Popular on Food52
21 Comments
h.mountainwall
May 22, 2018
Well...I am saddened by the phrase “cultural appropriation,” which seems to me a specious stance here. While we, as Americans immersed in what can be legitimately called “American culture,” acknowledge the contributions of all the glorious ethnicities that inform our lives here, we are talking about food here. I suspect anything and everything may be labeled “cultural appropriation,” if we are implying “theft” of the originating culture. But, why would you do that? How rich our American experience is because of the contributions of so many who have brought their traditions with them. And, are we so curmudgeonly and desirous of dissent now that we have lost sight of the fact that food is intended to delight? Maybe there are more heinous crimes to be called out than the application of a bread-making technique. If we are being accurate, by the way, almost all cultures have a similar flatbread tradition. Maybe we can simply feast, and take a break from accusing each other of empty offenses?
Colleen
June 27, 2018
Taking a recipe from another culture, renaming it, and pretending that it's in some way original is cultural appropriation. If the author had done more research, acknowledged the origins of the recipe (or even just that many different cultures have versions of this recipe), and called it by its correct name, we wouldn't be having this conversation. I'm not trying to put the author down - or anyone else for that matter - but when we borrow things from other cultures, it's our responsibility to learn something about them, too. It's not about being "PC" or liberal or whatever; it's about being respectful of others. If someone took your grandmother's famous apple pie recipe, called it something else, and pretended it was wholly original, I'm guessing you wouldn't be too pleased. Again, it's just about respect.
Jusika
May 22, 2018
All that build-up to talk about roti. Would have been nice if the article actually acknowledged that this is a form of roti. Would have been nicer if the author had researched a bit to see that roti is a staple of the Indian subcontinent. Feels like cultural appropriation to me.
I remember another article by this same author on non-gmo tearless onions which too seemed a little quick on the trigger.
I remember another article by this same author on non-gmo tearless onions which too seemed a little quick on the trigger.
FS
May 22, 2018
While these breads may be very similar to roti, not every reader may be familiar with roti. Introducing readers to a new recipe isn't cultural appropriation just because it resembles an existing recipe.
Valerio F.
May 22, 2018
You're right, there is a bit (a lot!) of a roti vibe going on here. In fact, when I made them for my coworkers, the roti comparison was one of the first things that came up! Thanks so much for pointing that out.
FS
May 20, 2018
I'll add some salt to the flour before assembling this dough. Don't care much for the bland flour-y flavor of unseasoned bread.
Jane D.
May 20, 2018
"this here operation"??
i was taught at three years old that "this here" is incorrect!
have all proofreaders and editors been fired? smdh!
nice roti recipe, thank you...
i was taught at three years old that "this here" is incorrect!
have all proofreaders and editors been fired? smdh!
nice roti recipe, thank you...
Valerio F.
May 22, 2018
Grammar is boring! I tend to play around with it for funnier verbal constructions. You're totally right though, "this here" is technically not correct, but sometimes it's fun to mess around with language! Otherwise, we'd all be speaking the same! Glad you enjoyed the recipe!
Joycelyn
May 20, 2018
Wondering why you'd not add a pinch or so of salt to the flour first? Sprinkling salt over the flat bread/roti once it's in the oily pan could easily cause over salting depending on what kind of salt the cook might be using not to mention if a salt shaker or hand sprinkle was used.
Valerio F.
May 22, 2018
The dough could totally use some salt. Sometimes I add it, sometimes I don't, depending on my mood. Good catch!
BakerMary
May 20, 2018
That link for the salt speckled tuna and tomato sauce? Didn’t see tuna when I went there.
Chad C.
May 17, 2018
I can't believe you just spent that many words on saying mix flour and water into a glop and you've got cave person bread! Ill be sure to stay tuned for other great recipes like "frozen peas but warmer" and "water with a twist! (Adding lime)". O yes, by the way, I'm channeling my best self, thanks.
Valerio F.
May 17, 2018
I agree! I couldn't believe how easy these are to make either. Sometimes the simplest things are truly the best... Like this recipe for peas and milk:
https://food52.com/recipes/11802-milk-peas
https://food52.com/recipes/11802-milk-peas
Join The Conversation