🔎

My Basket ()

The Piglet2013 / Final Round, 2013

The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook

The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook

Deb Perelman

Get the Book

VS
A Girl and Her Pig: Recipes and Stories

A Girl and Her Pig

April Bloomfield

Get the Book

The Judgment

Fergus_henderson3_(patricia_niven)

By Fergus Henderson

Cookbooks are particular things -- they’re not unlike catalogs of an artist’s work, a description of place and a marker of the time in which they are written. In that way, their permanence is not inherent, and many have the potential to become obsolete bookshelf fodder.

The world is drowning under a culinary tsunami wave of cookbooks, and as such, the gems -- those that act as flotation devices amidst the storm -- are becoming harder to distinguish. They’re becoming fewer and farther in between. 

The role of a cookbook is important: it needs to teach you how to cook. And the books that succeed in this become battered and stained from much use -- they become timeless, much like old friends. There are books that take you by the hand, making sure everything works. They detail times, temperatures, weights, and measures. Others prescribe a looser relationship, sort of like Yoda teaching Luke the Force. 

In both cases, the book you forever want on your shelf should reassure you. It should never preach, but rather, it should inform and excite. Take my mum, who, after cooking a recipe 100 times, will still read the method before cooking it for a 101st. This shows the immense responsibility of a cook who has endeavored to write. 

Photos factor into the greatness of a cookbook, too, if slightly less. Still, they need to be beautiful, to get your juices going. Like a buxom farmer's wife from Normandy with an apple tart, say, or a plate of splendid cheese alongside a bottle of Burgundy. Or a pork chop and prunes. 

In this competition’s final, we have two books: one that represents timelessness, and one that lacks a sense of permanence. And we have two authors, both of whom are putting themselves on a pedestal to write a cookbook. April Bloomfield has addressed food with the perfect split of time and place, and a true sense of genus loci. On the other, very different hand, we have Deb Perelman’s The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook, the current, immediate nature of which lacks permanence and rigor. (Both of which are needed even in the domestic kitchen.)

A great cookbook, a lasting one, behaves more like an artist’s portfolio. The work should be now, but should also be ten years from now -- and it should capture in full the spirit of foods’ permanence and joy. The Essentials of Classic Italian Cooking by Marcella Hazan is a great example of a cookbook, brilliant in its recipes, that will never go out of style. And I still cook from Paula Wolfert’s The Cooking of Southwest France, for its authority on all things French. (I also happen to love that she uses goose fat, but that is beside the point.) 

Here, between these two finalist cookbooks, it’s the domestic kitchen versus the professional. Both can be great, but it’s about adapting to your reader, becoming that old friend -- being the source that can be relied on time and time again.  

An 18th century Man-of-War captain had to befriend his crew and maintain discipline. There may be less broadsides today, but as it happens, there are many similarities between kitchens and such warships. So, in our modern day act of war between cookbooks -- each plentiful publication for itself -- the stand-alone book has to act as captain, to befriend its crew and to maintain discipline. And it has to do this in a way that lasts. 

The Votes

Cathy Barrow

CATHY BARROW

Vote: A Girl and Her Pig

[The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook] is a great cookbook for the novice cook. But A Girl and Her Pig? Every recipe I made had a surprise. Each one taught me a technique. Most added an ingredient where it was least expected. And each one delighted all those gathered at the table.
Tom Hirschfeld

TOM HIRSCHFELD

Vote: A Girl and Her Pig

A Girl and Her Pig is not just one of the best [cookbooks], but it rises to another level…As you get to know her food, you get to know Bloomfield. The pages are laced with personal tales of cooking and career and with each turn of the page her passion, which is quietly infectious, builds only to remain with you long after you've closed the cover.
Julia Turshen & Cleo Brock-Abraham

JULIA TURSHEN & CLEO BROCK-ABRAHAM

Vote: A Girl and Her Pig

April's [recipes] were much more evocative, incredibly inspiring and quite beautiful, more I want to eat that right now! In the end, both of these books deserve a place on your shelf; but while Deb made us feel even more at home in our home kitchens, April made us feel the grand possibility in these small spaces. When it comes down to it, it's April's book that makes us swoon just a bit more.

