Boston Greens with Tarragon Buttermilk Dressing, Red Pears, and Toasted Hazelnuts
Author Notes: Coquette Cafe in MKE has a wonderful green salad with buttermilk and hazelnuts. I tried to recreate a version at home with the addition of tarragon and shallots in the dressing, sliced red pears beneath, and crunchy pink sea salt on top (this may be my favorite part). - Jennifer Ann
Food52 Review: What's great about this salad is that it combines the robust flavors of fall -- pears and hazelnuts -- with an elegant salad green -- Boston lettuce -- and a succinct and tangy buttermilk dressing. So when you eat it, there are rich bits followed by bright bits and flashes of sweetness, and the whole thing is a delight to eat. Use two small heads of lettuce and small pears. - A&M - A&M
Serves 4
Fresh Tarragon Buttermilk Dressing
- 3 tablespoons buttermilk
- 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
- 1.5 teaspoons olive oil
- 1 teaspoon minced shallot
- 1.5 teaspoons finely chopped fresh tarragon
- freshly ground black pepper (4-5 turns on the mill - finest setting)
- salt (3-4 turns on the mill - finest setting)
- Whisk together buttermilk and mayonnaise until smooth; whisk in olive oil until well incorporated; add shallot, tarragon, salt and pepper.
Hazelnut Preparation and Salad Assembly
- 1/3 cup hazelnuts
- 3 red pears
- 2 heads of Boston lettuce, washed and torn into medium-large sized pieces
- coarse pink or red sea salt (such as Alaea Hawaiian)
- freshly ground black pepper
- Roast hazelnuts in a single layer in a 350 oven for about 10 minutes, or until they start to lightly brown; remove from oven, and roll hazelnuts in dish towel to remove the papery skins; allow hazelnuts to cool, then coarsely chop and set aside
- Thinly slice the pears, being sure to keep a good sliver of the red peel on each slice; arrange the pears in a single layer on 4 salad plates, with the peel edges facing outward
- Toss the lettuce in about half the dressing, adding more, as necessary, to nicely coat all pieces; pile the lettuce in a tall mound on top of the pears (be sure to keep the red pear peals visible)
- Top each salad with freshly ground pepper, a small handful of the toasted hazelnuts, and a little pinch of the crunchy sea salt.
- Your Best Autumn Salad Contest Finalist!




7 days ago Sylvia Parks
I was looking for a buttermilk tarragon recipe to make tarragon chicken salad and discovered your website. Wow! Lots of very appealing recipes here and I look forward to trying some more. The dressing made a very tasty chicken salad. I have to keep my fat intake pretty low, so I substituted fat free mayo for the regular. Since the fat free is sweeter tasting that regular, I added a tsp of vinegar to even it out. Next time, I will probably use lemon juice, but didn't have any lemons on hand. I doubled the recipe so I would have some left to try on an actual salad. Any suggestions for a summer version of this salad since pears aren't in season now? Thanks!
6 months ago Hark
Fantastic recipe, and really easy. I added some bacon, because that makes (almost) everything better!
over 1 year ago koechin
i could taste these flavors as i read the recipe so of course i had to make it. served it with pork tenderloin and roasted butternut squash, perfect flavor combinations, thanks for this yummy salad.
about 1 year ago Jennifer Ann
Thank you, Koechin! I am so happy you enjoyed it. (love your picture with the little one:))
over 1 year ago QueenOfGreen
Oh wow! Even with my less-than-stellar pears, this salad is AMAZING! Thank you!
over 2 years ago boulangere
Cynthia is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.
Oooh! Making this today!
over 2 years ago Jennifer Ann
I hope you enjoy the salad!
over 2 years ago hayley
How many servings does this make? Thanks!
over 2 years ago Jennifer Ann
4 as a first salad course. Hope you have a chance to give it a try!
over 2 years ago hayley
Tried it and loved it. Thanks!
over 2 years ago AntoniaJames
AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.
What a simple, elegant salad! And to my mind, simple + elegant = perfect. I made this last night, when I noticed that my tarragon needed trimming, and I had no other special plans for the evening's salad. I used a Bartlett because that was all I had on hand, and lightly toasted walnuts because I had no hazelnuts, and added a diced Persian cucumber because I wanted a bit more crunch. Utterly delicious!! I'm glad to have found this, which I am certain to be making again! ;o)
over 2 years ago Jennifer Ann
AJ, I am happy that you tried the recipe, and really so pleased that you liked it! Love your ad hoc substitutions and additions~
almost 3 years ago Midge
So many of my favorite ingredients. Saving this for fall. Love Coquette Cafe (and MKE in general).
almost 3 years ago Jennifer Ann
so happy you know about our lovely little hamlet! send me a note before your next visit - lots of new secret places to share :)
about 3 years ago NakedBeet
I love everything about this.
about 3 years ago Jennifer Ann
Thanks NB! I hope you find a chance to try it
over 3 years ago Mammamia
Plan to make this for this year's Thanksgiving salad. It offers simple delicious flavors.
over 3 years ago LLoquet
I love the simplicity of his salad. It would be great for Thanksgiving when you have a lot of competing flavors. Fresh, bright, elegant, delicious!
over 3 years ago glasgow
can't wait to try this one out!
over 3 years ago junebug
I tried this last night and was underwhelmed. It wanted something more - prosciutto or dried cranberries were some of the suggestions at our table. There wasn't enough contrast in the flavors. Not a bad salad, just not vote-worthy.
over 3 years ago SunnySideUp (lesley829)
boston lettuce is my favorite. nice combination!
over 3 years ago ENunn
The dressing did it for me. Lovely.
over 3 years ago Franck
fresh, and easy to make with easily available ingredients. the way to go. well done!
over 3 years ago CattyA
This will take the place of the grapefruit and avocado on greens on my Thanksgiving table!
over 3 years ago suschristine
I want to marry this woman!
over 3 years ago lastnightsdinner
So hard to choose between two gorgeous Fall salads, but this recipe incorporates so many of my favorite flavors, I just had to give it my vote.
over 3 years ago AntoniaJames
AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.
This one is a definitely on the menu for next week (probably Sunday evening, as our farmers' market is on Sunday mornings). I cannot wait to try it.