food52hotline help! Can I replace mustard sees with celery sees when making pickles?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Rebecca is a Recipe Tester for Food52
I would try fennel/anise/carraway, more along those lines. Mustard seeds would be good in addition, too! Perhaps crushed gently.
My mistake! Read it the other way around.
Yes, you can. You will have a slightly different flavor than if you used the celery (Rebecca above has good ideas for alternatives closer to the celery seed flavor) but you'll be fine and your pickles will be tasty.
It sounds to me like anonymous wants to use celery seeds instead of mustard seeds, not the other way 'round.
pierino is a trusted source on General Cooking and Tough Love.
That's how I read the question as well. But a pickle is a pickle. The seeds you use will alter the flavor but there really any hard core rules as to herbs and spices. It's what tastes good to you.
Pickled Mustard seeds themselves are being seen more and more as a condiment (Tom Colicchio of Wichcraft offers on many sandwiches)
What to eat, see, and do in Point Pleasant Beach.
The New Jersey Boardwalk of My Childhood
Make Store-Bought Hummus Better
Spread the Word
Our Favorite Dinner Prep Tools
Extra Chewy Sugar Cookies