And the winner is…

A Girl and Her Pig: Recipes and Stories

A Girl and Her Pig: Recipes and Stories

Get the Book

Do you Agree? (47 comments)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

about 1 month ago erryberrie

I purchased both cookbooks after last years contest. I have made about 3-4 items from April Bloomfield's "A Girl and her Pig"; but none of them were followed exactly to the recipe due to lack of available ingredients (living in the country is limited). Even though some of the ingredients were a bit off, all of the dishes were excellent; full of depth and wonderful flavor (mint can go a long way in the pea soup!). However, over the past year I have tried around 10 of Deb Perelman's recipes from the "Smitten Kitchen Cookbook" purely due to the approach-ability of the recipes themselves. Many of the recipes have been repeated--- to the point where water and food staining on the pages is prevalent throughout. The turkey meatballs with smashed chickpeas (a standard in our home now), baked eggplant, wild rice casserole, flourless chocolate cake, brittled peanuts, brown buttered Rice Krispie Treats, etc, etc, etc, have been made over and over. I would consider giving a copy of the Smitten Kitchen cookbook to my (wanna-be) chef family members; because it is just that good of a cookbook--- well written, approachable, with easily obtainable ingredients, and clear (if not perfect) instructions. I really like "A Girl and her Pig," but I would have to give Deb Perelman my vote here.

Img_1966

2 months ago Aly Waterfall

I love the Smitten Kitchen and her book. I do not get the comparison or why Deb has to endure the slam. They are different books and both are well done. I do NOT LIKE this kind of negative slam on a decent person who goes over the top to create and share well tested and thought out recipes. Boo on this format and style. It sucks. Why can't reviews be set up to be positive and constructive in that sense?

Img_2444

2 months ago o.lechow

Yayy! I cannot wait to get this cookbook. April is a real hero of mine! Great choice!

Default-small

11 months ago Salles

Terrible cover:(
She looks horrible, gross.

Default-small

9 months ago Minelia M Ramos

She looks splendid -although I'm pretty sure she doesn't care about looks, because she is a genius. An incredible person that will leave remembrances and important contributions to the time she is here in this earth. Unlike you perhaps, whom are a person that nobody shall speak about when you're gone -you simpleton!

Default-small

about 1 month ago erryberrie

I was initially put off the cover also; but purchased the book anyway based on the Piglet review (dont judge a book by its cover?). What I realized is that April has great respect for the animals with which she cooks. She uses mostly all of the animal; and the recipes are thoughtful and well written; a true testament to that animal's life. In the cover photo, April is holding the pig with respect, and in her recipes, she artfully prepares the meat in such a way that pays tribute to the main event (the meat itself!).

Default-small

about 1 year ago Victoria Carr

I'm glad you had the three community judges because I think the only thing the so-called conflict of interest could have caused would have been Mr. Henderson's being harder than he had to be when judging April Bloomfield's book. I, personally, think the choice made was the correct one. I love A Girl and Her Pig; it's brilliant, a wonderful book, one of only a few that I have two copies of because I cook in two places. I look forward to The Piglet each year, and even if I don't always agree with the Judges (I was personally shocked when Bouchon Bakery, which is a very readable, usable, important book did not move forward and disappointed when Canal House, which I read, and like, and use, dropped out), it's a lot of fun.

Default-small

about 1 year ago Bob Y

I haven't read either of the finalists but wonder if your choice of Ferguson was not a bit weighted to the Pig book. Using your most active members be the voice of the people is also a bit weighted, as these are expert and adventurous cooks.

