Serves a Crowd
Roast Spatchcocked Turkey
Popular on Food52
127 Reviews
MonicaAnn
January 5, 2023
The holidays are over, and tonight, I'm roasting another spatchcocked turkey. After dry brining uncovered in the fridge, I've taken to loosening the thigh and breast skin, adding a pat of butter and stuffing them full of stuffing. Seems to really help the meat come out even more juicy and flavorful. Any remaining stuffing goes under the cavity between the bird and the broiler pan. I then rub butter on the outside, and salt and pepper. Beautifully browned and crispy skin. I find I have to roast mine longer than the instructions indicate, but just chalk that up to the variation in ovens. Have been doing it this way for over 3 years. Never going back to a regular turkey.
MonicaAnn
January 5, 2023
I'm also certain the stuffing under the skin adds to the cooking time, as well.
nbrown
November 30, 2022
Superb, Antonia James!
My first time trying a spatchcocked turkey and I am so glad I landed on your recipe.
I started with a 16 lb bird. The butcher did not remove the keel bone, so I used pair of very sharp poultry sheers and managed to remove it myself. I carefully loosened the meat around the keel bone - gently scraping around it with a knife. Then using a small but strong sniping motion worked through the ribs with the shears to get it out. As you mentioned in the comments, removing the keel bone was key to getting a larger turkey flattened.
I could not resist that pricy, generous display of chanterelle mushrooms at the grocery store. I cubed them up and threw them in the pan under the rack. They absorbed some of the turkey juices and white wine baste.
My family commented that this was the best turkey ever.
My first time trying a spatchcocked turkey and I am so glad I landed on your recipe.
I started with a 16 lb bird. The butcher did not remove the keel bone, so I used pair of very sharp poultry sheers and managed to remove it myself. I carefully loosened the meat around the keel bone - gently scraping around it with a knife. Then using a small but strong sniping motion worked through the ribs with the shears to get it out. As you mentioned in the comments, removing the keel bone was key to getting a larger turkey flattened.
I could not resist that pricy, generous display of chanterelle mushrooms at the grocery store. I cubed them up and threw them in the pan under the rack. They absorbed some of the turkey juices and white wine baste.
My family commented that this was the best turkey ever.
AntoniaJames
December 1, 2022
nbrown, thank you so much. "Best turkey ever?" High praise that is. Love the idea of throwing mushrooms in the pan! I'll be doing that next year. Thanks for letting us know. ;o)
MonicaAnn
January 5, 2023
Re: keel bone - I follow America's Test Kitchens instructions on this for their Zuni Cafe Roast Chicken. They advise to put a small slice through the top of the cartilage, flip the bird breast side up and press firmly with both hands and it will crack. Works great for turkey, too.
DJM-VA
November 24, 2022
Amazing recipe. Easy to follow...may have added some extra wine [plus an Xtra glass for the cook] wish I could attach my photo!!
AntoniaJames
December 1, 2022
Thank you, DJM-VA. Extra wine, plus an extra glass for the cook - always a good idea! So glad it worked out well for you. ;o)
Bemused
November 24, 2022
This is the best-written turkey recipe I've ever read. It specifies cooking times for birds of various sizes. Most assume you're cooking a 10-12 pound turkey. Covering the drumsticks and other pieces with foil makes a ton of sense. This will be my guide today.
Arthur J.
November 24, 2022
For turkey, I have a DEDICATED pair of Fiskar Pruning shears for yard and garden. It cuts through the turkey bones with ease! For smaller birds, I find a sharp pair of poultry shears sufficient. You cut through where ribs join the spine. You don’t try to cut through the spine itself
Mrs B.
November 24, 2022
Great tip!! Thanks so much. Santa has been duly advised. Happy Thanksgiving!!
Makingheadlines
November 16, 2022
Help, please: I have a 16 lb spachcocked turkey, so it's likely too large to lay flat in my roasting pan. What size baking sheet do I need to purchase and can anyone recommend one they like or where they got it?
AntoniaJames
November 16, 2022
I have never spatchcocked a bird quite that large, but I just smoked a 13 pound turkey this past weekend which I let come to room temperature on what is known as a "half sheet pan," which is about 13" x 18". I'm quite sure that your turkey would fit on a sheet pan that size. I have tried several brands over the years, and Nordic Ware is my favorite (and seems to be that of various experts, too, as I've noticed in comparison review articles). You can buy them in the Food52 Shop, but also at restaurant supply stores and on Amazon. They are well worth the investment.
