Rosh Hashana Apple Cake
Author Notes: While preparing four holiday meals for friends and family over the span of the two days of Rosh Hashana (Jewish New Year) last week, I was reminded that there is a beauty in keeping things simple, both in the kitchen and out. So I was overjoyed to discover a cake that nearly bakes itself. I adapted a recipe touted as "The Easiest Cake Ever" -- meant for ripe pears or stone fruits dripping with juice -- to a slightly more traditional apple cake. Given that apples are not particularly juicy, I decided to first saute them in some margarine and sugar, giving them a slight caramelization as I would for a tarte tatin. I had leftover apples and the cake smelled so good in the oven that I whipped up a second batch of batter in about 5 minutes and popped the second cake in the oven while the first was cooling. [NOTE: the batter is adapted from www.notderbypie.com] - zahavah
Serves 8-10
For the apples
- 4 apples - I used a variety (1 each of Gala, Fuji, Granny Smith, and Crispin)
- lemon juice to prevent apples from browning as you cut (~1T)
- 2 tablespoons margarine (or butter if making dairy)
- 1-2 tablespoon sugar
For cake batter
- 1 cup flour
- 3/4 cups sugar
- 2 eggs
- 1/2 cup canola oil
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 2-3 tablespoons demerara sugar (optional)
- Preheat oven to 350º F. Grease and flour a 9-inch cake pan, springform or square pan. (If you want to plate this, use a springform; otherwise, just serve it out of the pan.)
- Peel and core the apples, then cut into ~12 slices. Sprinkle with lemon juice (you don't need much - maybe a tablespoon or so for 4 apples) while the others are being sliced to prevent browning.
- Heat margarine in pan over low heat and add apples and 1-2 T white sugar. Stir for ~10-15 minutes until apples soften. Some of the liquid will soak into the apples, but if too much of it starts to evaporate, then turn the heat down.
- While the apples are on the stove top, mix together the remaining ingredients (except for the demerara sugar) -- flour, sugar (the 3/4 C), eggs, oil, baking powder, and vanilla. No mixer is required - you can just mix everything by hand even though the batter is quite thick.
- Add half the warm apples (juices and all) to the batter and mix. Then pour into the prepared pan and spread the batter evenly with a spatula . Arrange the remaining apple slices on the top of the batter as decoratively as possible (though even a mishmash will look nice).
- Sprinkle the cake with demerara sugar if you'd like and bake for 1 hour. As it bakes, the high egg content causes the cake to rise up as the heavier fruit sinks slightly and the demerara sugar helps creates a crackly crunchy crust that caramelizes slightly at the edges and where the fruit juices pool.
- Cool in pan and serve. I doubt you'll have leftovers.
- This recipe is a Community Pick!
- This recipe was entered in the contest for Your Best Apple Cake



about 1 year ago bebe le perche
Amazing cake. Thank you. I used butter instead of oil, demarara sugar and a bit of maple syrup for sauteeing the apples, a splash of brandy and two tablespoons of Greek yogurt in the batter. I ate some warm with a cappucino, and the rest was devoured by my family in minutes after dinner.
over 1 year ago zahavah
Thank you minissimus, Thi, Nancila, and RachaelMR for your comments. I'm so glad that you've enjoyed this cake that has also become one of my go-to desserts. It's great with pears too!
over 1 year ago zahavah
Thank you minissimus, Thi, Nancila, and RachaelMR for your comments. I'm so glad that you've enjoyed this cake that has also become one of my go-to desserts. It's great with pears too!
over 1 year ago minissimus
Made a lovely desert for a brunch I "catered" for my wife. Easy to make from pantry ingredients. The only way to improve it is with a dollop of softly whipped, lightly sweetened cream. Thanks for sharing the recipe.
over 1 year ago Thi
I made this last week. Very easy but fantastic. The cake was light and the mix of apples give such great flavor.
over 1 year ago nancila
So, I made this for Rosh haShana, and it was a huge hit. So I made it again for that next Friday night's dessert. And it was loved again by all. So I made it again for dessert a couple of weeks later for out on the Sukkah. Loved it. And then I made it again...well, you get the picture.
over 1 year ago rachaelmr
This cake has become an absolute staple - i made it once for a lovely dinner with friends and now my spouse requests it weekly, i am so glad it is so easy and so delicious - Thank you!
over 1 year ago Judy at Two Broads Abroad
Made this cake last week for a "culinary challenged" Rosh Hashana at a friend's house. What a gem. Thanks for this. It's a keeper that I will share.
over 1 year ago zahavah
Hi Judy -- I'm so glad that you liked the cake. Shana tova!
over 1 year ago zahavah
Hi everyone - thanks for all the comments and my apologies for my delayed responses. I've been a bit absent from food52 due to a crazy job. But I'm so glad to hear that you guys had great results with this cake. So easy!
over 2 years ago gingerroot
I made this on Saturday for a get together - it was fantastic! So easy to put together and really delicious. The only change I made was substituting one mango for one of the apples (and so used only 1/2 cup sugar). I will definitely make this again.
over 3 years ago Julia Alling
The cake was well-received last night. Recipe requested by guests! I also used butter and it was lovely.
over 3 years ago Julia Alling
The cake was well-received last night. Recipe requested by guests! I also used butter and it was lovely.
over 3 years ago mtrelaun
This was a snap to put together! I substituted butter for margarine, and brown sugar for demerara, and used Fuji and Stayman Winesap apples. Cake looked and tasted great.
over 3 years ago porkchop
I made this cake as a last minute addition to family dinner invite. Was enjoyed by all.
over 3 years ago amanda
Amanda is a co-founder of Food52.
Nice photos. Is that a green flannel sheet? If so, will make me feel better about our props. We're constantly scavenging my house for surfaces.
over 1 year ago zahavah
Amanda - nice to hear from you (the founder!). I have a whole bunch of different colored cloth napkins that I use as backdrops. So many, in fact, that I store them in my wooden coffee table (you know, the kind that's essentially a huge, hinged box that you get when you live in NY and have not room?). As you can see, I never manage to iron any of them...
over 1 year ago amanda
Amanda is a co-founder of Food52.
Yes, I know that kind of furnishing. We keep one of our tables inside the fireplace, because there's nowhere else to put it!
over 3 years ago Jestei
This cake was a crowd pleaser. I used vegetable oil rather than canola. because that is what I had, and ditto Turbinado for Demerara sugar. All good. Would make again.