The Piglet2014 / First Round, 2014

Summerland vs. Whole-Grain Mornings

Summerland

Anne Quatrano

Get the Book

Whole-Grain Mornings

Megan Gordon

Get the Book

Judged by: Christina Tosi

Christina Tosi is the chef, owner, and founder of Momofuku Milk Bar, called “one of the most exciting bakeries in the country” by Bon Appétit. As founder of the dessert program at Momofuku, Christina helped Momofuku Ko earn two Michelin stars and Momofuku Ssäm jump onto Restaurant Magazine’s top 100 restaurants in the world list. She is the 2012 recipient of the James Beard Rising Star Chef award. Christina lives in Brooklyn, NY with her three dogs and eats an unconscionable amount of raw cookie dough every day.

The Judgment

I adore and admire a good cookbook, but these days I rarely get the opportunity, or the excuse, to cook from one. As such, I hold each cookbook as a chef’s endearing, enduring story of food on their terms -- and on their turf -- more than a companion for me in my kitchen. 

I am a) in the industry and b) a New Yorker, meaning in order to learn, bond, and be inspired by another chef, I often travel to eat out at his or her restaurant. My meals at home are typically late at night and desperate, if I light the stovetop at all.

At home with my family in Virginia one Sunday, I reveled at the excuse to spread out and really dive into Megan Gordon’s West Coast-inspired Whole-Grain Mornings and Anne Stiles Quatrano’s Southern-inspired Summerland: Recipes for Celebrating with Southern Hospitality, a great adventure in both living life through each author and cooking under their guidance. 

I cannot face any morning without a strong, loving cup of coffee (it is the most important beverage of the day). And though my seeming “schtick” -- somewhat perpetuated by the media -- has been all about breakfast and its many inspirations, I eat very few, let alone cook them. That said, the 10 early morning meals a year I do prepare, I relish in. At the break of day, I cradled Whole-Grain Mornings in a large green oversized chair in my family’s warm home. Drifting through the seasonal chapters and Gordon’s path from a small bakery to a lovely cookbook, I was reminded that it is time to slow down just a little, and remember how clever, inspiring, and soul-serving a hearty breakfast can be. 

I’m a list maker, like all of the other women in my family, and off I went scribbling while flipping through Gordon’s pages. I’m always drawn to “basics” as new jumping-off points of creation and creativity in the kitchen. (At Milk Bar we have milk crumbs and cornflake crunch and cereal milk as jumping-off points.) I began to list: homemade yogurt, make-your-own signature granola, almond milk, infused honey, quinoa crunch!

My mind started to race, imagining what MY signature granola would be, and what if I made pistachio milk in place of almond milk? “I’m definitely buying gallons of honey and taking this infused honey bit to another level!” I thought. This is what sets apart cookbooks for me. The good ones give you a basic guide and an encouraging option to either follow recipes directly or use them as a kind of road map. Gordon urges you to start with her “cooking style" and to spend enough time in the kitchen to work the recipes into your own. And so I did just that. 

My granola had apricot jam, pistachios, pistachio oil, and cocoa nibs; my milk was made from roasted walnuts; and my new collection of infused honeys highlighted red onions, coriander, ginger, and smoked red pepper.

The colder months are here, after all, so I was lured into the Baked Pumpkin Risotto and Buckwheat Crêpes. Both wholesome, nurturing, and family favorites, I couldn’t help but question some of the process and technique: Why not salt the sautéed plums so they really pop with the honeyed ricotta, folded up into the Buckwheat Crêpes? Why par-cook the brown rice in the risotto only to bake it the rest of the way in the oven? Why use apple juice -- the sweeter, less seasonal version of its earthy counterpart, apple cider? 

I decided to do the dishes rather than criticize. I said goodbye to the West Coast and curled up again, this time with Summerland, taking a trip much further south than Virginia, down to Georgia. 