Also, it's just as well that your roasting pan won't work. You really need to expose the turkey all over on a surface with much lower sides in order for it to roast properly. ;o)
Also, it's just as well that your roasting pan won't work. You really need to expose the turkey all over on a surface with much lower sides in order for it to roast properly. ;o)
Makingheadlines
November 16, 2022
Thanks! I just ordered the Nordic Ware Extra large (14 x 20) Oven Crisp Baking Tray. It comes with a rack and has 2" sides, so it will make it a little easier not to spill than the traditional sided baking sheet. Does that sound like a good choice to you? And may I ask two other questions: 1) I ordered a fresh bird and the butcher suggested 16 lbs for 11 people to have leftovers. Does that sound right to you? 2) I was considering a buttermilk and salt wet brine if I don't do your brine. Can I use your timing directions even if I use this wet brine? Thank you so much. I appreciate how simply you've written your directions and how complete they are. Most others are only for smaller birds and don't give such specifics.
AntoniaJames
November 17, 2022
That rack sounds fine! The 2" sides should be okay, and the surface area should be more than enough.
The 16 pound bird should be plenty. I don't know how old or how hungry each of your guests will be. There will be plenty for everybody at the table, but how many leftovers there will be depends on how much is eaten on Thanksgiving itself. Generally, if you're serving the usual array of sides, people don't take an enormous amount of turkey. If you really want to make sure there is enough for sandwiches, you can set some aside in advance.
The timing instructions should be the same if. you use the wet brine. Don't rely on those recommendations, however. Use a probe thermometer to start checking early. Mine always seem to take less time than I expect.
Here is a note of caution, however. Your bird is at the top of the range of ideal weights for spatchcocking a turkey.
It is critical therefore that you either cut out the keel bone completely (I've never been able to do it myself, so get your butcher to do it for you, if possible), or at least snip around it part way to release the meat attached to it, and then cut the keel bone down the middle from the top a good inch or two, if you can. You may have to break it by pressing down very hard on the outside of the bird at the top. Breaking it is okay. The point is that with a turkey breast that size, you must flatten it out well, to allow it to cook properly all the way through.
I had a situation a few years ago when some of the breast meat looked a little pink after I'd removed the bird from the oven, started carving, etc., despite correct internal temperatures on my probe thermometer. I sliced it anyway and then dropped the slices in a skillet with some hot gravy for about 1 minute, which completed the cooking quite nicely.
Have fun! ;o)
The 16 pound bird should be plenty. I don't know how old or how hungry each of your guests will be. There will be plenty for everybody at the table, but how many leftovers there will be depends on how much is eaten on Thanksgiving itself. Generally, if you're serving the usual array of sides, people don't take an enormous amount of turkey. If you really want to make sure there is enough for sandwiches, you can set some aside in advance.
The timing instructions should be the same if. you use the wet brine. Don't rely on those recommendations, however. Use a probe thermometer to start checking early. Mine always seem to take less time than I expect.
Here is a note of caution, however. Your bird is at the top of the range of ideal weights for spatchcocking a turkey.
It is critical therefore that you either cut out the keel bone completely (I've never been able to do it myself, so get your butcher to do it for you, if possible), or at least snip around it part way to release the meat attached to it, and then cut the keel bone down the middle from the top a good inch or two, if you can. You may have to break it by pressing down very hard on the outside of the bird at the top. Breaking it is okay. The point is that with a turkey breast that size, you must flatten it out well, to allow it to cook properly all the way through.
I had a situation a few years ago when some of the breast meat looked a little pink after I'd removed the bird from the oven, started carving, etc., despite correct internal temperatures on my probe thermometer. I sliced it anyway and then dropped the slices in a skillet with some hot gravy for about 1 minute, which completed the cooking quite nicely.
Have fun! ;o)
Makingheadlines
November 17, 2022
Got it. Thanks. I have the butcher spatchcocking it for me. I'll call in advance to give them that direction and remember I must have it completely flat.
Makingheadlines
November 17, 2022
And can I use my old school meat thermometer my mom gave me years ago -- you know it's got a round head with numbers on it and it has a pointy end to go into the meat or is there something new I need to buy?
AntoniaJames
November 17, 2022
That meat thermometer should be okay. Check it by putting it in some boiling water to confirm that it is accurate (it should be 212 degrees, if you live at or near sea level). ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 17, 2022
Be very clear with them that they must "remove the keel bone." That should do the trick. I'm guessing that they are getting a lot of requests for that these days. When you go to pick it up (perhaps before they go back into the cold room to get your order for you), ask them to check, to confirm that they removed the keel bone. With the craziness those workers are dealing with this week, details like that could be overlooked.
And make sure they give you the back and neck! You'll want those for making gravy - ahead of time. ;o)
And make sure they give you the back and neck! You'll want those for making gravy - ahead of time. ;o)
Wonderwoman984
November 24, 2022
I use a full sheet pan. I'm roasting a 22lb hen. I lay the seasoned turkey on a bed of onions, carrots, celery, rosemary, sage & lemon. Comes put perfectly every time. I baste a with white/melted butter combo
Pickyeeee
November 26, 2021
Help! My butcher gave me a butterflied turkey but removed ALL the bones, I am now left with a completely boneless turkey that is kept intact via the breast and its ski . I was really looking forward to doing this spatchcocked recipe, any ideas on cooking times and temperatures or methods for this unfortunate circumstance?
