Serves a Crowd
Raspberry Ice Cream Sandwiches
Popular on Food52
51 Reviews
Arthur
July 1, 2017
Has anyone tried the ice cream portion of this recipe without using an ice cream machine? Would simply freezing overnight be OK? Thank you, in advance, for your comments!
Hillary B.
June 23, 2017
Made today with strawberries. The purée was too thick to get through a fine mesh strainer. I also think I cooked the custard bit too long as little clumps began forming. Not to worry, the end result = delicious and decidedly smooth. One last note: this made a lot of ice cream! Over a half gallon. Such a problem to have to solve...
borntobeworn
September 19, 2013
The ice cream part was a breeze to make but these cookies are a challenge. With 3 sticks of butter in the dough, they are very soft and hard to get off my floured surface in one piece although I chilled the dough for more than 1 hour. If you don't have experience rolling out dough to a certain thickness, the caution about not using too much flour should be ignored - you need a certain amount or they just stick to everything. So keep dusting until you hit that happy medium :)
Shalala
August 29, 2012
Have discovered just one problem with this recipe: it is almost impossible to stop yourself from eating the shortbread dough before it is cooked. My husband and I just love it. Highly recommend this one!
fiveandspice
September 3, 2012
Teehee. That is a problem! A reason to make a double batch, I guess! :)
Shalala
August 28, 2012
Haven't made the sandwich cookies yet as I just finished making the ice cream this morning. Even on its own it is absolutely delicious! I echo the need to leave the ice cream cooling in the refrigerator over night. I have noted a noticeable difference in the batter after that amount of time--it generally seems to give the flavors more of a chance to gel.
leslie3733
August 26, 2012
How much ice cream is yielded from this recipe? Also, at the size you prefer for each cookie, how many cookies does that recipe make? Thx.
fiveandspice
August 26, 2012
Hi Leslie! The ice cream portion makes around 1 1/2 quarts. And the whole recipe makes somewhere around two dozen sandwiches.
Kitchen B.
August 23, 2012
Many congratulations - what a wonderful combination! I was on your blog this weekend, loving your 'boller' recipe!
fiveandspice
August 23, 2012
Thanks KB! And, I'm so glad you are loving the boller! They're one of my all time favorite treats.
AntoniaJames
August 22, 2012
Yes, I'd agree, this certainly is show stopping. And what a drop dead gorgeous photo, too. I love the combination of flavors but even more so, am thrilled to have found a tried-and-true cookie that works well in ice cream sandwiches. Congrats on the Wildcard which I know, even without having tested the recipe, is richly deserved!! ;o)
gingerroot
August 22, 2012
Woo-hoo!! Congrats on the well deserved wildcard, fiveandspice. These beauties are the perfect end-of-summer treat, and I hope to make them soon.
fiveandspice
August 22, 2012
Thanks Jenny! I hope you guys get a chance to try them. (p.s. passion fruit ginger jam = life changing. Amazing.) :)
gingerroot
August 22, 2012
Yay! So glad to hear you are enjoying it...I will keep you well stocked once you move. : )
Nozlee S.
August 22, 2012
We couldn't stop eating these in the test kitchen -- congrats on an amazing recipe, fiveandspice!
fiveandspice
August 22, 2012
Thanks so much Nozlee! I'm thrilled you guys liked them! It's funny because I was actually thinking about these earlier in the week and wishing my kitchen wasn't packed into boxes so I could make them. I'm so glad that you guys did instead!
ChefJune
August 22, 2012
I'm sure you couldn't! they sound unbearably decadent. If I had that many lemon coconut shortbread cookies and that much raspberry ice cream in the house at the same time, I'd be in SERIOUS trouble!
TheWimpyVegetarian
August 22, 2012
Congrats on the Wildcard win!!! This looks just fantastic!!
fiveandspice
August 22, 2012
Wow! Thank you so much Susan! And belated congratulations on your gorgeous linguine recipe last week! I've been head down embroiled in thesis committee meetings and packing to move and it slipped my mind to congratulate you earlier, but it is high on my must cook list.
TheWimpyVegetarian
August 22, 2012
No worries. I think an ice cream sandwich beats out any linguini dish and day of the week. Just sayin' :-) Good luck with your thesis and your move!
gingerroot
July 14, 2011
Holy moly, fiveandspice! I'm only now looking through all of these raspberry entries and these sound ah-mazing. I think you should add these beauties to your bicycle-pulled food stand. You'd have a line a mile long in the summer!
fiveandspice
July 14, 2011
Aw, thanks gingerroot! If I could find a freezer trailer for my bicycle they would be a good addition, wouldn't they?! :) We just finished eating the last two last night, and I'm so sad they're gone. Midge just told me about a community kitchen in the neighborhood where you can rent space, so who knows, the bicycle food stand may someday be a reality...
Sagegreen
July 9, 2011
I just noticed these: What a great idea to make your own shortbread with coconut for the chambord raspberry dream filling!
fiveandspice
July 9, 2011
Thank you Sagegreen! I'm really happy with how the combination of textures and flavors worked out! I just love ice cream sandwiches! I think they're so fun to eat.
See what other Food52ers are saying.