As I flipped through the pages, I scrunched up my nose; I cook even less larger meals for fabulous lunch and dinner guests than I do breakfast. The cookbook is gorgeous, but will I really be able to cook from it on a regular basis? “I’m trying to cook a dinner for my family, and it’s neither Valentine’s Day, nor the 4th of July, nor the perfect day for a masked tea party,” I thought. I read on. I let down my guard, and I lost myself in Quatrano’s story. 

Like Quatrano, I have my favorite seasonal produce that I go back to each year, in search of finding a new, inspired approach to cooking each one. It became clear that Quatrano has an unbelievable knack for both setting the table and filling the table, the key balance to festive and true hospitality. There is a seriousness-when-it-counts vibe to her food, and a take-your-shoes-off-and-grab-a-mint-julep-by-the-old-red-barn vibe that leaves me wishing that I were the next generation of lineage to receive her magnificent family farm.

I skipped through the suburban grocery store parking lot to gather ingredients for Roasted Brussels Sprouts, Sweet Potato Purée, Pea and Fennel Salad, Italian Wedding Soup, and Thyme Onion Rolls. I held my shopping basket sweetly under my bent forearm as though I was off to gather fresh eggs from the coop and pick vegetables from the garden. 

Though Quatrano has arranged her recipes in a planned menu format, each dish can easily be plucked, prepared, and placed on the daily dinner table. Her cooking style and process clearly balances the home cook in her with her many accomplished years as a restaurateur and chef. The Brussels sprouts were simple yet cleverly instructed, hard-roasted in the pan before finishing in the oven. The pea salad was bitey, fresh, and new with fennel juice and shallots as the stars of the vinaigrette. Generous amounts of caramelized onions, thyme, and honey catapulted the Thyme Onion Rolls into the realm of otherworldliness.

She’s got the “basics” too: homemade mayo, buttermilk biscuits, broccoli stock, and yes, even granola. Did I mention Quatrano is almost as crazy about furry four-legged family members as I am? Only her quirk extends beyond mine -- she vrooms around in a golf cart on the farm, and has dreams of taking her airstream trailer on the road.

Though I sometimes daydream that I’m a calm and peaceful West Coast gal, and Gordon certainly makes me want to be a better, most-important-meal-of-the-day, whole-grain woman, Quatrano reminds me that I am who I am -- a far more Southern spirit, a crazy dog lady, and one who, with or without rules or planned menus, cooks to transport, cooks to unite, cooks to share, cooks to nourish, and cooks to celebrate a big event or a simple meal at home. And that’s the power of a great cookbook.

 

And the winner is…

Summerland: Recipes for Celebrating with Southern Hospitality

Summerland: Recipes for Celebrating with Southern Hospitality

Get the Book

Do you Agree?

91 Comments

Naomi M. February 28, 2014
Beautifully written review! I have heard of Whole-Grain Mornings but have never found a copy to take a peek at it! But both sound like very lovely books indeed, and Summerland will be on my short list!
 
erinsk February 27, 2014
Sounds like two more for the library list! The idea of recipes that are easy to make your own is appealing to me, so I'll definitely look forward to Whole Grain Mornings.
 
Bob M. February 26, 2014
Anne Q is a big spirit and I can't wait to put "Summerland" to work in my kitchen.
 
sandriavdh February 21, 2014
Thanks for the great review. It made me want to rush out to purchase Summerland and host a fabulous dinner party!
 
Sara H. February 19, 2014
I was given Summerland for Christmas this year and cracked it open finally on Valentines. Well, it's STILL on the counter and I've made three other recipes from it. It's actually more than just a visual stunner, truly terrific recipes. The writing just makes me want to cook them more! I live in Atlanta so I'm lucky enough to know what a great restaurateur Ms. Quatrano is.
 
beejay45 February 18, 2014
I love the whole grains idea. I grew up with that stuff, not to extremes, but it was as common to find brown rice on the table as white, and my grandmother made whole grain breads several times a week. But I do like the sound of that pea and fennel salad! They both sound like go to books, depending on the mood you're in.

