Fry
All Day Duck Gumbo
Popular on Food52
41 Reviews
cosmiccook
February 2, 2025
As a N.O. native, we do a smoked duck gumbo fall/winter. it takes us 2-3 days. I like the stock to cure after I make it. We've learned over the years to only smoke the duck for 2 hrs. (indirect heat around 300 degrees). I prefer light smoke flavor since the andouille will add more flavor. De-skin the ENTIRE DUCK; lay aside. Remove all meat you can from entire duck--yes it will be mostly raw. (This is day 1 for us). A further quick roast --30 min-- in the oven will provide extra flavor. take the carcass and add what aromatics you like for stock--we NEVER use chicken stock for duck gumbo). Cook down for 3 hours over a low heat; skim any fat off. As for oven browned flour; I gave up on (as do most experienced gumbo makers I know) this method years ago. It was a Paul Prudhomme thing when he was trying to make his recipes "healthier". Just use a cast iron or SS skillet. 1 to 1 ratio is okay. We add more like 1/2 cup of garlic for over a gallon of gumbo. We typically use duck fat for our gumbo. Healthier than Canola & better tasting. Avocado is another neutral oil. We DON'T USE BEER--it can get bitter tasting as the gumbo cooks down. For those cracklings''-- lay the skin (use a weight to flatten it) in a heavy duty skillet w water to cover; cook on med. high heat and let the water evaporate (appr. 2 hrs.). Let the skin cook in the remaining fat till brown. This is how LARGE vats of pork cracklings' are made--same method, different products. Once our roux is made (my husband does this as he is the "gumbo man" and we have the playlist for it. It MUST be played while making a roux! It takes a good 3 hrs. of simmering after the trinity is added (for duck I like to throw in some chopped fennel). While the meat is almost raw going in it will cook. My BIGGEST PEEVE about ANY gumbo--overcooked meat that chews and tastes like leather. I just don't like it. NO file for us (can't stand that slimy metallic texture it adds) FRIED OKRA sprinkled on top w cracklinss; YES! OYSTERS A MUST AT THE END!! But we usually grill, bake or other in addition to gumbo. That's what gallons & sacks are for! LOL --we'll probably do a sack for Superbowl since we don't watch the game and its here in NEW ORLEANS (NOT NOLA) loathe that acronym-I KNOW I live in La lol!
Greg F.
August 8, 2020
So this is really good but... First, if you're cooking duck you make the roux with duck fat, not vegetable oil. Second, I think this needs more than one cup each of the Holy Trinity (onions, celery, bell peppers) so as to give the gumbo more ummmphhh. That of course means more roux and so that's what I do. I generally smoke ducks as opposed to roasting them but that is not a critique of this recipe. Nice spicing, nice narrative in the recipe. It's good, make it.
melindasterne
October 3, 2018
Yummy!!! I love the intro about your connection to New Orleans (so sweet!) I really appreciate the reminder for some tunes, to let the beer sit for a bit, and the duck skin crackling. Wondering why you didn't include okra in this recipe? I can't wait to try your recipe, thank you for sharing.
Julie
April 25, 2018
So I just made this and yes it is a wonderful gumbo and it does indeed take all day. I am from New Orleans and this recipe in no way serves a crowd. It will feed only 5 for dinner so be aware!
gingerroot
June 18, 2014
Abbie! I made this for Father's Day and omg is it amazing! I enjoyed the last of it today for lunch. Even my daughter, who was skeptical about duck, loved it. Can't wait to make it again!!
starface80
July 3, 2013
this recipe is fabulous. i have a louisiana family, and have made their tried and true duck gumbo recipe more than once. this far surpasses it. i only change a few things only because of what's available in my kitchen: i use smoked paprika in the rub; i add oysters (about 7 minutes before serving so the oysters don't overcook); and i use wild ducks - 2 in this particular recipe since they're a bit smaller.
aargersi
July 3, 2013
Awesome - thanks! As soon as I can get one of my nephews to shoot a couple ducks for me I will try this with them - I think season is in the fall. The oysters sound good too!
inthebow
May 9, 2011
We just finished dinner. This was fantastic! I really enjoyed making it too. I love recipes that you can make over time. You can really watch them develop and your kitchen smells wonderful.
I did make this over two days. Day 1 I spent roasting the duck, toasting the flour and cooking the sausage. I finished everything on Day 2. I served it over brown rice and it was wonderful! The recipe is a definite keeper.
One small thing to note on the recipe is that the ingredient list doesn't have green onion, but it shows up in step 7.
Thank you, aargersi!
I did make this over two days. Day 1 I spent roasting the duck, toasting the flour and cooking the sausage. I finished everything on Day 2. I served it over brown rice and it was wonderful! The recipe is a definite keeper.
One small thing to note on the recipe is that the ingredient list doesn't have green onion, but it shows up in step 7.
Thank you, aargersi!
aargersi
May 12, 2011
Thank you so much for the nice review - I am glad you enjoyed it! I like "project" dishes too ... they are so gratifying in the end. I will fix the green onion oopsie :-)
lorigoldsby
April 28, 2011
Your duck gumbo recipe sounds as good as any I've ever had in NOLA, it makes me want to check priceline for a last minute ticket to the Big Easy!...a cup of your gumbo, half an oyster po boy and a couple of my oysters ROCK, some jazz in the background and a hurricane to sip on...thanks for the culinary daydream!
lapadia
April 27, 2011
Your gatherings sound like fun and your Gumbo looks like a party in a cup, aargersi!
MyCommunalTable
April 26, 2011
What an adventure in a bowl. I need to make this since I have never been to New Orleans. Thanks for sharing.
drbabs
April 26, 2011
It was SO fun having lunch with you yesterday. I love this recipe, and hope there's a day soon when we can do some real New Orleans cooking together. Thanks for sharing this and your great story.
gingerroot
April 25, 2011
Really love this - the headnote, the duck, the music...it sounds amazing and I love that your recipes always feel like coming home.
fiveandspice
April 25, 2011
SO awesome aargersi! Love, love it!
aargersi
April 25, 2011
Thanks! Would be fun to have a big Food52 Feed-Up and everyone cook their recipe this week wouldn't it?
See what other Food52ers are saying.