Meat

The Absolute Best Cut of Meat to Grill, According to a Butcher

August 22, 2018

Labor Day is but a blink away. Oh, didn't you hear? The proverbial "end of summer" is fast approaching. I'm from Texas, so I've never really bought into the whole "summer is over" deal. Where I'm from, we've got at least two more months of 80+ degree weather. Still, this final hurrah is a nice chance to get outdoors, gather friends and, should you feel so inclined, fire up that grill. We've spent the past few months dreaming up the best foods to toss on that outside furnace.

But what about meat? Grilling meat can be daunting, even if you do it every summer. As we all get ready for the upcoming holiday weekend, I thought it'd be nice to get some tips from a pro. I reached out to Frankie from Ottomanelli Brothers, a New York City–based butchery, to find out the absolute best cuts of meat we should be grilling—before it's too late.

For a little background, the Ottomanelli family has been in business since 1900 (!) getting New Yorkers all the cuts of meat they want. Summer, what with all those grills on the loose, is a particularly busy season. I for one am partial to the simplicity of a burger, but after a quick convo, Frankie started to convince me otherwise. Maybe grilling a nice steak doesn't have to be as complex as I previously thought:

"I like to take all of my steaks out of the fridge an hour before I cook them and let them get to room temperature," he tells me over the phone. "If you take them out of the fridge, they lose some of that moisture from sitting in the fridge. Then, I like to season simply with Kosher salt and pepper."

Now we're talking. Like Frankie, I tend to lean toward simpler recipes, preparations that are clean rather than complex. But that doesn't have to be the case. Every now and then there's the chance for a marinade or a grilled steak sandwich. Here are two of my favorites:

As for cuts of meat, Frankie recommends a few go-tos when feeding a large crowd: sirloin, flank, or even skirt steak should do the trick. Those are all pretty simple and take well to the grill's smoky treatment. Plus, they err on the side of affordable, so you can keep a whole crowd fed without worrying about the old wallet.

So, what's the best cut of meat?

"I’d say a nice porterhouse," Frankie says. "You get the best of both worlds: a piece of filet and a nice strip steak all together. You have a bone that gives you nice flavor as well."

What's YOUR favorite meat to grill? Tell us in the comments below.


here, try this

Order Now

Any Night Grilling is your guide to becoming a charcoal champion (or getting in your grill-pan groove), any night of the week. With over 60 ways to fire up dinner—no long marinades or low-and-slow cook times in sight—this book is your go-to for freshly grilled meals in a flash.

Order Now

86 Comments

Karin B. October 4, 2018
I think a nice thick rib eye with all the fat is best. I eat it medium rare from the outside in until I get to the lean center which I save to have on a lad sliced very thin.
 
Karin B. October 8, 2018
I meant to say "salad"
 
Michael C. August 31, 2018
Petite Tender sounds like an overpriced small filet to me.
 
Barb September 2, 2018
I'm a small woman, I can't tell you how often (yes I can, every single time) I wish restaurants would offer a 6 oz steak, so I can only take home half my dinner.
 
R C. September 5, 2018
Actually you can google it, it is above the front shoulders, muscle that does not get used a lot, about 9-11" long, 10-11" diameter. here are utube links to cut it, but still cannot find anyone to do it properly... <br />https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcIz8kCmNho<br />https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9bsDxVXXFg<br />Underpriced better than filet if u can find a butcher.....
 
R C. August 31, 2018
We used to get a cut called Petite Tender when we lived in BVI (oddly an island with no cows) however pricey, it was excellent. Since we returned home (California) cannot seem to find butchers who know how to cut it. Help?
 
Nan G. August 31, 2018
Filet Mignon. I buy whole filets from a restaurant supply market. Cut it THICK. then often stuff it before grilling. (Roquefort cheese)<br />I like a coffee-based dry rub on it. <br />A neutral wood like oak or apple.
 
Michael C. August 31, 2018
Great point Stephen, you must get the chill off of meat when cooking or any protein for that matter. If you do not, the outside will burn up before the inside warms up. Ya gotta get the chill off.
 
Smaug August 31, 2018
Depends a lot on the room- my kitchen is apt to be 95 degrees in the summer and things warm up pretty quickly, especially if you put them in front of a fan.
 
Stephen S. August 31, 2018
I keep reading that you should take steak out of the fridge for an hour so it gets to room temperature. But unless it's a paper thin cut, it needs much longer than an hour. Stick a thermometer in when you take it out and see for yourselves.
 