Default-small

about 1 year ago MsMora

A well deserved win for April. I attended a debut of her book at Lincoln Restaurant in Portland OR last year where she made recipes from the book along with Lincoln's chef/owner Jenn Lewis. The two of them made a terrific team. April was a breath of fresh air; she's casual and real. Her food was delicious. She treated everyone as if they were a long lost relative. We'd love to have her come back to Portland again.

Face-1

about 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

There were so many outstanding cookbooks this year. And one that never seemed to get noticed for some reason is a major impressive study into Latin American Food, from all the Latin American countries. It is
Gran Cocina Latina: The Food of Latin America by Maricel E. Presilla. I just cannot get over how amazed I am by this book. It is, to me, as important as Mastering the Art of French Cooking. Here is the blurb from Amazon..."Gran Cocina Latina unifies the vast culinary landscape of the Latin world, from Mexico to Argentina and all the Spanish-speaking countries of the Caribbean. In one volume it gives home cooks, armchair travelers, and curious chefs the first comprehensive collection of recipes from this region. An inquisitive historian and a successful restaurateur, Maricel E. Presilla has spent more than thirty years visiting each country personally. She’s gathered more than 500 recipes for the full range of dishes, from the foundational adobos and sofritos to empanadas and tamales to ceviches and moles to sancocho and desserts such as flan and tres leches cake. Detailed equipment notes, drink and serving suggestions, and color photographs of finished dishes are also included. This is a one-of-a-kind cookbook to be savored and read as much for the writing and information as for its introduction to heretofore unrevealed recipes. Two-color; 32 pages of color photographs; 75 line drawings". Really if you have any interest in the fabulous cuisine from Latin American, it is a must have book. It blew me away more than any other book this year.

Face-1

about 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

Sorry- I forgot about this one....it was also easy to overlook, and is fabulous. '101 Classic Cookbooks 501 Classic Recipes'. This is a huge book, with fabulous color photos of the 101 cookbooks they selected, then recipes from them. A lot of thoughts expressed on what makes a classic cookbook. The book is a real joy. It is like finding old friends in the pages, and finding new ones as well. The book is 688 pages and weighs a bunch!

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Associate Editor of Food52.

We featured Gran Cocina Latina as a Piglet Community Pick! http://food52.com/blog...

Face-1

about 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

Cool! I did not see that!

Birthday_2012

about 1 year ago luvcookbooks

Meg is a trusted home cook.

So happy to read all the Piglets ... luv the community picks reviews, please repeat next year.

Mcs

about 1 year ago mcs3000

What a fun ending to the Piglet w/three of my faves: April Bloomfield, Fergus Henderson (dying to visit St. John) + Cathy Barrow. Love the Piglet. Can next year's start tomorrow?

Profilepreferred

about 1 year ago MrsWheelbarrow

Cathy is a trusted source on Pickling/Preserving.

Default-small

about 1 year ago Stevenrides

Any contest that eliminates Jerusalem in the first round is suspect IMHO :-)

Image

about 1 year ago jamcook

Maybe just a teensy bit of British nose to tail Jingoism?

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only

about 1 year ago AntoniaJames

AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.

I'd love to hear more from the community judges about the specific recipes they tried and liked, and why. (I suspect that the community judges had strict word limits for their comments.) Thank you. ;o)

Profilepreferred

about 1 year ago MrsWheelbarrow

Cathy is a trusted source on Pickling/Preserving.

As one of the community judges, I tried six or more recipes in each book. In SK, loved the leek fritters, meatloaf, chocolate chip brioche pretzels (OMG) and a snap pea salad with a miso dressing. All were really solid recipes. From GAHP, I went bonkers for coddled eggs with anchovy and cream, liver and onions, pancakes with bacon and chile, squash and pancetta toasts and seven vegetable soup. Each of these had some special element or technique that took the recipe over the top. It was a difficult choice, but GAHP quite simply knocked me out.

