This Year's Best Condiment Comes All the Way From Amsterdam

And yes, it's just a little bit boozy.

October  4, 2019
Photo by Gin Mayo

Mossel en Gin, a laidback seafood restaurant just outside the center of Amsterdam, is one of those places you're lucky to find as a tourist. Even luckier when you didn't plan a single thing to do or eat during your two-day trip.

Set in the sprawling, serene Westerpark (which is consistently less crowded than its more well-known neighbor, Vondelpark), this five-year-old spot is known for two things: big pots of buttery steamed mussels served with thick-cut french fries and a vast selection of gin and tonics.

We heard about Mossel en Gin thanks to one of my friends who I was traveling with; he got a tip to check out the place from a co-worker who grew up in the city. So we stopped by in the afternoon and made a reservation with Wouter, a friendly, effortlessly cool (as it seems all Amsterdammers are) guy who we'd later find out was one of the owners.

The late-summer weather was brisk, so that night we sat under string lights at one of the many wooden picnic tables in the garden, hearing little else but Dutch being spoken around us.

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“Mussels, gin & tonics, fries, and of course that fabulous sauce. The owner (quoted in the article) came by to ask us how dinner was, so we told him how we found out (he was very pleased). The sauce is delicious, and the mussels were wonderful. But if you go there, don’t pass up the shrimp bitterballen (fries balls with shrimp and more inside). Oh. My. A lovely place, and we look forward to buying Gin Mayo in the US.”
— LynnD

We each started with a gin and tonic—I went for one with orange and clove, while my friends ordered the mango with red pepper–infused gin. Seeing as we were very hungry after a day of traversing the entire city by foot, we pregamed our heaps of mussels with an an appetizer of shrimp bitterballen, a deep-fried Dutch snack very similar to a croquette.

And this is when we met the restaurant's unsung third claim to fame: Gin Mayo.

Photo by Gin Mayo

Arriving alongside the bitterballen in a blue tube with a flashy, almost retro-looking logo, the Gin Mayo confused us a little at first. Would it taste good? (Yes.) Was it alcoholic? (Yes, but not very.)

I squeezed a tiny blob onto my plate to try it on its own—it had a light orange color and tasted a little bit sweet, with just the right amount of tangy and salty (almost like a creamy shrimp cocktail sauce). I slathered it over the crispy bitterballen, and asked for another tube to go with the french fries that came as a plus-one to my mussels steamed with fennel, white wine, and Roquefort cheese.

Toward the end of our meal, Wouter stopped by our table to check in on us. We ended up chatting for a while over a round of beers from his wife's brewery, Gebrouwen door Vrouwen (which literally means "Brewed by Women").

Photo by Gin Mayo

Before heading out, he gave us his email in case we needed any recommendations, though he had already given us a few: TonTon Club, Café Checkpoint Charlie, and Lely.

I got back from my trip (which also included London and Linz, in Austria) a few weeks ago, but I still had a few lingering questions about the restaurant and Gin Mayo, particularly whether or not I could find it in New York. (Update: You can order it online from Chelsea Market Baskets in New York City!) So I reached out via email for a little chit chat, which you can read below. (Our conversation has been lightly edited for clarity.)

Erin Alexander: How did Mossel en Gin get started?

Wouter ten Velde: Josh [Selter, the other co-owner and self-proclaimed "mayonair"] fell in love with the mussels in Zeeland (in the south of Holland) and started wondering about the national love for mussels. It's a big thing as a dish in the south of Holland, but not so much further north, so 80% of the Dutch mussels are exported to Belgium, the U.K., Germany, and France. How could we make mussels more attractive to Dutch consumers and make them relevant again as part of our national pride?

Josh is the creative and food man, dealing with the kitchen, recipes, design, and marketing (the Mossel). I'm the hospitality guy, dealing with service, operations, and guests (the Gin).

EA: Where did the idea for Gin Mayo come from?

WTV: It made sense for us to make a sauce with gin in it to eat with your fries in our restaurant. Actually making something tasty that made people happy was the thing that triggered Josh to create the brand. We decided we didn't want to branch out with multiple restaurant locations, but instead to focus and go deeper around what we were already doing and this product fit with that philosophy.

EA: What was the process of coming up with the formula like?

WTV: Mixing gin with mayonnaise and ketchup (haha). After that, playing with herbs and sugar, and eating a lot of mayo—pure mayo, scooping it up a spoonful at a time.

EA: Is it made in Amsterdam?

WTV: It's made near Amsterdam, in Zaandam. We are proud to say our producer is a famous Dutch factory called "Zaanse Mayo,” which is quite a special thing as we are the only non-internal brand they work with.

EA: It's obviously great with fried food, but what else do you like to eat with Gin Mayo?

WTV: It goes with everything! I personally love it with eggs, on a burger, smoked salmon, fries, and of course, mussels.

EA: And the most important question, where can you buy it?

WTV: In the Netherlands, the U.K., and South Africa. We just started exporting to the United States and are working with Chelsea Market Baskets in New York.

What would you eat with Gin Mayo? Tell us in the comments below!

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Denise Marie Estrella
    Denise Marie Estrella
  • Barbara McIntyre
    Barbara McIntyre
  • LynnD
  • Jpassione
  • Molly Reese Lerner
    Molly Reese Lerner
Erin Alexander

Written by: Erin Alexander

Erin Alexander is the Managing Editor of Food52.


Denise M. October 14, 2019
I also broke down and bought a case- yikes, the shipping was twice the cost of the product. But it will go great with my dungeness crab thanksgiving feast!
flyinfish November 13, 2019
Where did you order from?
Denise M. November 14, 2019
I found the Gin Mayo shop on Facebook.
Cat. November 24, 2019
Barbara M. October 13, 2019
I’d love to try this gin mayo. As I get older my taste buds need more excitement and new experiences. Barbara
LynnD October 12, 2019
This landed in our email while we were in the taxi to the airport to go to Amsterdam! So, of course we made a reservation and had dinner. Mussels, gin & tonics, fries, and of course that fabulous sauce. The owner (quoted in the article) came by to ask us how dinner was, so we told him how we found out (he was very pleased). The sauce is delicious, and the mussels were wonderful. But if you go there, don’t pass up the shrimp bitterballen (fries balls with shrimp and more inside). Oh. My. A lovely place, and we look forward to buying Gin Mayo in the US.
Jpassione October 11, 2019
Just ordered a case, Christmas is coming early this year!
Molly R. October 6, 2019
How funny to read that you were in Linz! I live there and never, ever, hear it mentioned!
Erin A. October 14, 2019
Ahh! I was there for the rowing event this summer—it's such a charming city!
justen_m October 5, 2019
Sounds a lot like fry sauce that is common out here in Idaho and Utah. Fry sauce is mostly mayo and ketchup, and the best IMO add buttermilk and a bit of sugar. No gin, for some reason. ;) There are other options. Pickle juice, onion powder, garlic powder, etc.

Fry sauce goes great with any type of fried food, really. French fries, tater tots, finger steaks, beer-battered fish, wings, etc. Not bad on eggs either, or as a dipping sauce for pizza crust.