Cast Iron Conundrums
Hi all,
I'm gleefully starting my cast iron collection (well, adding it to the registry) and in addition to the classic question of LC v. Staub v. Lodge I'm having a hard time figuring out which sizes I need and which pieces are actually necessary. Right now I'm just cooking for my fiance and myself but look forward to cooking for more and entertaining in the future. So the list goes:
French oven (5.5 or 7.25?)
Raw cast iron skillet (10"?)
Braiser (5 qt?)- If I have a french oven do I really need a braiser?
Grill pan- seems like this should be raw cast iron to get hot enough to sear meat. What's the argument for enameled?
Thanks for your help!
Recommended by Food52
5 Comments
We also have a grill pan. It is a Lodge rectangular one that is on the small side. We use it for steaks all the time. We live in a place where we can't grill outside, so the grill pan is our friend. I don't recommend using that small pan for a crowd, bit it does allow the fat to drain off like when grilling and with grill marks, we can pretend we cooked it on our grill. Do you absolutely need one, I don't think so. Should you buy one if it happened to ne on sale for less than $20 including shipping? Absolutely
Raw cast Iron. I own a ten inch. Sometimes I wish I also had a 12 inch, but I've lived without it. If I need a 12 inch, I have a 12 inch, heavy bottomed non stick that works quite well.
I don't have a grill pan. When I grill, I do it outside on my Weber, so I'm no help there, but my gut tells me raw cast iron. Hopefully someone who knows will chime in.
If someone were to tell me they were going to purchase a LC for me, I probably would go for a braiser, but that's because I have the two Dutch ovens.
Have fun!!