Jaye B. August 31, 2018
Any conversation about "best" steaks, or any meats, needs to consider what is sold in different parts of the country. When I moved out West from the Midwest, I had to re-learn much of what I knew about meats because cuts I was familiar with either have different names or are not available at all. Sirloins here are not like sirloins in Chicago. Yes, there are some of the same cuts like T-bones and Porterhouse and Ribeye, but many other cuts are different. It took me awhile to find simple ground beef that tasted right. This goes for pork, too. There are regional differences in butchering that make blanket recommendations a bit iffy. Also, supermarkets hardly ever butcher their own meats - most of it comes from mass producers and that creates geographic differences. Costco is probably one source that has continuity, but there you have to buy quantity which doesn't always work, at least for me because I never buy fresh meat and then freeze it at home because I assume it was already frozen once for the transportation process. I have yet to find a good way to prepare Tri-Tip here!
 
Hank A. August 31, 2018
Low and slow at 225F, hits 130-135F pull it, if not 125F ... you'll have the small end Well, and the rest Med at most. Salt & Pepper and maybe a bit of Garlic Powder.
 
Buddy S. August 31, 2018
A simple method of coarse salt and fresh coarsely ground pepper, sear it over a bed of HOT mesquite and finish to your liking over indirect heat. I go for 140 - 145 F and tent it for 10 - 15 minutes before slicing. Perfect for our local, grass fed beef.
 
tamater S. August 31, 2018
I know what you mean. My parents regularly served what they called London Broil, but I have yet to see it on the west coast.
 
DMStenlake August 31, 2018
Check with the butcher but I think it’s called top round. We like to grill this one med rare simple s and p enjoy
 
Jaye B. August 31, 2018
Tamater - skirt steak where I live is often called "flap meat" steak so it's possible London Broil is called something else out here. I don't understand why these discrepancies exist.
 
DMStenlake August 31, 2018
Thank you for your comments. Although we eat red meats only on occasion We’re trying to make sense of the discrepancies as well. We have real butchers st our local market and it’s always interesting to have these types of discussions with them. So we’re checking with them. Also, tri-tip low and slow! Mooo 🐄 (thats a milk cow!)
 
Barb September 2, 2018
London Broil is a recipe, not a steak. At least, that's what I keep reading.
 
Jaye B. September 2, 2018
In the Chicago area, certain cuts of beef are labeled London Broil. Doesn't look like a steak, more like a small roast.
 
tamater S. September 3, 2018
Maybe it's both, depending upon where you live. I know my parents would order it as a certain cut, and then they'd do it different ways, (but I don't remember them broiling it!).
 
Smaug September 3, 2018
London broil is a method of cooking, but butchers on the west coast generally label thick cuts of top round as London Broil, much as they label similarly cut hunks of chuck as pot roast, although you can pot roast all kinds of cuts. Including "London broil".
 
tamater S. August 31, 2018
"a nice porterhouse," ? - Ok, but first, I'll have to take out a 2nd mortgage on my house.
 
Mark W. August 31, 2018
I still love a really good skirt steak, it takes to the grill like a brother and is a flexible meal served as either fajitas or as a steak smothered in onions and a multitude of peppers...
 
Hank A. August 31, 2018
Tri-Tip, hands down, and I'm not from California!!
 
Michael C. August 31, 2018
Does it have to be beef? If not, have your butcher cut a two inch steak off a pork shoulder. So inexpensive, but flavor to excess and VERY INEXPENSIVE.
 
Abyforce August 31, 2018
Yes the muscle used for cappacollo is excellent on the grill and a contender.
 
tamater S. August 31, 2018
I'm with you on this one, Michael.
 
Anastasia August 31, 2018
I’ve been wanting to try this, but am intimidated by the tough cut. I’ve only ever cooked it low and slow for pulled pork or carnitas. Any advice to move me past my fear and into successful action with a pork shoulder steak?
 
Abyforce August 31, 2018
Some parts of the long shoulder or pork butt or sometimes called the money muscle are delicious as steaks. Ask your local butcher for help with this.
 
Jaye B. August 31, 2018
Pork shoulder steaks are great from the grill, especially served with zucchini & onions that have been dabbed with diluted barbeque sauce.
 
Mary L. August 31, 2018
I like a ribeye, medium rare, just salt and pepper, sliced thin
 
Fran M. August 27, 2018
My favorite is tenderloin little salt and caramelized in a pan with a little olive oil then I finish it in the oven. Tender & delicious.
 
sarah August 27, 2018
Our favorite cut is a 2 inch porterhouse. We have the butcher leave the fat as that adds flavor. A quick coating of olive oil, a nice dose of salt and pepper, and then onto the grill. Cooking it to medium rare to rare and then letting it sit before slicing. After it's plated another drizzle of olive oil is all that it needs.
 