AntoniaJames
November 16, 2022
How much does it weigh? Yes, the time will be much less. It almost doesn't matter how much it weighs, as you'll want to start, early, to check the temperature.
For a 14-pound turkey I'd reduce the initial browning phase by 10 minutes and then start checking with a probe thermometer after 45 minutes, keeping a close eye on it and checking frequently, as it no doubt will roast very quickly.
Checking the internal temperature though is absolutely the only way to do this.
Please let us know how long it takes and how the turkey turns out! Thank you. ;o)
For a 14-pound turkey I'd reduce the initial browning phase by 10 minutes and then start checking with a probe thermometer after 45 minutes, keeping a close eye on it and checking frequently, as it no doubt will roast very quickly.
Checking the internal temperature though is absolutely the only way to do this.
Please let us know how long it takes and how the turkey turns out! Thank you. ;o)
saucy S.
November 24, 2021
Question…..do you not put some butter on the bird before roasting?
AntoniaJames
November 24, 2021
I do not. The high heat brings the juices out of the skin right away, which seem to be all that's necessary. You could, of course, brush melted butter on it if you wanted to. I've never tried it, but I've seen recipes where others do.
Happy Thanksgiving! ;o)
Happy Thanksgiving! ;o)
Kim
November 9, 2021
So easy after you spatchcock the bird, juicy, takes less time to cook. Easier to carve after
PhillipBrandon
November 22, 2020
We've taken to spatchcocking our turkey every year, mostly for speed (and one memorable instance, sheer geometry) but this year I'm wondering about those oven bags for cutting down on the scrubbing up. Is there any reason I couldn't roast my butterflied bird in a Reynolds sack?
AntoniaJames
November 23, 2020
If the sack is large enough, I can't see why not. I've never done it, but one would think it would work. The only issue I see is that, because you're essentially steaming the bird, you won't get the crispy dry skin. Does one take the bird out fo the bag for a final roast, to dry out and brown the skin? ;o)
PhillipBrandon
November 23, 2020
For the sake of the recently scrubbed oven walls, one might be removing it from the hot box entirely, and selectively torching it.
andi
November 19, 2020
A crazy question...our butcher ran out of small turkeys so we have 1/2 of a 26 pound one. Basically, it is spatchcocked...but my question is this: Do I cook it as a 13 pound turkey or 26? My concern is that the bird is "thicker" and not really the same as a real 13 pound one.
AntoniaJames
November 20, 2020
I'd start by using the 13 pound turkey as your guide, but check it of course and extend it a bit if necessary to cook the breast all the way through. For this, please use a probe thermometer. It's really the only way to know for sure. If you find when carving that you've ended up with breast meat closer to the bone that is just not cooked, chunks or slices of that can quickly finish cooking if you warm them for a few minutes in very hot gravy.
Happy Thanksgiving! ;o)
Happy Thanksgiving! ;o)
Risottogirl
November 17, 2020
This has been my go-to method for years...my grandmother did it this way but she'd likely never used the terms "spatchcock" or "dry brine". She called it a salt seasoned butterflied bird. LOL I have never found the drippings to be too salty for the gravy, but I use homemade double or triple turkey stock that has no salt added to it at all. This year I will be using the same method with a walnut fed turkey. Should be interesting!
Walter T.
November 30, 2019
Beest turkey I have ever prepared. Juicy with crispy skin. My guests were marveling. I am a convert. Never again a whole turkey -- only a spatchcoked one.
AntoniaJames
December 3, 2019
Walter, I'm delighted to hear that.
Thank you for your kind comment. ;o)
Thank you for your kind comment. ;o)
Ellzabeth R.
November 3, 2019
Back again...used this recipe with a small chicken that I butterflied...shorter time for everything...easily one of the most flavourful and best tasting dinner involving chicken that we have had. Will try the gravy next time too.
AntoniaJames
November 4, 2019
Thank you, Elizabeth, for this comment and the one you posted last month I'm honored - and so pleased - that (a) even a turkey hater in your midst liked it, and (b) that you used the recipe twice! ;o)
Ellzabeth R.
October 17, 2019
Used this turkey recipe last Sunday for our Canadian Thanksgiving for family and friends. I've butterflied chickens and turkeys for a long time now, my preferred way of cooking them, but although the results were good, this one was the best. We had other meat offerings as one part of the family has always expressed a dislike of turkey. The best vote for this recipe came from a 16 year old youngster who was helping her Dad carve the bird by arranging it on a platter and she turned to me and stated that she hadn't liked turkey at all but this was delicious and she couldn't help tasting little slices of it as she worked. This is our new go-to for turkey in the future! Thank-you!
Stephen M.
