Make Ahead
Maple Oatmeal Princess Coffee Cake
Popular on Food52
46 Reviews
chezjenne
September 19, 2022
My family and I loved this cake and I saved it in my Favorites! The texture of the cake is superb with the softened oatmeal in it. I made it as written except I forgot the nutmeg in the batter so I added it to the topping, which was AMAZING.
Wheezy C.
July 1, 2022
Doesn't Jim broil the top a little? I used to live right down the street from J&P's on Fremont, and I've got a Princess addiction.
Laura415
May 15, 2019
I've done this cake many times now. I make it gluten free using oat flour among other GF flours. I doubled the recipe for a thick cake or make some muffin cakes with no topping for the anti-coconut crowd. The rest was made into a cake with the topping almost as thick as the cake. A tiny piece will do. I also use unsweetened coconut, greek yogurt instead of creme fraiche and a splash of bourbon. Very forgiving and easy recipe.
Olympia S.
February 12, 2017
Can I replace the pecans for walnuts? Also, I'm out of organic butter can I replace it with coconut oil or expelled canola oil ? 😬
hardlikearmour
February 13, 2017
My opinion is that any nut you like will work. I suspect you can replace the butter w/ coconut oil though butter has some water in it so I can't promise it will work perfectly.
Karen
February 9, 2015
Ok must share this tidbit: this is cake is so good that I accidentally (this is a not wearing my glasses in the kitchen while multi-tasking story) used the shredded parmesan cheese for my broccoli soup that was waiting on the side INSTEAD of the shredded coconut. Worst part was I accused the dog of stealing the parmesan! And then realized too late that I had just topped the cake with a pecan and parmesan topping!! It STILL tasted good. I just threw the coconut on top at the end. Thank you again!!
DoubleNegative
May 14, 2015
That is seriously one of the funniest things I have seen in print in a long, long time. You couldn't make this stuff up! Thanks for the laugh, Karen...being Italian I can vouch that parmesan goes with everything (except seafood, according to my Pop Pop). Hug the dog for me, poor guy, he probably looked totally guilty upon your maligning too, being a dog ain't all gravy.
Karen
January 24, 2015
I LOVE this cake. This time I made it with Greek Yogurt (to be honest all I had was the full fat Honey Salted Caramel flavor). It as great. I am generous with the pecans because they are a favorite. The oatmeal is a great addition. Great recipe. Thank you so much!!
fearlessem
November 16, 2014
Made this a few days ago, with unsweetened coconut for the topping. It didn't rise as much as I'd hoped, which meant it was quite dense. However it did seem to get better each day -- I baked it on Friday night, and my husband said the scraps that were left on Sunday night were the best. I might try this again but would add more baking powder to try to get little more lift in the cake part...
emily
March 4, 2014
Anybody tried to veganize this? I have vegan butter and thought I could use some type of vegan cream for the topping...just wondering how it would react if I subbed out the egg for something else. Baked goods are always a challenge for this!
Barbara B.
February 20, 2014
Can you substitute unsweetened yogurt for the creme fraiche or sour cream? Looks delicious!,,
Maureen M.
February 19, 2014
Would the cake be worth making without the topping? Hubby won't eat either nuts or coconut but I think he would like the cake itself.
Hina
February 19, 2014
This cake sounds great! What are some possible substitutes for the creme fraiche or sour cream?
Kathryn V.
February 19, 2014
I have made a similar recipe out of a cookbook I have had for 30 years! It was one of the simple, luscious cakes in the "More-With-Less Cookbook", a Mennonite cookbook with recipes from around the world. I have used that cookbook so much, pages are falling out of it!
swrk
December 21, 2013
we live just a few blocks from J & P's, and my daughter loves this Princess coffee cake. is it because it's cake, or because it has Princess in the title? Hard to say. But thank you for figuring out the recipe, we'll be making this soon!
Dimitrios
October 14, 2013
On a whim I searched for "princess cake" not thinking a recipe would actually show up. Low and behold this is the exact cake from Jim and Patty's that I'm trying to recreate. Looking forward to giving this recipe a whirl.
fearlessem
May 30, 2013
Making this tonight, but don't have creme fraiche or sour cream in the house. How essential are they to the topping? Can I get by without them?
hardlikearmour
May 30, 2013
I'm sure you can get by without them. They just cut the sweetness of the topping a little.
JessicaBakes
May 12, 2013
I put a splash of bourbon into the topping. Really cut the sweetness and added something awesome. Highly recommended!
Barbara G.
April 29, 2013
Great cake. Super tasty. Brunch guests loved it. I think I will make one and a half portions the next time to have a deeper cake. Added cinnamon to cake and a thimble full of brandy. Used toasted walnuts.
HFog
April 27, 2013
cake was great, but the topping very, very sweet. next time will sub unsweetened shredded coconut for sweetened.
hardlikearmour
April 27, 2013
Sounds like a great idea! I confess to having a pretty strong sweet tooth when it comes to desserts, so I can definitely see that it would be too sweet for lots of folks!
cookinginvictoria
April 29, 2013
I can attest that unsweetened coconut works well with this recipe. I have made this cake, using unsweetened coconut for the topping and without adjusting anything else. Everyone I served this cake to agreed that the sweetness level was perfect -- sweet but not TOO sweet.
piacere
April 27, 2013
This reminds me of a family fav recipe that originated with a friend my mom's when I was a kid. We made it many, many times as it always held well and was a hit with whatever age group, from kids to adults, and no matter what time of day. This version, with the maple syrup added, sounds even better. I'm eager to try it. Thanks for sharing! It is on next week's "agenda".
fiveandspice
April 13, 2013
Dang this looks amazing HLA! My oat-barley-rye intolerance seems not as bad right now, which of course means I'm asking for it and have been eating small amounts lately, and as long as things stay good, this cake is going on the must make list.
See what other Food52ers are saying.