Props to Christina for giving a feel for the style of both books before making her decision and admitting it's because Summerland is more like what she, herself, is about. Very fair.
 
Elveenah February 18, 2014
I respectfully disagree this time with the judgement. From the review, I favored Whole Grain Mornings. Perhaps because I am a West Coast girl? :). I guess I'll have to find out when I actually look at the book!
 
Melina H. February 16, 2014
Thank you for taking me on an adventure through your writing, C. I love the visuals you sparked as I pondered further "who could have won?" Gives me more insight to your lovely way, as well as those of each these talented authors.
 
twinjadojo February 15, 2014
Wonderful reviews, and I appreciate your thoughtful criticism of Whole Grain Mornings. I depend on my cookbooks to promise aspirational flavour results, leaving me the flexibility to tone it down with what's on hand or for the palate of my diners. I have been disappointed in the past with cookbooks that leave me wanting more, though they teach in their own way by inspiring augmentation.
 
Megan February 15, 2014
Whole grain morning still sounds like a great cookbook.
 
Effie February 15, 2014
So glad Summerland is a contender. I'm a huge fan of Anne's restaurants and pay weekly visits to Star Provisions, her gourmet market. I bought the book upon publication. It's beautiful and lures me to the kitchen to cook.
 
Muttersome February 15, 2014
Both books sounds great, but I can't wait to read Summerland now! Those gorgeous tomatoes....
 
Laura February 14, 2014
Summerland really appeals to me the most - I can't wait to get my hands on that book!
 
lisabu February 14, 2014
Christina Tosi you are on my mind! I made your cereal milk panna cotta last night for a friend whose favorite cereal is Golden Grahams...Delicious with your crunch made with the Golden Grahams also. I actually got a "shut the F- up" from one of the guests...Best compliment ever!!
 
Ashley February 14, 2014
Both sound interesting and seem reflective of the writers location.
 
Jen B. February 14, 2014
The way Tosi described Whole Grain Mornings, I really expected it to win! I'll have to check it out.
 
aargersi February 14, 2014
covet Summerland. A. Lot.
 
Allison M. February 14, 2014
Excellent review! Christina Tosi got me so excited about Whole Grain Mornings that I was surprised when Summerland won. I think both cookbooks look excellent and worth exploring; however, I think I would choose to start with Whole Grain Mornings. Breakfast for dinner in my house!
 
mcs3000 February 14, 2014
Beautiful review by Christina Tosi. Excited to check out Summerland. That said, I'm biased and wanted Whole Grain Mornings to win. It's been fun to see Megan's career takeoff with Marge Granola and her new book. Congrats to all Piglets!
 
Jenali February 13, 2014
Reading this review makes me want to check out Summerland. I was unfamiliar with this cookbook until now.
 
foodynewty February 13, 2014
oh! p.s....if only I could get you to sign mine?!?
 
Michael H. February 15, 2014
You can buy a signed copy of Summerland here!

http://food52.com/provisions/products/699-summerland-signed-cookbook
 
foodynewty February 13, 2014
Go Summerland! Rooting for you Anne. Having been lucky enough to be at Ms. Quatrano's farm table, I can say that, yes, no one "sets the table and fills the table with hospitality" better than Chef Anne. And a gorgeous book too!
 
Amy S. February 13, 2014
I would love them both. A little bias toward whole grain morning because well, Clare Barboza had a hand in the magic. She was the photographer. Also..kinda love breakfasty whole grain stuff. Then again, I would love them both and who wouldn't I love books as though they were my babies. Please and thank you kindly.
 
theatrelion February 13, 2014
Summerland definitely sounds like a cookbook I'd get a lot of use out of, I adore Southern-style cooking!
 