December 25, 2018
Just cooked a 16 pound turkey. Followed the recipe precisely and roasted the bird on my Camp Chef pellet smoker. I Pre-heated at 400 and turned it down to 325 immediately. Covered the breast and leg tips with foil after an hour. The breast hit 150* after two hours.
It was the juiciest bird ever; perfectly cooked! The pellet smoker did not impart a smoky taste at all. It was just a delicious turkey.
It was the juiciest bird ever; perfectly cooked! The pellet smoker did not impart a smoky taste at all. It was just a delicious turkey.
Lynn S.
November 25, 2018
I prepared this according to the recipe and it was GREAT! We had a 12 1/2 lb. turkey and it only took about an hour and a half to cook and was so flavorful. I used a rack over a baking sheet and put sliced lemon underneath the bird while it cooked. I was worried that it might be too salty with the dry brine but it was perfect. Thanks for this recipe!
Arlene
December 26, 2017
Spatchcocked my first turkey yesterday and it was, hands down, the tastiest turkey ever! I used your tutorial for cooking times only and it was spot on. I have an electric oven so am unsure about my oven temperatures. Checking the temp after roasting 4 minutes per pound is very wise advice so you can adjust cooking times as necessary. If you like dressing, try putting bread pieces (14 oz french bread, white bread, whatever kind you like) underneath and around your bird, mixed with minced veggies: 2 onions, 4 celery stalks and 5 cloves garlic, sauteed in 1T Sage, 1T Thyme and 4T butter. Pour just a little broth (maybe 1 cup) over the bread before roasting the bird. When the turkey is done you just spoon the dressing into a container and voilà! you have delicious dressing!
AntoniaJames
December 26, 2017
Thanks, Arlene. I'm so glad the timing suggestions worked for you! I've been doing this for a number of years, always with a smaller bird. After learning of some discouraging results with larger birds, I researched the roast time point - and must give the good people at SeriousEats.com credit for the updated rubric. I followed those guidelines this Thanksgiving and all agreed that it was my best turkey ever.
Great idea to put the stuffing ingredients under the bird. I will try that next time. Happy New Year! ;o)
Great idea to put the stuffing ingredients under the bird. I will try that next time. Happy New Year! ;o)
jodyrah
November 20, 2017
Nothing revolutionary. Mark Bittman did this in 2002.
AntoniaJames
November 20, 2017
jodyrah, no one here is claiming that it's revolutionary. May I respectfully suggest that the dry brine (not in Bittman's recipe) results in a superior, beautifully flavored, moist turkey? As noted in the headnote, that dry brine is borrowed with gratitude from Judy Rodgers - also not revolutionary, but if I may say so, a good idea. ;o)
jodyrah
November 24, 2017
I actually dry brine using kosher salt and baking powder (seriouseats.com). I put a compound butter (garlic, fresh herbs, lemon zest, and a bit of minced Thai chili) beneath the skin. Spatchcocked breast, roasted 450’. I use a meat probe so only an occasional check for over browning. Stock, garlic, quartered onions, meyer lemon, herbs in the pan makes for a wonderful gravy.
AntoniaJames
November 24, 2017
Sounds great, jodyrah. So many good suggestions here. I haven't tried the baking powder . . . have had good success with the herbs + salt, but I admire and trust Kenji so I'll look into this. Thanks for the tips! ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 20, 2017
To update this, to reflect the concerns of those with much larger birds: The 10 minutes per pound rule does not seem to have worked for some who used it on bigger turkeys. I tested this recipe on a smaller turkey and had to rely on someone else (it happened to be Melissa Clark of the New York Times) when scaling it up. Based on the comments below, my original instructions apparently recommend a much longer roasting time than is necessary. For birds in the 20+ pound range, please start checking at 2 hours and, as noted, put foil on the breast when it starts looking very dark. I see in one comment that someone with a 25 pound bird found it was done in 2 1/4 hour. Those with medium size birds, say 16 pounds, should check after 1 1/2 hours. Results can vary widely due to differences in ovens' heating and insulating properties, how often they're opened and shut, etc. The key here is to start checking the internal temperature early to prevent overcooking. ;o)
P.S. I'm going to ask the editors to revise the instructions in this recipe to reflect this additional information. I cannot do it because the recipe was a contest finalist and therefore is locked down.
P.S. I'm going to ask the editors to revise the instructions in this recipe to reflect this additional information. I cannot do it because the recipe was a contest finalist and therefore is locked down.
Minnie
November 25, 2016
I tried this yesterday and it was done at least 1 1/4 hours earlier than the instructions indicated per pound. I had a 16 pound bird (before taking out backbone). I've done spatchcock turkeys before and they turned out great. The legs on this one turned out like jerky, as previous comments say. I do not recommend this recipe, the times are very off. Very.
