Popular on Food52
37 Comments
Thomas K.
February 4, 2016
Sorry but you cater to the east coast of the Hudson River and disregard what is here on the west coast of the Hudson River except hiking trails there are plenty of other restaurants here in Orange County and Rockland County and Ulster county that rivals that of Westchester County, Putnam County and Duchess county.
Tania P.
February 1, 2016
Keegan Ales Beer ROCKS!!!! sorry for anyone's loss of one of the top award winning craft beers in the country!
Linda
October 22, 2015
I grew up in Newburgh New York, just across the Hudson from Beacon. In those days there was no bridge; we had to take a ferry to get to the other side. Back then Newburgh was a magical place to grow up. Small town values, beautiful neighborhoods, great schools and easy access to all that New York City had to offer. I'm very happy living in Southern California but I do miss the beauty of the Hudson Valley, especially in the fall.
lunule
October 22, 2015
Who knew the Hudson Valley was so controversial! ; )
Thanks for the list Samantha and everyone's additional suggestions. Your piece is so timely because we are new to the area and planning a fall getaway. We were thinking of Rhinebeck but some of the places that you mentioned also sound great. Keep the suggestions coming!
Thanks for the list Samantha and everyone's additional suggestions. Your piece is so timely because we are new to the area and planning a fall getaway. We were thinking of Rhinebeck but some of the places that you mentioned also sound great. Keep the suggestions coming!
gardeningal
September 23, 2015
We would always go "upstate" from L.I. for hiking. But to visit Kingston, you have to go to THE steakhouse: Rudigans. We found it by accident one year...it's been a while since we've been there. Hope it's still nice.
Linda C.
September 23, 2015
Deborah, I know how you feel. I live in Florida and it has been ruined by people flocking here to enjoy the way life "use to be"
Deborah
September 23, 2015
I'd tell you about the amazing place I live in the Hudson Valley, but then Brooklynites might start coming here in droves, and while that might be good for the economy temporarily, in the longer term it drives up prices of real estate and at local stores for locals, driving out the longtime local businesses (a beloved cafe in my village just closed for this very reason). It means more traffic on roads where we used to joke that the only traffic jams were caused by slow tractors or cow crossings. It means weekenders buying homes that once were owned by families who sent their children to our public school.
Deborah
September 23, 2015
All that being said, we're pretty awesome, and when visitors respect that we're an actual community, not just a playground, we love you and appreciate you. We have a film festival in a 1920s era theater, an outdoor dance venue, a nearby sculpture park, several excellent restaurants and bars, a brewery, family farms, places to buy local food, and a strong sense of community.
Sally S.
September 7, 2015
This is a PR job. 'round and "round we go stopping at the same places written for different articles pushed by the PR firms hired by the same places. For example go to the neighborhood page at Graham and Co in Phoenicia and compare it to this article. Same. Peekamoose FED article lists the same places in Phoenicia and Kingston. Get REAL!
Cipriana C.
September 7, 2015
I'm sorry but, the restaurants listed for Kingston are obscure! I live there and have never even heard of them. Like, what about Dallas, Broadway Lights, any Guido Establishment, Tony's (or any decent pizza spot), Mickey's...?
Jack
September 6, 2015
I'm with Amy Daidone on this one. This article, like almost every other in these tres hip blogs, is 100% Brooklynite clickbait. Almost every establishment you mention is founded run by Brooklyn gentrifiers with the express purpose of luring up monied Brooklynites for an "authentic" Hudson Valley experience. I also enjoyed the wary reference to Kingston's "scrappy"-ness. For those of you not fluent in Brooklyn gentrifier euphemisms, scrappy means "black." I liked Janis Borgueta's comment about the City of Newburgh. Sorry to break the news Janis, but Newburgh is likely a bit to "scrappy" for the author's taste.
Suzanne B.
September 6, 2015
Another really neat place to visit in Saugerties is The Catskill Animal Sanctuary.
Andy N.
September 6, 2015
Phoenicia Diner is a scam. Big city bullshit. Far from an authentic Catskills experience. Take it from a native.
btglenn
September 6, 2015
Why no mention of the great Storm King Sculpture Museum south of Newburgh. Its rolling hillsides contain wonderful sculptures and also has a picnic site for those who prepare their own outdoor feasts. There is also an indoor museum for smaller works.
Amy D.
September 5, 2015
The Woodstock Farm Animal Sanctuary has recently moved to High Falls, which is about 30 minutes South of Woodstock. In fact today is opening day for them there
shannon
September 4, 2015
Just outside of Phoenicia is a cute place that never disappoints. Catskill Rose has the best food that we never miss going to when we are in the area. Why does it seem like the places mentioned are always mentioned? Go forth and explore!
Homer &.
September 4, 2015
If you're headed to Phoenicia, stop by and say hi to us at Mystery Spot Antiques on Main Street! (You can find us by the 14-foot tall statue of Davy Crockett out front). We've got seven rooms of antiques, records, vintage clothing and plenty of oddities to entertain the kids.
Sarah
September 4, 2015
We have a home in Phoenicia, and some of our favorites include dinner at Tavern 214, amazing pizza at Brio's, brunch at Zephyr in Pine Hill [about 11 miles down the road], and a sandwich to go made by Margaret at The Phoenicia Deli [hint - get the roast beef that is made in-house]!
Samantha W.
September 4, 2015
Wow, I want that roast beef sandwich right now! Thanks for these great recommendations!
Marybeth M.
September 4, 2015
Worth noting that two establishments mentioned above have been closed for some time. Sweet Sue's and Woodstock Farm Sanctuary. (Phoenicia). But absolutely still worth a visit to our town!
Samantha W.
September 4, 2015
Thanks for spotting that about Sweet Sue's -- it's been a while since I've been back. Sad to hear about it closing.
Actually the farm sanctuary is reopening tomorrow! http://woodstocksanctuary.org/about/move
Actually the farm sanctuary is reopening tomorrow! http://woodstocksanctuary.org/about/move
Samantha W.
September 4, 2015
And I'd love to know your favorite places in Phoenicia if they weren't mentioned! It's such a wonderful, calming place.
Molly
September 4, 2015
Including Kingston on this list was a good idea, but maybe doing a little further research into the "Do" portion would have been smart as well. Telling someone to visit a town, but then telling them to go somewhere else to "do" something seems ridiculous.
Cipriana C.
September 7, 2015
EXACTLY. Also, the restaurants were obscure! I live there and have never even heard of them. Like, what about Dallas, Broadway Lights, any Guido Establishment, Tony's (or any decent pizza spot), Mickey's...?
See what other Food52 readers are saying.