All questions

Oil instead of butter for oatmeal cookies?

A friend does not want to use butter or margarine. She wants the cookies to be parve and low-chol. Can she use oil?

asked by creamtea 9 months ago
7 answers 1619 views
Default-small
added 9 months ago

Someone else asked about substituting oil for butter when making Linzer cookies. I’ll give the same answer to your question as I gave to the first question. Sure, you can make the substitution, but don’t expect the cookies to taste particularly good. Butter adds lots of flavor that oil will not. Oil will also change the texture. Instead of substituting an oil with little or no flavor, why not find a recipe for a cookie that doesn’t call for butter in the first place? Biscotti are a start--most Italian recipes for biscotti (or cantucci) don’t use butter. There are plenty of other cookie recipes from around the Mediterranean that don’t use butter either, so there are many good choices. I understand the parve issue, but I suspect the cholesterol concern is off-target. You might want to check out this article in the NY Times today about whole organic milk: http://www.nytimes.com...

Dsc00859_2
added 9 months ago

Thanks for your answer, Maedl, but I was asking on behalf of a friend who really won't care that much about perfect flavor or an authentic Italian cookie. She would be unlikely to go to the trouble of double-baking biscotti. She just wanted to make the cookie recipe from the lid of the Quaker oatmeal box--as long as the cookie dough hangs together, she's happy. She did try subbing oil and it was fine for her needs. I on the other hand want all the butter cream and sugar I can get ;)

Jc_profilepic
added 9 months ago

I have never had trouble using oil as a sub for butter with this ratio: 1/3 cup oil for each 1/2 cup butter.
Yes the flavor and texture will be different but sometimes the change in texture is a desirable one (softer, less crunchy) and it is a good trick to know for various reasons...

Dsc00859_2
added 9 months ago

Thank you Sadassa; I agree it is useful to sometimes be able to sub some or all of the fat. I sometimes like the tenderer crumb that oil bring to a cake, for example.

P1291120
added 9 months ago

Agree with Sadassa -- I've done it a number of times. FWIW: my favorite substitute is Safflower oil as it is very "clean" and won't leave a bit of the underlying flavor.

Dsc00859_2
added 9 months ago

Thank you SeaJambon. Agree about Safflower oil. I have recently switched from canola which has a "fishy" taste.

Img00019-20100929-0432_1_
added 9 months ago

Hi creamtea, this link from California Oil popped in my email today with an article about replacing butter with oil. If you read it also features a conversion table. http://consumers.californiaoliveranch...