AntoniaJames
November 20, 2017
Minnie, I am so sorry to hear that. I will post another comment with more details on this, in the hopes that people looking at this recipe will scroll down to see it. ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 21, 2017
The instructions above have been revised to address the roasting time issues raised in this and several other comments. (Thank you, Lindsay-Jean!) ;o)
Ms. T.
November 25, 2016
Great recipe, I love this method! Except for one thing...I've followed this method for the last two years and both times the breast was perfectly cooked and moist and delicious, but the legs were dried out and practically turkey jerked :( The first year I thought it was just because I didn't have the right size pan and so the legs were sticking off the pan with a cookie sheet underneath and I thought I must've created some uneven temps in my oven. But I tried again this year with proper pan and same deal. Small turkey--only 10 lbs. Was done in an hour. Anyone else have this problem and/or ideas to prevent it next time?
Ms. T.
November 25, 2016
I meant "turkey jerky" not "jerked"...but a Carribbean spiced turkey is not a bad idea...
carlos
November 25, 2016
Haha love both jerky and jerked! 😀 Our 25 bird cooked in about 2 and a quarter hours and the legs did the same this year. Maybe it's about lowering the heat from 400?
AntoniaJames
November 21, 2017
Ms. T, I'm sorry to hear about the dried out legs (but happy to hear that the breast was perfect!) Try putting some foil on the drumsticks about half way through. Happy Thanksgiving! ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 21, 2017
Carlos, I've never actually roasted a bird this large, but based on the extensive research I've done using reliable sources (primarily on Serious Eats), I think your suggestion is probably correct -- the temperature in your case should be a bit lower. And you definitely should put some foil on the drumsticks, even with the lower temperature. ;o)
Anna M.
November 24, 2016
This is the 3rd year we are spatchcocking a 30 lb turkey and we can never go back to the traditional, dry, way too time consuming way of cooking a turkey again! This is the easiest and tastiest way to cook turkeys! It is so much tastier, crispy on the outside, moist on the inside, and evenly cooked! Just remember to wrap the wings and legs in foil for a little longer then the first half of the cooking time, so they don't dry out. Antonia James, you have the best, step by step article I have found to date, and thank you for stating the amount of time per pound with this method. (No one else has!) Happy Thanksgiving! Anna Marie & Family
Anna M.
November 24, 2016
I do not know why my comment is posted 3 times and I can not find a way to remove them. I do not brine and add salt & pepper before I place it in the oven and it comes out perfect. I do the stuffing separately in a large baking dish so it gets that golden brown crunchy top layer. Happy Thanksgiving!
Anna M.
November 24, 2016
This is the 3rd year we are spatchcocking a 30 lb turkey and we can never go back to the traditional, dry, way too time consuming way of cooking a turkey again! This is the easiest and tastiest way to cook turkeys! It is so much tastier, crispy on the outside, moist on the inside, and evenly cooked! Just remember to wrap the wings and legs in foil for a little longer then the first half of the cooking time, so they don't dry out. Antonia James, you have the best, step by step article I have found to date, and thank you for stating the amount of time per pound with this method. (No one else has!) Happy Thanksgiving! Anna Marie & Family
Anna M.
November 24, 2016
This is the 3rd year we are spatchcocking a 30 lb turkey and we can never go back to the traditional, dry, way too time consuming way of cooking a turkey again! This is the easiest and tastiest way to cook turkeys! It is so much tastier, crispy on the outside, moist on the inside, and evenly cooked! Just remember to wrap the wings and legs in foil for a little longer then the first half of the cooking time, so they don't dry out. Antonia James, you have the best, step by step article I have found to date, and thank you for stating the amount of time per pound with this method. (No one else has!) Happy Thanksgiving! Anna Marie & Family
placidplaid
November 24, 2014
I showed this recipe to a friend of mine and he wondered what size oven you'd need to accomodate the flattened out bird. He also thought it would be dry.
AntoniaJames
November 24, 2014
A standard 30" oven is plenty large, even for a large bird. We have never had a problem with the bird being dry (especially when prepared with the dry rub as suggested), and in fact, it's amazing how juicy it is. The cooking time is greatly reduced. Overcooking is what dries out turkey. I haven't heard of any complaints from anyone else on this. ;o)
Maria C.
November 23, 2014
This will be my first time ever cooking a turkey and I want to try this. I will be using a 24 pound turkey, what size pan or sheet should I use? Also, did you put the water into the pan with the turkey?
AntoniaJames
November 23, 2014
I don't know about the size of the pan, as I've never roasted one that large. I'll post a question over on the hotline about that. As for adding water, yes, I usually put just a bit in the roasting pan when I put the bird in, to keep the initial drippings, etc. from burning. Liquid is released during cooking, which tends to keep things in order, but I would keep an eye on it and add a bit more during the cooking, if necessary. (Good question!) ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 24, 2014
Maria, here is the link to the Hotline discussion: https://food52.com/hotline/26727-how-large-a-baking-sheet-or-roasting-pan-should-be-used-for-a-24-lb-spatchcocked-butterflied-turke ;o)
Paula B.