JadeTree February 13, 2014
As a Southerner, I'm always wary of "Southern" cookbooks (are they drinking nothing but sweet tea? Are they craaaaaaaaaazy?) but this one sounds delightful. charm and quirk with actual intriguing recipes, not just Karo syrup. Clearly, I need it!
 
fiveandspice February 13, 2014
Wonderful review! Now I want both books.
 
Sheli H. February 13, 2014
They are both gorgeous! Must get them!
 
Christine February 13, 2014
Both sound great, but the cover on and Ms. Tosi's description of the winner are enough to send me hunting for it.
 
topdawg11 February 13, 2014
If someone in the industry questions the processes and techniques, a home cook like me is grateful for her honesty in her reviews.
 
petitbleu February 13, 2014
Good review, although I question whether putting two cookbooks focusing on completely different subjects and themes is fair. It seems like pairing two cookbooks on similar or at least parallel themes would make for a better comparison. I'm also not convinced that this is an East-Coast-West-Coast dichotomy. One book focuses on whole grain breakfast foods and the other is about loosely interpreted southern food. Both look lovely and sound appealing, but they're so dissimilar that I can't really get behind the review process. I'll probably just wind up getting both books and seeing for myself!
 
lazyliger February 13, 2014
I'll say "yes, please" to both of them. Thank you ;)
 
Lexi February 13, 2014
love the look of whole grain mornings!
 
EmFraiche February 13, 2014
Great review! Interesting to read about different takes on food from different parts of the country.
 
Lia S. February 13, 2014
I love the story and the uniqueness of the recipes of Summerland but I think I'd actually try more of the recipes in Whole Grain Mornings. I also love the creativity that is encouraged with Whole Grain Mornings.
 
CaseyAnne February 13, 2014
I just want them both!
 
Haley M. February 13, 2014
I love that she took the time to look over both to decide what was best. I always have to really look through a cookbook to decide if I'll use most of the recipes. Good job! What a fun post!
 
LittleFrier February 13, 2014
Good review. Well written and enjoyable.
 
Brianna P. February 13, 2014
While both books have great recipes and stunning photos, I totally agree with this decision. Maybe it's because I'm not an elaborate breakfast gal, but Summerland has been on my radar for a while, so I'm excited it won this round!
 
QueenOfGreen February 13, 2014
I generally love reading the judges comments, and in this case too will take her word for it!
 
jamcook February 13, 2014
I am definitely a breakfast person 3 meals a day, but have read neither cookbook. What I do appreciate this year is that both judges have thoroughly read and cooked from both selections, and have made informed choices. this was not always the case in past years...especially the fashionista who didn't cook and chose on the basis of photos .
 
Elaine February 13, 2014
I loved Christina's views and wholeheartedly agree. Summerland seems like an excellent choice.
 
jenna_lee February 13, 2014
Having Christina Tosi's Milk Bar cookbook, I was very interested to hear her perspective on these very different cookbooks. I appreciate her openness and honesty in reviewing both. I had not much of Summerland prior to this so I am definitely interested in checking it out!
 
AntoniaJames February 13, 2014
Very well written; I understand and appreciate the judge's decision, though I would have gone the other way. I've lived on the West Coast for almost thirty years, transplanted from the great Commonwealth of Virginia. I feel a much greater affinity to Megan Gordon than to either the judge or to Anne Quatrano, for a variety of reasons that I shall not get into here. The judgment informs and allows for a considered appreciation of each of the books. I'll be buying and using "Morning Grains," for sure.
That said, I am grateful for the care and thoughtfulness with which Ms. Tosi tested both selections, and drafted the judgment. ;o)
 
Shikha K. February 13, 2014
For personal reasons, I would go with Whole Grain Mornings. When I first started as a pastry intern, I was almost immediately introduced to every grain except for flour. Buckwheat cookies, kamut tart crusts, everything took on another flavor with the addition of whole grains. It's influenced my pastry style ever since and I am always looking for ways to incorporate these grains into everything I eat!
 
Charlotte D. February 13, 2014
Definitely trust Tosi's opinion but both cookbooks look great!
 