ArcticChar August 26, 2018
I WAS a diehard skirt steak griller until I moved to Alaska where finding skirt steak is a challenge. Now my go to griller is ribeyes for small get together or Tri-Tip for a crowd.
 
Abyforce August 26, 2018
As football season begins I've decided to draft on my team the best players. At quarterback bone in Ribeye, at running back Coulotte, tightend Tritip, wide receiver NY Strip and my entire offensive line...Flatirons. Feeling confident on the grill field.
 
William G. August 26, 2018
The team must be the Memphis Meateaters or the Charlotte Carnivores...lmao
 
Smaug August 25, 2018
Anyone have any idea what that "moisture from sitting in the frig" comment is about? Unless you like half raw meat- which many do- it's best to avoid bone in cuts- the bones serve as a heat sink and the meat near them never really gets done.
 
Teri D. August 31, 2018
If you are eating "done" steak.....shame on you. That's a waste of good meat. <br /><br />Give me a steak that doesn't moo and I don't have to chase...seared on the outside, warm, red and juicy on the inside.
 
Smaug August 31, 2018
I'm really not ashamed for not sharing your prejudices.
 
tamater S. August 31, 2018
"shame on you" + "a waste of good meat" - Really? Judge much? Growing up, Dad cooked each steak to order, and when new guests showed up, the question was, "How do you like your steak." - How do YOU like YOURS, get it? And just for the record, Dad liked his to moo, too.
 
Ted M. August 24, 2018
I don't get the tri-tip hype. We call it bottom sirloin and to me, it's a lean, flavorless, uneven cut of meat that's best dropped in the slow cooker. Give me a nicely marbled ribeye any day.
 
William G. August 24, 2018
It's obvious you have never had tri-tip cooked by someone who knows how to prepare it. Ribeye is fatty. That is to say more pure fat than marbling
 
Ted M. August 24, 2018
It's obvious you're not clear as to what marble is. What shouldn't be so obvious is how and where I have had tri-tip.
 
William G. August 24, 2018
Jeez Ted. Don't take it so personally
 
Smaug August 25, 2018
I love tritip, but tend to find it excessively fatty, even after careful retrimming. Fortunately, grilling eliminates a good deal of that.
 
Teri D. August 31, 2018
No one said where....but, I concur with William. If you think tri-tip is flavorless then you just told us you have never had it prepared by someone who knows what they are doing.
 
Hank A. August 31, 2018
Fatty Tri-Tip? I have the butcher leave a slab on one side when I'm doing 'low and slow', but it's anything but fatty.
 
Smaug August 31, 2018
Some would call it "well marbled", but it's more fat than I like to eat and for me it detracts from the flavor. I've seen them sold with up to a 3/4" slab of solid fat on one side- some seem to actually prefer this, but for the rest of us it's easy enough to remove. However, they tend to package meat with that side down, so unless you're dealing with a live butcher it's hard to tell how much meat you're buying.
 
Montanamaven August 31, 2018
Montana rancher here. I cook this for the branding crowd and for friends. Flavorful but needs a little marinading. I like a tequila lime.
 
Hank A. August 31, 2018
@Smaug You need to find a Butcher - if you're buying your meat packaged with styrofoam and plastic wrap you should consider a step up, or buy a cheaper cut of meat appropriate from a grocery store.
 
Smaug August 31, 2018
Actually, tri tip is a pretty cheap cut, one reason I use it. I find that the Styrofoam and plastic does no actual harm to the meat- I can get the same stuff from the in house butcher and check the trim, but it's generally not worth waiting in line and the price is higher- I'm used to trimming nearly all the meat I buy anyway. Or they can be had really cheap untrimmed in bag straight from the slaughterhouse, just like the butcher gets them. I really can't see how a slab of pure fat can be "anything but fatty".
 
Don H. August 24, 2018
Agree with Mr. Green, Tri-tip is pretty awesome here on the Best Coast, with only salt & pepper. The idea is to enhance the flavor of steak. I grill tomatoes, jalapenos, onion and garlic on mesquite, toss it in the blender with cilantro and place slices of medium rare tri-tip in a flour tortilla and some of the salsa. Delish.
 
Michele August 23, 2018
I love skirt steak. This week at my market, though, it was 16.99. / lb. tenderloin was 15.99 A’s was prime porterhouse (on sale). Not skewing towards affordable in the northeast!
 
Jaye B. August 31, 2018
I hear you, Michele! I also like skirt steak and pricing is getting up there so I wouldn't say it was an affordable option for a crowd.