Do you think I could successfully double this recipe and bake it in a 9x13 pan to feed a crowd?

Emily Stapley


Emily S. April 3, 2017
I did (I always) use a buttered and floured parchment liner in the bottom of the pan for easy removal-- you can even see it in the picture I think. Sticking to the pan wasn't the problem. It's a VERY delicate cake. As soon as it was turned out it fell apart. Springform is definitely the way to go with this cake. I will try again sometime (in a springform pan as recommended) and let you know how it goes. The cake still tasted pretty good even though it doesn't look pretty anymore. I kept the pieces, and may make them into trifle. When life gives you lemons (or hunks of cake)...
Nancy April 3, 2017
Emily - yes, parchment is there. I missed it 1st time bc I was looking at crumbled cake. So, nothing helps. Back to spring form (and trifle). Enjoy :)
Sarah J. March 28, 2017
Based on Alice's great post on converting baking pan sizes (, I think it should work! But if you feel like you have too much batter, I'd leave it off (siphon it into a muffin tin!) rather than forcing it into the pan, if that makes sense. Also, I suspect it may take longer to cook—but check at the 30-minute mark to be sure! Good luck and let us know how it goes!
Emily S. April 1, 2017
I have a really nice 9x13" pan with tall 3" sides and the batter doubled fit into it perfectly. The cake rose just to the top edge and domed just a bit. I had to cook it for about 55 minutes to get it to set in the middle. The outside edges were fairly dark because of this, but not burnt. Everything went really smoothly until I tried to take it out of the pan to cool on a rack. Now I know why you recommend a springform pan for this cake. It does not transfer well. So sad.
Nancy April 2, 2017
If you ever need such a large cake again & aren't discouraged, line the sheet pan with wax or parchment paper (buttered & floured) or silicone mat(s). Removal should be much easier.
Recommended by Food52