Serves a Crowd
Butter-Toasted-Walnut Layer Cake
Popular on Food52
17 Reviews
FrugalCat
September 23, 2020
I halved the recipe and made one pan of moist, nutty cupcakes. I just put whipped cream on top for frosting. Toss the nuts in a little flour before adding to the batter so they don't sink to the bottom.
KLM
November 6, 2018
Does this really have 6 cups of icing sugar? Does not sound right...would think WAY too sweet. Want to make this for a special occasion but need feedback on the icing, please. Many thanks!
Pinky
February 17, 2018
Made this cake for my walnut-loving mother's birthday and she and the party guests have not stopped raving about it! Thank you so much!
Nostrovia_ca
February 21, 2018
So glad it was a hit, Pinky! Thanks for taking the time to let me know. (And I haven't made this cake in so long. It may be time...)
lin R.
July 21, 2014
Do you think that black walnuts would work in this recipe?
Nostrovia_ca
July 21, 2014
I think using black walnuts would be a wonderful idea! They're even more flavourful than regular walnuts and would like give the cake a whole extra dimension of richness. If you try it, let me know how it turns out!
Synky
January 26, 2014
Six CUPS of icing sugar?!?! I made this recipe, following everything perfectly. It was very hard to eat the cake, much less taste it wothout being hit over the head with a wall of sugar. My 5 and 2 year old would not eat this after a single bite. It reminded me of those cakes one would get from a big box grocery store in the 90s for a whole group of children celebrating a birthday. Only cake to be thrown out to date in this household. Be wary!
Nostrovia_ca
January 27, 2014
Sorry to hear that you did not like the cake, Synky. Others seem to have liked it and Food 52 actually tested it, chose it as a wildcard winner, and also included it in their best layer cakes roundup, so I guess it's a matter of taste.
Brian D.
September 26, 2023
I am thinking I will make a Swiss buttercream. Six cups of sugar in an American buttercream is tooth-achingly sweet.
Angel
September 22, 2013
I made this cake yesterday to serve for a dinner party. Although it turned out a little too dry (not sure why) it was delicious. I would make this again and maybe add a little more liquid.
Nostrovia_ca
September 23, 2013
Sorry to hear it turned out a little dry for you, Angel. Something to watch with this cake is length of time in the oven. Since everyone's oven is different, the recommended baking time can vary. You can try testing the cake 5 minutes before the least amount of time called for and pulling it out if it seems cooked through and still moist. I'll usually pull the layers out if there's still a few tiny crumbs clinging to the cake tester; the few minutes' cooling time in the pan usually takes care of that last little bit of firming up without drying everything out.
Angel
September 23, 2013
Actually, in my case I think it was the residual baking after I took it out of the oven that got me into trouble.
I am going to try to figure out how to make this into a coffee cake. So good. I just had the last slice for breakfast :)
I am going to try to figure out how to make this into a coffee cake. So good. I just had the last slice for breakfast :)
lynnel
November 13, 2014
Coffee - yes! This is nearly my grandmother's recipe for "man's cake" so-called because strong coffee was the liquid added to the batter. It also originally called for pecans rather than walnuts. The icing was more of a 7 minute penuche type frosting, also with a bit of coffee added. It was a surprisingly light-tasting yellow cake, and much loved by our family. Thank you so much for posting this!
kitchenkiddo
December 24, 2012
Just made this and what a treat it is. I made one large cake and cut it into two layers, and made a tart raspberry and rhubarb compote for the middle layer to offset the sweet frosting-awesome!
Nostrovia_ca
December 29, 2012
Glad you liked the recipe ~ and I love your twist of adding a compote layer!
Dessert's O.
August 20, 2011
sounds amazing!
Nostrovia_ca
August 20, 2011
Thanks ~ it really is a lovely cake! The buttered walnuts give it that extra-special something. (I'm so intrigued by your frozen sun gold cherry tomato cheesecake, by the way!)
See what other Food52ers are saying.