January 11, 2014
There is one thing that bothers me about so many recipes...too complicated! First one must learn basics to branch out. As a trained chef...now retired, I must say to all I coach...make it simple...relax...enjoy. Most posted recipes skip basics and jump right into a more advanced level. Consiquently people give up or get scared and do something wrong. Spatchcocking a bird is very simple. (see my other post below.) Cut the bird's back top to bottom...cut off all the extraneous fat and tissue and put in a generous pot...then add tail, neck and gizzards all and onion skins and onion ends...celery bottom and wilted top, maybe tomato stem ends if you are using tomato for ...say salad...throw in the stem parts and cover all with water...bring to a boil and immediately turn to simmer...start this before turkey goes into oven. When turkey is done, and resting covered on counter....pour simmered liquid through 3 layers of cheesecloth in a strainer....discard all solids and skim as much fat as possible off liquid. You now have a very tasty liquid for gravy....add a bit of Soy sauce for added color and a bit more flavor. thicken anf grave is ready.
The Aleppo pepper I use quite a bit, is deceiving...use too much and you can get into trouble. But an adequate amount will leave a very nice taste in your mouth after you finish eating the food it is in.
The Aleppo pepper I use quite a bit, is deceiving...use too much and you can get into trouble. But an adequate amount will leave a very nice taste in your mouth after you finish eating the food it is in.
AC
November 18, 2020
It bothers you that recipes sound complicated. Okay. I think the recipe was pretty clear and easy. You add the following which I think would scare off a novice in the kitchen: Cut the bird's back top to bottom...cut off all the extraneous fat and tissue and put in a generous pot...then add tail, neck and gizzards all and onion skins and onion ends...celery bottom and wilted top, maybe tomato stem ends if you are using tomato for ...say salad...throw in the stem parts and cover all with water...bring to a boil and immediately turn to simmer...start this before turkey goes into oven. When turkey is done, and resting covered on counter....pour simmered liquid through 3 layers of cheesecloth in a strainer....discard all solids and skim as much fat as possible off liquid. Who the hell wants to do all this while the bird is resting and they probably have a house full of guests? This is something you do beforehand, not at crunch time if you are not advanced.
Paula B.
January 11, 2014
The best I have found is a rub w/o salt...
1/2 cup tuscan seasoning
2 T Aleppo ground pepper flakes
4-6 cloves garlic very fine chopped
mix together well then add just enough olive oil to make a paste,
rub all all over the prepped (Spatchcock) bird
let stand 1/2 hour to an hour depending on size
and cook at 425 till golden
and you can feel the leg joint moving when you twist it gently
I do not remove backbone but smack it flat
1/2 cup tuscan seasoning
2 T Aleppo ground pepper flakes
4-6 cloves garlic very fine chopped
mix together well then add just enough olive oil to make a paste,
rub all all over the prepped (Spatchcock) bird
let stand 1/2 hour to an hour depending on size
and cook at 425 till golden
and you can feel the leg joint moving when you twist it gently
I do not remove backbone but smack it flat
calendargirl
November 11, 2013
AJ, this was just the best last year and we are going to do it again this year. There is no reason to do a turkey any other way. Warmest greetings to you and yours!
Connie C.
November 6, 2013
I agree that Antonia's directions are the best I've ever read..Julia's weren't so easy in her first two books!!
Will be enjoying Thanksgiving with Newlyweds ( daughter and son-in-law ) in SF and plan on cooking our turkey this way! Have been cooking chicken like this for years but never thought of doing a turkey! Brilliant! My vote is for you!!
Will be enjoying Thanksgiving with Newlyweds ( daughter and son-in-law ) in SF and plan on cooking our turkey this way! Have been cooking chicken like this for years but never thought of doing a turkey! Brilliant! My vote is for you!!
dymnyno
November 22, 2012
This is the first time I have ever butterflied a turkey. I thought that I was going to have to bring out a chainsaw (my shears are in need of sharpening...maybe?) I won't do it any other way now. It took a little less than 2 hours for a 14 pound turkey and it looks evenly browned and perfectly cooked. I hope you had a great hike today (we did!) and enjoy a wonderful Thanksgiving with your husband and dear boys.
maryvelasquez
November 22, 2012
I am thankful for the clear advice of AntoniaJames and my new poultry sheers! Can't wait to see how this turns out.
Whats4Dinner
November 19, 2012
Ah, and so it begins.....the bird is here, butterflied, I've yet to pull out the food processor to process the salt and herbs, but here we go!
fiveandspice
November 14, 2012
Congrats again on being a finalist AJ! This simply a gorgeous recipe.
aargersi
November 14, 2012
Congratulation to you - I for sure want to try this - I started small on a cornish hen :-) but building my way up to a turkey. GREAT recipe!!!
hardlikearmour
November 14, 2012
Congrats on a great recipe! I for one will never cook a whole turkey that isn't spatchcocked again.