Default-small

about 1 year ago ElizaB

Yes! This has been one of my favorite cookbook purchases of the year. Beautifully written and with fascinating techniques and recipes. Glad it won.

Default-small

about 1 year ago Lauren10028

So enjoyed the the tournament and rushed to my UWS Barnes and Noble to buy A Girl and Her Pig. After searching the cookbook table, I found out the book was removed!!!!!! and now on the bookshelves due to complaints from the vegans. Is this a cause for roast pig????

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only

about 1 year ago AntoniaJames

AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.

I agree with so much of what Mr. Henderson has to say. I also appreciate the concise, helpful comments of each of the judges. I agree that timelessness -- i.e., a book that ages well -- should carry the day. And on that basis alone, I concur in the judgment. (Sorry, but the banal chatter that typifies so many food blogs, and increasingly is making its way between the covers of hardbound cookbooks by food bloggers, doesn't age well. I don't buy, because I find tedious and tiresome, cookbooks that include more than a bare minimum of first-person-singular prose. There, I said it.) ;o)

Default-small

about 1 year ago cookkate

The same Fergus Henderson who has a quote on the back cover of the book? Nice.

Gator_cake

about 1 year ago hardlikearmour

hardlikearmour is a trusted home cook.

Which is why food52 fully disclosed the conflict & and had alternate judges pick the winner.

Default-small

about 1 year ago nancy o

I'd suggest that food52 put a note about the conflict and how they resolved it here on this page to avoid the ongoing confusion.

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Associate Editor of Food52.

Thanks, hla! If anyone would like to read more, here is the post we published and featured on our homepage: http://food52.com/blog...

Imag0055

about 1 year ago mainecook61

How much better it would have been in this case to avoid a conflict of interest rather than have to explain it. And how much better all of these reviews would have been if there had been a set of standards for what they should contain. Celebrity in the food world does not always equal good writing. Given the labor and love that must go into the writing of a cookbook, the writers whose volumes were reviewed in this competition often deserved better than they received.

Default-small

about 1 year ago jellygood

Kenzi - I'm please you mention the conflict of interest! While I like April's book I'm surprised that Fergus was chosen as the judge. He was not only April's culinary mentor, and is acknowledged as such in the book, but she included a recipe "Fried Pig's Ear Salad" which is described as her "homage" to Fergus "a friend and chef." Bearing that in mind, he is a surprising choice to judge the final round lol!

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Associate Editor of Food52.

Of course! And we totally agree. We pick all of the judges and the books before the start of the tournament, so we didn't choose Fergus after we knew that April's book would be in the final -- but this was our solution to keeping the Piglet's integrity and fairness intact. Also, sidenote: that salad is delicious.

Default-small

about 1 year ago paseo

Great reply, Kenzi. I don't get the complaints about Henderson being judge between the finalists. It's not like anyone knew which would be the last two. And there was complete unanimity amongst the five of them.

Gator_cake

about 1 year ago hardlikearmour

hardlikearmour is a trusted home cook.

Great Piglet this year! And quite fitting that it was won by a Girl and Her Pig. Congrats to all participants. I've already purchased Roots and Salt Sugar Smoke thanks to the Piglet, and I'll likely add a couple more soon.

Junechamp

about 1 year ago ChefJune

June is a trusted source on General Cooking.

I agree, Liz, and I'm off to order both these books. The various reviews I've read during Piglet have convinced me they are must-haves. Have to admit I was partial to April's book. Having been the granddaughter of a pig farmer, and having raised a pig myself, I love the cover of her book.

Face-1

about 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

My grandparents raised pigs as well as food crops, cattle, and chickens. I will never forget the screams from the pigs as they were slaughtered. I raised a pig too, a pet of my daughters. Her name was Spamala. She was extremely smart, very social, and really sweet, living to be 19 years old. Our pet rescued goats are even more loving and smart. I like all cookbooks, but my main goal is to try to adapt their recipes and make them taste great but be vegetarian.

