Root Vegetable
Your Roasted Holiday Vegetables Deserve This Puckery, Crunchy Topping
No cream, butter, or cheese required.
Photo by Rocky Luten
Popular on Food52
11 Comments
KJ
November 25, 2018
MSG is manufactured using a strong acid which produces both the MSG and a lot of nasty neurotoxins that are poisonous to humans. It is not accurate to state that MSG is harmless. Racism has nothing to do with it.
argentazure
November 25, 2018
It is not accurate to state that MSG is harmful; you're using scare terms like "strong acid" as if that makes something unsafe, whereas everyone regularly consume acids and acid-processed things in all aspects of daily life.
There is no clinical evidence that MSG is neurotoxic. If you have clinical evidence of that, please publish your research so that it can be peer reviewed. I'm sure there's a lucrative academic career awaiting you if you have that kind of evidence.
There is no clinical evidence that MSG is neurotoxic. If you have clinical evidence of that, please publish your research so that it can be peer reviewed. I'm sure there's a lucrative academic career awaiting you if you have that kind of evidence.
Burton
November 18, 2018
Although I'm not a huge fan of advertiser content on a rule, I'm glad that people are finally moving away from MSG hysteria. The way that MSG has been maligned is deeply unfortunate from a culinary perspective, and frankly racist from a cultural perspective. However, I do wish that this piece had mentioned what happens when you over-season with MSG (namely, that it flattens out the same flavors that it previously made pop), because I find that that's a common problem that those new to cooking with MSG have, and it's really hard to diagnose if you don't know what you're looking for.
Marionw
November 16, 2018
You're also quite likely to wake up the next morning with a headache from the MSG you added... I'm disappointed Food52 has sold out to an advertiser in this way; I've always enjoyed it as a source of real food recipes.
Burton
November 18, 2018
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glutamate_flavoring#Safety_as_a_flavor_enhancer
I'm not a huge fan of advertiser content either, but MSG sensitivities are scientifically nonsense, and are probably just the nocebo effect.
I'm not a huge fan of advertiser content either, but MSG sensitivities are scientifically nonsense, and are probably just the nocebo effect.
argentazure
November 25, 2018
Hi Marionw, there is actually no evidence that MSG causes headaches any more than regular table salt. It does contain sodium, just like salt, and thus has the same reactions on body hydration and blood pressure, but it's no more dangerous than regular table salt.
charlotte
November 15, 2018
I'm really surprised to see MSG being used as an ingredient in a food52 recipe. Isn't it something we're supposed to avoid?
Cory B.
November 16, 2018
Hi Charlotte and Marion W! Actually, MSG is totally safe to eat, and if you haven't noticed a problem when eating foods high in glutamates such as Prosciutto, fish sauce, or Parmesan cheese, you're not likely to experience headaches. If you're interested, you can read more about that here: https://food52.com/blog/22455-the-cultural-journey-of-msg-in-america
Gianna
November 24, 2018
MSG is a neurotoxin, if you want a mini-lightshow of nerve firings occurring in your brain and killing off neurons then sprinkle on EVERYTHING. Your taste buds will love it... brain, not so much ;) In science it is all about structure and function, the structure of naturally occurring glutamates is different then man-made ones such as those in Accent. I have respect for both chefs and scientists (and those who do both) but generally speaking, one should not try not obtain their health advice from someone looking to boost flavor through MSG. I suggest using things like parmesan, tomato paste, soy sauce, anchovies, dried shiitakes, etc, to bolster flavor of dishes. Why not dry a pulverized shiitake powder? AKA UMAMI "dust"...
argentazure
November 25, 2018
Hi Gianna, you're either misinformed or lying; MSG is not a neurotoxin. MSG is ubiquitous in Asian cuisines with no associated health problems.
If you have clinical evidence of MSG's neurotoxic properties, please publish your study; there would be lots of academic fame awaiting such evidence.
If you have clinical evidence of MSG's neurotoxic properties, please publish your study; there would be lots of academic fame awaiting such evidence.
Join The Conversation