Kathy K.
November 14, 2012
Spatchcocking a turkey is made easier using your handy dandy kitchen mallet or a clean hammer. Put your cleaver or heaviest knife parallel to the side of the backbone at the point where the ribs attach. WHACK the thickest part of the knife. Repeat going down. I use the scissors to clip the soft tissue after the bone is cut. I also use the whacked knife technique to massage large squashes and rutabaga apart. It is much safer to have your hands distant from the sharp knife and whack than to struggle inside a cold, slippery buzzard with scissors. Finally, the funitude factor with turkey whacking is awesome. Be sure to have timid folks watch. It REALLY makes the cook look authoritative!
ChocolateDiva
November 14, 2012
My turkey was 16 pounds. I used a cookie sheet. I put chopped onions, celery and carrots on the cookie sheet then put the turkey on the rack on top of the vegetables with one cup of broth. You make gravy from these drippings.
Spatchcocked turkey is really great---it cooks so much quicker. However, much easier to have the butcher do this.
Spatchcocked turkey is really great---it cooks so much quicker. However, much easier to have the butcher do this.
ChocolateDiva
November 12, 2012
Your are oh so right about having the butcher remove the back bone. I always do this but my son brought home a frozen turkey from work and I was only able to cut down one side, but it worked. It still lay out flat like yours. My recipe is a little different, I cook it at 325 degrees.
Congrats on being a finalist! ! !
Congrats on being a finalist! ! !
Stubor
November 11, 2012
I really enjoy your writing style, Ms. James. You remind me of Julia Child ("and one for cook!" & "The best way to execute French cooking is to get good and loaded and whack the hell out of a chicken. Bon appétit.")
NakedBeet
November 9, 2012
I love all the explicit instructions..something I have a tendency to do myself. Because I can't decide on which recipe for the vote, I'm going to combine the best of both worlds. I just read a long article on the non-merits of brining from serious eats, but this looks different and too good to pass up, plus the fact that you've been trying out different methods for 35 years, has me convinced. ; )
Kitchen F.
November 9, 2012
What a great idea! You have made something that looks so intimidating seem so easy. I am keen to try it. Congratulations on being a finalist.
Jaynerly
November 9, 2012
Wonderful! I tried the Judy dry brine last year and loved it! I was left with a turkey that just about filled the oven though so spatchcocking is such a clever plan, a very worthy finalist congratulations!
EmilyC
November 9, 2012
Congrats on your well-deserved finalist nod AJ! This is such a smart recipe, sure to be made in lots of households this Thanksgiving!
Kukla
November 9, 2012
Many congratulations AJ!!! You are not only a wonderful cook, but also a great teacher and a talented recipe writer!
Fairmount_market
November 8, 2012
I can't wait to try this! Such wonderful detailed instructions filled with common sense. I love the idea of having more room in the oven for sides.
Greenstuff
November 8, 2012
From the minute I saw this recipe, it had "finalist" written all over it. We don't generally do a turkey for the big holidays (family quirk), but I've spatchcocked enough chickens to know that this is a keeper. Besides the faster, more even cooking you get with a flattened bird, think of it--you might get 2 turkeys in your oven at once!
ChezBob
November 8, 2012
Spatchcocked chicken is my # 1 method of cooking. As in the chicken recipe, the turkey should be weighted down to achieve the required bonding with the pan. Suggest two bricks wrapped in foil. It also helps to pound the turkey vigorously prior to cooking. My experience is that the flatter the bird against the hot surface the quicker it is done and the meat is juicier.
bobhallsr
bobhallsr
mariaraynal
November 8, 2012
So smart, with great tips and instructions, AntoniaJames. Congrats on being a finalist!
aargersi
November 8, 2012
Congratulations AJ on being a finalist! This is one beautiful bird and on my To Try list!!!
mrslarkin
November 8, 2012
Congrats AJ! I've got a sage salted turkey breast on the menu for tonight's dinner, to celebrate the return of our electricity.