Default-small

about 1 year ago paseo

i have both books, have cooked from each and completely agree with the result. As much as I like Smitten Kitchen, Bloomfield's book is on a whole other level. My only regret with the result is that it means The Piglet is over for another year.

Face-1

about 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

Mr. Henderson, did you cook from both books? What recipes? I don't disagree that a great teaching cookbook that will stand the test of time should win. But modern trends are pointing more and more to far more plant based foods with much less meat. Think stir fries with a bit of meat for flavor as opposed to a big steak. This trend is good not only for our health but for the planet and the humane treatment of the animals. I don't disagree with Aprils genius in the kitchen, but proudly carrying a dead piglet on her shoulders on the cover is not even good for the current times.

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Associate Editor of Food52.

The point was not for him to muse on his experiences cooking from each book -- we had a whole panel of judges who cooked and tested recipes tirelessly. Rather, because of his conflict of interest with April Bloomfield, we wanted to hear about these two books in the context of what he thinks makes a great cookbook. See the full explanation here: http://food52.com/blog...

Img00019-20100929-0432_1_

about 1 year ago sexyLAMBCHOPx

Dissappointed with the recipes in The Smitten Kitten - I'll stick to her blog. However, Piglet has convinced me to buy Japanese Farm Food & A Girl and Her Pig. Great reviews for all.

Img00019-20100929-0432_1_

about 1 year ago sexyLAMBCHOPx

Although only one winner is possible, the great reviews has moved me to purchase both cookbooks. Oh, and also Roots.

Ozoz_profile

about 1 year ago Kitchen Butterfly

I love the parallels between food and art. And the reasons from all the judges on their unanimous choice. Congratulations April.

And Congratulations Deb.

Well done to the great team for bringing us wonderful, passionate reviews!

La_gerbe_detail

about 1 year ago rosalind5

Sigh. I don't quibble with the result, but the scientist in me would really liked some evidence of the reviewer actually having cooked from either book to illustrate his point of view. I would not have guessed before The Piglet that one of my favourite reviews would come from an American sportscaster, rather than one of the more revered chefs of my homeland. But that's the fun of it, right?

Mrs._larkin_370

about 1 year ago mrslarkin

Mrs. Larkin is a trusted source on Baking.

well said, rosalind.

Can't wait to dig into both of these great books. After taking a Look Inside on Amazon, (thank God, because there wasn't one mention in this whole review of a single recipe made) it's surprising how similar their Table of Contents are. Maybe it's The Curse of the Book Jacket.

Default-small

about 1 year ago sanfranchristo

You can reference any of the other three times that these respective finalists were reviewed in the tournament for more specific examples of content.

Mrs._larkin_370

about 1 year ago mrslarkin

Mrs. Larkin is a trusted source on Baking.

you sure can. but it'd be nice to see a side-by-side comparison in this final round of the judgement.

Img__631-1_(1)

about 1 year ago thirschfeld

I can't speak for the other judges but I cooked no less then four recipes out of each. Both are great books and while both books brought great things to the table in the end it was Bloomfield's book that captivated me.

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Associate Editor of Food52.

Thanks, Tom! And sorry for the confusion, mrslarkin, this year we did things a bit differently! Fergus's piece is meant to be focused on what makes a great cookbook in general; we thought it would be unfair for him to make a specific decision, as he has a conflict of interest with April. Enter: our fantastic final round panel, who tested the heck out of these books.

Mrs._larkin_370

about 1 year ago mrslarkin

Mrs. Larkin is a trusted source on Baking.

No worries, Kenzi! I think I got spoiled from all the amazing, and thorough, Community Pick book reviews – now those really rocked! In regards to the fuss about Fergus’s piece, perhaps it would have made things easier for folks to digest if it were titled “What Makes a Great Cookbook” instead of “The Judgement,” seeing as he did not judge either book.