BakerK February 13, 2014
I love Whole Grain Mornings, so I have to admit I'm a little disappointed she didn't win this round. But, now I have another cookbook to consider for my collection. Great review.
 
Sarah G. February 13, 2014
I've always been intrigued by Southern cooking, growing up on the West Coast. I think Summerland would be my more challenging book.
 
Hannah R. February 13, 2014
Very much leaned in the other direction. Gordon's recipes are inspiring and forward thinking- they get one excited about the possibilities of whole grains and simple but epiphanal food.
 
Tery February 13, 2014
I am a very big Tosi fan, so I trust her opinion. Having never read both, I look forward to looking into them, especially Summerland.
 
Jassy February 13, 2014
great review!
 
Risa February 13, 2014
Even though they're both lovely, I have to say I was leaning in the other direction. Two tough competitors though!
 
LuLuLa February 13, 2014
Anne Quatrano is an amazing chef (dining in her restaurants is always a transporting experience); it's no wonder her book won this round. But it doesn't really seem a fair match-up, since Whole Grain Mornings has a completely different concept and design. I'd try them both!
 
Diana February 13, 2014
Summerland sounds like one I need to add to my collection!
 
claradelune February 13, 2014
Really enjoyed Christina Tosi's thoughtful review. Can't wait to try the recipes in both books!
 
Taylor R. February 13, 2014
I rarely eat breakfast, but I love it as a concept. I would probably use Summerland much more, but I am far more intrigued by Whole Grain Mornings.
 
maryjo February 13, 2014
I'm now totally intrigued by summerland
 
Diane S. February 13, 2014
I can't wait to get Summerland after this thoughtful review!
 
Michelle F. February 13, 2014
This cookbook is going on my wishlist for sure! thank you for posting such a great review!
 
Andrea M. February 13, 2014
Being from the South and respecting Christina Tosi, I agree with her decision.
 
Amanda M. February 13, 2014
I confess, my breakfasts are usually limited to smoothies or some homemade granola thrown in a mason jar and taken to work, but there's nary a food blogger in sight who hasn't given Whole Grain Mornings a raving review. I love how Christina takes the opportunity to allow Megan's recipes and concepts to transport her to places breakfast doesn't usually take her. I found that very inspirational, and am looking forward to imbuing a bit more of an adventurous spirit into the first meal of my day as well!
 
Rinchen February 13, 2014
Thoughtful review. Unlike reviewers of novels, you got to experience the books. Regional cooking reigns!
 
Tina F. February 13, 2014
I want both!
 
aecummingsII February 13, 2014
It occurs to me that I failed to mention that I already have Megan's Whole Grain Mornings. I didn't want to appear as though I had been reasoned out of it when actually I will Have them Both!
 
Bonkboo February 13, 2014
Nice review and I agree with the outcome.
 
Helen B. February 13, 2014
Christina: not only are you an accomplished pastry chef, but a superb reviewer and writer as well. Gave a great sense of what the books are about.
 
Mindy K. February 13, 2014
Both sound like lovely cookbooks for different reasons. Admit to simply being drawn to the title "Summerland" (and the cover photo), though, with currently more than a foot of snow blanketing everything around here!
 
Jdrd233 February 13, 2014
They both look and sound scrumptious !
 
holly February 13, 2014
Tosi illustrates a beautiful explanation of both books. Both cookbooks look lovely, works of art as well as roadmaps in the kitchen. As an Italian baker with an enormous sweet tooth, I have always been fond of dessert, breakfast, and anything else that can satisfy a sweet craving. Growing up, I remember a few occasions in which my older sister and I advocated for breakfast foods at supper time. Getting to be part of the process at such a young age, flipping pancakes or cooking up a citrus curd to fill fresh-from-the-skillet crepes became a highlight for me, and inspired me to continue practicing the art of food. I mastered crepe making, over the years, after being the designated crepe-maker for Mothers Day and Fathers Day, and every slumber party visit with my Sicilian grandmother ended with pancake making in the morning, which I cherished oh-so-much. In summary, I may be a bit biased in this review, as there is a place in my heart for breakfast which, for me, is tied to family and good memories, thus leading me to reach for the whole grain mornings.
 