Sf2oak
November 8, 2012
I need to cook a kosher turkey which is already salted, how would you suggest I deal with that? I'm always afraid of adding salt to kosher meat products because they are already salted. TIA
AntoniaJames
November 8, 2012
You definitely should not salt it. Here's what I'd do. The night before, I'd just finely chop the herbs by themselves, and perhaps use a few more of them, and very gently lift up the skin on the breast, taking great care not to tear it, and push some of them inside. I'd then rub the rest of them into the outside of the bird, and the underside of the cavity. Then I'd put it in the fridge, uncovered in a bowl or on a plate if you have enough room, to let it dry out overnight. This creates the crisp skin. Some of the herbs will most likely come off in the water that no doubt will drain; so I'd probably rub a few fresh herbs into it again, right before roasting. You might want to ask this question on the Hotline, too, to get the collective wisdom of the community. ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 8, 2012
Okay, I just took a look over on the Hotline to see if this issue has been addressed by others in the past. There seems to be a difference of opinion on this, so you probably should ask the question again over there, to see if anyone reading it this year knows for sure. My experience with kosher chickens is that they are perfectly seasoned, for my taste at least, without any additional salt. I don't know if that's the case with kosher turkeys. I suppose though that it ultimately comes down to how much salt is used, how carefully it's rinsed and whether it's been injected with a brine solution (a practice that seems to be common these days among a lot of commercial poultry processors). ;o)
AntoniaJames
November 8, 2012
Alright, I just sent a note to Russ Parsons, who published the original "Judy Bird" recipe in the L.A. Times about five years ago. He's a great guy. (Everyone should own and read his tremendously useful "How to Pick a Peach".) Anyway, he said that there yes, you can use the dry salt brine method with a kosher bird, as there is not enough salt flavor left, after they rinse it, to make a difference. So, there you have it. From the expert. Sorry about all the back and forth on this. ;o) P.S. I'd still be cautious, and make sure I had a bird that had not been injected with a brine solution.
calendargirl
November 8, 2012
Oh, this will be the one for us this year! After spatchcocking a chicken I wondered about doing it with a turkey and vowed to try it, but you have worked out all the bugs for us. Thank you so much, AJ! I will raise my wine glass to you, too.
AntoniaJames
November 8, 2012
calendargirl, you are too kind. Thank the Hotline and this wonderful community for this recipe. I would never have tried it without their help. I hope you do try this, and enjoy it. ;o)
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2012
Oh dear! I've been traveling on vacation for nearly a week, and just read through this on my full screen. There's an error in Step 12 -- the foil should be removed from the breast and placed over the legs of the bird while it's resting. Sorry about that! ;o)
judyschwab
October 22, 2012
We spatchcock the dry-brined turkey and then barbecue. But the cooking times are even more volatile with the added variable of charcoal. It's always raining, but the wine helps. Turkey is delicious and lots more room in the oven for sides. Make ahead gravy especially important if you're barbecuing.
Love your dry-brining tips. I'll definitely use them this year. Thanks!!!
Love your dry-brining tips. I'll definitely use them this year. Thanks!!!
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2012
Thanks, judyschwab. "Always raining but the wine helps" cracked me up! ;o)
wssmom
October 21, 2012
I loved the spatchcocked and braised chicken recipe and always wondered how it would fare with a turkey! Winner!
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2012
Thanks, wssmom! I started with chickens and moved to turkeys, with the help (a lot of help!) from the Hotline. It really works well. Try it! ;o)
Miafoodie
October 17, 2012
Spatchcocking is new to me but I am definitly a convert. Love the fact that the skin is
crispy all over. Thanks for your very specific instructions, i.e. celery rack holders and of course the wine.
crispy all over. Thanks for your very specific instructions, i.e. celery rack holders and of course the wine.
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2012
Yes, the crispy skin is amazing. One of many good reasons to spatchcock the bird! ;o)
arielleclementine
October 16, 2012
This is amazing! I'm going to try it for thanksgiving this year! Thank you thank you!
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2012
I hope you do! Easiest turkey I've ever made, leaving plenty of time, and room in your oven, for all the other delicious things you'll be serving. ;o)
mrslarkin
October 16, 2012
As I expected, a winning submission from you, AJ. I love the way the skin on the spatchcocked bird is uniformly crispy. Also, I love your celery/cooling rack kitchen hack.
AntoniaJames
October 16, 2012
Thanks, mrslarkin! I learned the hard way that using carrots for this purpose can be tricky, if you don't make sure there's a lot of liquid in the bottom of the pan, as they can easily over-caramelize, which makes the pan juices taste weird (a little bitter). Celery releases so much juice, and has a lot less sugar in it, so it tends to work much better. ;o)
drbabs
October 16, 2012
This is really a great way to roast turkey. Thanks for the meticulously detailed instructions.
AntoniaJames
October 16, 2012
Thanks so much, drbabs! I just realized that one entire step was dropped when I first published this yesterday, regarding the variability in roasting time required, especially for a larger bird. So I fixed it. ;o)
hardlikearmour
October 15, 2012
Since spatchcocking a couple of turkeys last year, I'll probably never go back to cooking them any other way! Love your added wine step, too.
inpatskitchen
October 15, 2012
Oh my! What a wonderful way to cook a bird! Love the 2 glasses of wine!
AntoniaJames
October 16, 2012
Thanks, ipk! I started pouring a glass of wine for any bird I roast, and one for me, many years ago. For a bird that's not brined, it makes the pan juices and gravy heavenly. But I've found also that it's a great idea even if you're not using the pan juices, because the fruit sugars in the wine makes the skin extra tasty. ;o)
See what other Food52ers are saying.