Lemon
Lemon Birthday Cake
Popular on Food52
14 Reviews
Kpaz459
November 28, 2023
I can see how this recipe would be delicious but the recipe is poorly written and created a lot of confusion. I am not new in the kitchen and typically I have success with recipes from this site. Please edit as I know many people would enjoy this cake. Also, bake time is way off.
LippyLou
October 8, 2022
I made this cake last night and I was INITIALLY impressed with the frosting. Indeed the meringue was glossy and thick, and it was delicious and I lathered it all over my cake -- but the next day it had separated and dissolved entirely. I made it a day ahead for an event and never even had a piece of the cake, it was completely ruined. I don't even understand what happened because the meringue was perfect. A total disaster. And I'll agree with everyone else, that the recipe for the cake was confusing in the cook time was too long. After my experience I think I would just move away from this recipe altogether folks.
zoomorphic
April 24, 2016
This cake was a disappointment. I read and reread the instructions to make sure the recipe didn't trip me up (per Merrill's explanation, it uses 8 whole eggs and 4 egg yolks), and indeed the batter looked (and tasted) amazing! But the cooking time was way too long. I've never had a problem with my oven running hot, and while I was skeptical about the 90 minute baking time, I figured that the pound cake-like richness would require a longer bake time. I checked on it around 70 minutes in and it looked fully done, passed the toothpick test, etc, so I took it out early. Even so, it was rock hard by the time it cooled.
Amma
May 16, 2014
The recipe calls for 8 eggs to be used to make the cake. So no more than 8 eggs are to be used. In my opinion, the recipe is asking for you to use the egg whites of all 8 eggs "put aside the whites in a stainless bowl" but instead of using 8 egg yolks, it is asking you to use 4 "dump 4 in the main bowl and repurpose the rest".
It could be explained clearer but this is what I will do. Feels better to use 8 egg whites versus 8 whole eggs.
It could be explained clearer but this is what I will do. Feels better to use 8 egg whites versus 8 whole eggs.
Alex H.
April 29, 2014
I was also totally confused by this recipe, to the point where I ended up taking the strawberries and macerating them in with the zest! Good lord, it turned out amazing. Alls well that ends well?
I also halved the recipe and used slightly less sugar and (I think?) only two egg yolks in the actual recipe. Then I just took Meyer lemon zest and juice with powdered sugar and butter and poured half over the cake for the topping while it was still hot, then I piled a bunch of fresh strawberries and blueberries on top of the cake and poured the remaining icing over that. Mmmmm
I also halved the recipe and used slightly less sugar and (I think?) only two egg yolks in the actual recipe. Then I just took Meyer lemon zest and juice with powdered sugar and butter and poured half over the cake for the topping while it was still hot, then I piled a bunch of fresh strawberries and blueberries on top of the cake and poured the remaining icing over that. Mmmmm
em-i-lis
February 14, 2014
This recipe is written in SUCH a confusing fashion. Who has any idea how many eggs to really use. After much consideration, I halved the recipe and used the following:
2 and 1/4 c cake flour
3/4 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1 and 1/2 cup plus 1/8 cup sugar
zest of 2.5 lemons
1 large egg + 2 large egg yolks + 2 large egg whites beaten until fluffy (so three whole eggs)
2/3 cup heavy cream
2 T dark rum
1 stick unsalted butter
I cooked this halved recipe in a 10-cup max heart-shaped bundt pan and it was the perfect amount of batter for that pan. Cook time was 58 minutes. I just made a lemon juice-powdered sugar glaze. Hope this helps in any way!
2 and 1/4 c cake flour
3/4 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1 and 1/2 cup plus 1/8 cup sugar
zest of 2.5 lemons
1 large egg + 2 large egg yolks + 2 large egg whites beaten until fluffy (so three whole eggs)
2/3 cup heavy cream
2 T dark rum
1 stick unsalted butter
I cooked this halved recipe in a 10-cup max heart-shaped bundt pan and it was the perfect amount of batter for that pan. Cook time was 58 minutes. I just made a lemon juice-powdered sugar glaze. Hope this helps in any way!
George H.
November 23, 2015
The frosting calls for 7 eggs, but the instruction only mentions "egg white". Kind of confusing.
LanBanan
July 3, 2013
The recipe calls for 15 eggs altogether, 8 for the cake, 7 for the frosting, but actually what it is is 8 whole eggs and 4 egg yolks in the cake, 7 egg whites in the frosting, and 3 egg yolks for another recipe -- that's a lot of eggs!!!
call72
April 5, 2011
I am not understanding Step 3. Dump 4 yolks in bowl ; repurpose the rest. Then whisk in 8 more eggs? That's a total of 8 eggs and 4 yolks to be whisked and the recipe only calls for 8 eggs...... Your directions call or 12. Please explain further.
MrsArkban
February 7, 2013
I think they mean repurpose the rest of the separated yolks. Hang on to the 8 whites and whisk those in
Marie A.
May 10, 2013
Ya the egg part is confusing... I put the four yolks in and cream and rum but it was wayyyy too dry and thick when I added the flour. I had to add more rum (which isn't a bad thing necessarily) and then I also whipped the egg whites and folded those in. I guess it turned out alright though. I made a recipe of lemon curd from The Splendid Table and filled the layers with that and finished everything off with a lemon buttercream. Delicious!
LanBanan
July 3, 2013
The recipe calls for 15 eggs altogether, 8 for the cake, 7 for the frosting, but actually what it is is 8 whole eggs and 4 egg yolks in the cake, 7 egg whites in the frosting, and 3 egg yolks for another recipe -- that's a lot of eggs!!!
See what other Food52ers are saying.