delicious! Mom baked the cake and the texture and flavor were spot on. I made the frosting and it was silky smooth and just right for the cake. I decorated with pistachios and candied rose petals. So pretty! One of my favorites.
Tummypen6
April 2, 2019
Itried this recipe for a second time and failed. This time I made 3 times the mixture and divided it in to 3 8” pans but it still didn’t cook properly. The very top of each layer seemed to gain a little sponge like texture but the rest was like rubber. The only thing I can think now is that my conversions of the recipe to grams are wrong. Are you using cup measurements or grams? The mixture before baking is runny. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated as I’m desparate to get this right!!
Kris
November 11, 2018
I tripled this recipe for the cake to make 3 layers. I lessened the amount of sugar and used half of the almond extract so as not to take away from the pistachio flavor. It turned out great! The layers were a little dense and crumbly but ultimately, with the frosting I made (I made a cardamom American buttercream), it turned out alright. I don't think I'll be making it again since I like it a little lighter and more moist but everyone else seemed to enjoy it!
Jenn
July 29, 2018
Can you pls advise the height of the 8" pan you used? 1"? 2"? Thank you
Nancy
July 29, 2018
This cake is very thin I imagine a 1" would probably be fine. In my previous review I said that in order to make the cake look like the picture you'd need to make three 8" cakes. Raspberryeggplant confirmed this as well. I love these as cupcakes!
Jenn
July 29, 2018
Thanks Nancy. I will definitely try them as cupcakes. I was looking for a confirmation of height to save time, because pan height does make a difference but most recipes I encounter don't specify height for some reason. I am curious of the former case. As you indicate that the 1" height pan would work, if you use a 2" height, whether this would affect the results since the cake would not rise above the rim in that case. I only have 3"H pans and was curious which height was used as I was going to buy shorter cake pans.
raspberryeggplant
July 30, 2018
Hi Jenn,
I've never encountered a cake pan with a 1" wall - I use 2" pans, sometimes 3". A 2" pan should absolutely suffice here.
As the recipe notes, this makes enough for one 8" layer, so you will need to triple this for a three-layer cake.
Hope that helps!
Roopa
I've never encountered a cake pan with a 1" wall - I use 2" pans, sometimes 3". A 2" pan should absolutely suffice here.
As the recipe notes, this makes enough for one 8" layer, so you will need to triple this for a three-layer cake.
Hope that helps!
Roopa
Lmar
May 9, 2022
I used supermarket EZ foil cake pans, rectangular, 12.25"x 8.25"
x 1.25" Three batches worked well for two trays- making the layers about a half inch high each. The oven temp seemed okay but baking took longer- and be careful to use a good shortening to grease and flour the pans since there was a tendency to stick in the middles, but it was not a problem once the cake was assembled.
x 1.25" Three batches worked well for two trays- making the layers about a half inch high each. The oven temp seemed okay but baking took longer- and be careful to use a good shortening to grease and flour the pans since there was a tendency to stick in the middles, but it was not a problem once the cake was assembled.
Nancy
April 6, 2018
I'm thinking the problem is your pan! You say you made it in a loaf pan and that would NOT work, it's too thick to cook properly. Try again as cupcakes or you need to double the recipe and make three 8 inch cake pans in order to get the layers in the picture. This looks like its a square cake but its not, the picture is just how she sliced it. The layers are very thin. I hope you try again this so worth it.
raspberryeggplant
April 6, 2018
Thanks, Nancy! The single cake layer is indeed thin - I prefer baking thinner layers rather than torting a thicker cake. You'll need 3-4 of these for a layer cake, or you can double this recipe and put it into three 6" pans.
Tummypen6
April 1, 2019
Hi Nancy. So I just tried this again failed. This time I made 3 times the mixture and divided it in to 3 8” pans but it still didn’t cook properly. The very top of each layer seemed to gain a little sponge like texture but the rest was like rubber. The only thing I can think now is that my conversions of the recipe to grams are wrong. Are you using cup measurements or grams? The mixture before baking is runny. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated as I’m desparate to get this right!!
Tummypen6
April 5, 2018
Hi. I’m hoping someone can help! I tried making his cake today and failed miserably. I had to convert into grams and milliletres as I’m in the uk and am wondering if my conversions are wrong. The cake didn’t cook inside at all. It went into and almost rubber like texture.
I converted the recipe into the following:
25g pistachio
85g flour
1 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1/4 tsp ground cardamom
57g butter
100g sugar
1 egg
125ml milk
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1/4 tsp almond extract
I then doubled the recipe and baked in a 2lb loaf tin.
