Winter
Schiacciata alla Fiorentina
Popular on Food52
18 Reviews
Jigger
May 8, 2023
This recipe lacks fluid except for the small amount for yeast: add fluid amount (water or milk) otherwise the recipe is useless, especially to novice bakers…
Emiko
May 9, 2023
Did you have trouble making this cake? I have tested and eaten this very traditional Florentine cake many, many times and I can assure you that there is sufficient liquid (including butter, eggs, etc just like most cake recipes). As I have answered to some of the comments below, you want enough water to make a dough with the flour -- the exact amount of water isn't so important, but I would start with about 1/2 cup of water or enough so that the flour turns to a dough -- you will see as you are mixing it in and you should do it bit by bit. If you use too little water, the flour will be crumbly and too much the flour will be like a batter and neither of these are "doughs". Depending on where you live and the climate, as well as the hydration and age of your flour, you may need a little more or a little less than what I've suggested. So it really is best to go by feel and look. I hope that this makes sense for you.
Rose
January 1, 2017
Made it twice and ruined both times. Don't know if it is the area or the measurements that it is not coming out right.
Emiko
June 29, 2020
In ingredients list it says 'fresh yeast dissolved in some water'. It's not an exact recipe, no, but that's because you don't need an 'exact' or a significant amount of water for this, the dough/batter for this cake is mostly made with the butter, sugar and eggs (like most cakes). The water is just to dissolve the yeast in and make it active, but if you need an indication, I would say use about 1/2 cup. Hope that helps you.
Dorene
October 22, 2014
I USE TO HAVE THIS WITH GRAPES DROPPED ON TOP OF THE BATTER AND COARSE SUGAR AND CHOPPED FRESH ROSEMARY BEFORE BAKING. E BUONA
Lorenza
March 22, 2014
Please advise as to the amount of water called for in step one of the recipe; "combine the flour and fresh yeast (along with the water)" I do not find that measurement in the list of ingredients or the written instructions. Grazie
Emiko
March 23, 2014
Thanks for pointing out that this isn't clear enough for some readers, Lorenza. It's the sort of recipe (like many traditional recipes) that are passed on with measurements by eye and feel! In the list of ingredients you'll see "fresh yeast dissolved in some warm water." This is the water you will be adding to the flour. It doesn't need to be much, just enough to loosen the yeast and create a dough with the flour - it doesn't need to be a precise amount, but you can aim for using about 1/2 cup and just watch as you're adding until you get a dough. If it's too much, leave it as is, if it's too little, add some extra water. I hope this helps.
Amber
March 13, 2014
Can it substitute dry yeast for fresh in this recipe?
Emiko
March 14, 2014
Yes you can, you'll just want to make sure you get the right ratios when substituting dry (7 grams of dry yeast should work for this recipe). This article has some more info too: http://food52.com/blog/5036-demystifying-yeast
Amber
March 14, 2014
Made the cake this morning and it is delightful! The 7 grams you recommended worked well and I found the article very informative - thank you! I used butter but was tempted to try the olive oil. Would you use the same amount (100 grams) for the olive oil? I used about 3/4 cup warm water with dry yeast to get a dough consistency. Didn't know how fluid (olive oil) vs. butter might affect the cake.
Emiko
March 14, 2014
Substituting olive oil for butter you generally use a little less oil than the butter required (there's a chart here that gives you an idea: http://thefamilydinnerbook.com/tips/2014/01/08/using-olive-oil-instead-of-butter-for-baking/) so for 100 grams (about 1/2 cup) you could go 1/4 cup according to this chart. I've never tried it myself but I've seen quite a few of schiacciata alla fiorentina recipes that use it. So happy to hear you had good results!
See what other Food52ers are saying.