love2cook February 13, 2014
Simply looking at the cover of Summerland as I sit here with over a foot of snow on the ground and more falling made me want to dive into it! Reading the review settled it for me--that's the one I want to try.
 
healthierkitchen February 13, 2014
Beautifully written!!
 
aecummingsII February 13, 2014
I jumped right into the Whole Grain Breakfast cookbook starting with the Pear-Hazelnut Oat Muffins and the Salmon and Creme Fraiche Tart and both were great. We are absolutely breakfast
mongers around here and everything about Megan's book is
wonderful. That being said I am a Southerner and can relate to
coking for gatherings and events;specifically Sundays and the Forth of July. Your review has prompted me to run out and buy Summerland!
 
luvcookbooks February 13, 2014
The sad thing for my husband about this well written review is that I want both books.
 
Suzanne N. February 13, 2014
i will be checking out both books! nice reviews.
 
The C. February 13, 2014
Love Megan and her website. I need to try her granola! And while I'm a PNW girl by birth, I'm in Texas now...so I find myself agreeing with Christina.

Nice. Really enjoyed this one.
 
Jenalle February 13, 2014
Thank you for this review! I think you really summarized and highlighted the intentions of the authors when writing these books, despite your own concerns regarding integrating their work into your own cooking habits. I also think you nailed it when you said a cookbook that resonates with you is one that creates a platform to then expand on for yourself. This is how you create comfortable cooks in their own home - not just by simply having readers follow a recipe. Great job.
 
Kendra February 13, 2014
This review made me want to cook from BOTH cookbooks WITH Christina herself. Ideally with a slice of crack pie.
 
fariha February 13, 2014
This is a fabulous review! hadn't heard of summerland yet, but this definitely makes me want to crack it open and take a look.
 
Barbara M. February 13, 2014
Summerland!
 
Joan O. February 13, 2014
I so enjoyed this review. I felt like I was with the judge while she shared her diving into each cookbook first reading, making a list, and then, shoping and cooking. That's the way I usually devour a cookbook for the first time as well. Although Whole Grain Mornings sounds like a fun book, being a southern gal I was rooting for Summerland even though I haven't had a chance to take a peek at it yet. It has now moved to the top of my wish list. I'm so enjoying the piglet this year and looking forward to the next head to head.
 
Jessica M. February 13, 2014
Breakfast is my eternal love but in this nyc snow blur I'm ready for Summerland!
 
kgmom February 13, 2014
Trying to develop a healthy breakfast habit. I'd love to have Megan Gordon's whole Grain Mornings. Thanks for the reviews!
 
xuedanw February 13, 2014
I'm intrigued by Summerland. This is the first I've seen or heard of it, but I have seen Gordon's book all over the webs. I am on a spree to learn more about Southern cooking and Christina Tosi has sold me.
 
Teruska February 13, 2014
Breakfast is the most important meal of the day ~ or so I've been told.
 
Tiffany February 13, 2014
Great review, sounds like an overall great cookbook.
 
Naomi E. February 13, 2014
I love Megan Gordon's blog - looking forward to getting the cookbook! As a West Coast girl who loves breakfast, that would probably be my pick!
 
drbabs February 13, 2014
Another wonderful review, and thank you, Christina Tosi, for actually using and cooking from the cookbooks.
 
Ayarir February 13, 2014
Nice description of the recipes. I love cooking books with lots of pictures. :)
 
Ileana M. February 13, 2014
I really enjoyed this very personal review. And what a gorgeous book cover. I miss tomatoes.
 
Catherine L. February 13, 2014
I love Summerland! Atlanta, represent.
 
The F. February 13, 2014
Great review!