Have I gone wrong with the ingredients or does it need to be baked only as cupcakes or layer cake?
Any help would be much appreciated...the flavours are amazing so I’m very keen to get this recipe sorted.
I converted the recipe into the following:
25g pistachio
85g flour
1 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1/4 tsp ground cardamom
57g butter
100g sugar
1 egg
125ml milk
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1/4 tsp almond extract
I then doubled the recipe and baked in a 2lb loaf tin.
Have I gone wrong with the ingredients or does it need to be baked only as cupcakes or layer cake?
Any help would be much appreciated...the flavours are amazing so I’m very keen to get this recipe sorted.
raspberryeggplant
April 6, 2018
It's the pan! This needs to be baked in an 8" cake pan, either round or square. A loaf pan is just too thick so it was certainly not cooked inside after even 25 minutes. Try it again in a cake pan and it will be full baked after the specified time :)
Nancy
April 16, 2017
So I finally made this. Twice. As a cake I felt that the layers were way too thin. You'd need to make 4 in my opinion. I tried cupcakes and for me they are perfect! The cake is moist and has an amazing flavor, the pistachios and cardamom are fantastic together. This frosting is simply ethereal. So light and melts in your mouth. I used 1/4 teaspoon of Nielsen-Massey Rose Water, it's strong and any more would be far too much. I made the cupcakes 2 days ahead and kept in an air tight container room temp. Frosted a day ahead and refrigerated. They were perfect. I did not bring to room temp to serve.
raspberryeggplant
April 17, 2017
So glad you liked it! This is definitely my favorite cake.
The recipe does make thin layers - I make three or four of them instead of two thicker layers that I need to divide.
The recipe does make thin layers - I make three or four of them instead of two thicker layers that I need to divide.
hessa
March 5, 2017
I made this cake it's so yummy!!! Turned out moist and fluffy as i wanted. I increased the quantity of pistachio to 3/4 cup- 1 cup for a richer flavor and a bright pistachio green color- always my favorite color! Thank you for the best cake recipe! Just what i was looking for!
Tip: Can use as well Pistachio cream spread to layer the cakes or as a toping for the cupcakes.
Tip: Can use as well Pistachio cream spread to layer the cakes or as a toping for the cupcakes.
LouLou
February 6, 2017
I can't rave enough about this cake!! I had my doubts when it came out fairly dense. However, after frosting it (and trust me, don't skimp on the frosting - the flavors of both cake and frosting blend beautifuly) and then eating it (best part), I was sold on what a wonderful cake this was. I did add more a bit more cardomom for the flavor.
raspberryeggplant
April 17, 2017
Thank you LouLou! So glad you like it. I usually use a light hand with the cardamom as I have found that some people don't love it as much as I do, but I agree that the recipe can take a bit more than what's written here without being overpowering to a cardamom-lover!
kumalavula
April 30, 2016
i love anything with cardamom so ended up almost doubling the cardamom amount this recipe called for and it still didn't seem overpowering. i, also, made a different buttercream frosting but added rose water which accented the pistachio-cardamom pairing nicely. i would echo another comment below that the amount of batter was scant and i'd double it when making again. otherwise, a complete winner!
raspberryeggplant
April 17, 2017
Glad you liked it! This is indeed a small yield. I usually double or even triple it but I like having the base recipe make a smaller quantity as I find it easier to scale up than scale down :)
Dedairyfy
May 11, 2015
Hi!+Just+tried+your+recipe+and+loved+it!+However,+I+made+a+dairy+free+version+and+blogged+about+it+if+you'd+like+to+check+it+out.+#dairyfree+cardamom,+pistachio,+and+rose+#cupcakes+with+@MeltOrganic+http://wp.me/p5P3gx-5L+Thank+you+for+sharing!
Jessica
September 2, 2014
Excuse typos/punctuation errors I must need coffee and can't see how to edit hehe.
Jessica
September 2, 2014
Thanks for sharing. I was wondering if you use green or black cardamom in this recipe? I assume green but want to check. Would you say this is what people usually refer to when not specified in recipes in general in your experience. I've only tried my hand at some traditional savory indian dishes which have specified in my limited experience. Thanks for your time :).
raspberryeggplant
April 17, 2017
Green cardamom! Black cardamom has a more earthy flavor that's better for savory dishes, I find.
See what other Food52ers are saying.