Serves a Crowd
Strawberry Pop-Tart Slab Pie Dessert
Popular on Food52
25 Reviews
rachelk2
January 15, 2024
worth the work! major favorite in our house.
would strain the strawberry mixture as the liquid causes some issues when baking.
would strain the strawberry mixture as the liquid causes some issues when baking.
cjane
July 5, 2021
Perfect for Fourth of July! First slab pie I ever made and it was delightful. Will be making it again!
BruceDK
February 28, 2021
It is crazy how good this is!!! I’ve made a few times. I strongly suggest spraying top layer parchment pieces with cooking spray. My dough stuck to parchment first time. The filling is perfectly sweet and the dough really holds up in all its buttery deliciousness!!!
Gigi
May 24, 2019
Sorry to share but this was not at all like a strawberry pop tart & resulted more like a strawberry pie. The filling was not jam-like as a pop tart is; the crust was a flaky pie crust rather than a pastry pocket dough. Disappointed. 🍓💔
Rebecca
October 20, 2018
Love this! 😍 I did a giant brown sugar cinnamon one: http://thedoughtydoughnut.com/giant-brown-sugar-cinnamon-pop-tart-recipe/
upsidedown
December 29, 2017
I made this today and it was amazing! Everything about it was perfect! Thanks for sharing the recipe. It will stay in my archives for sure.
Becca R.
May 29, 2017
How is this possibly enough dough for a double crust? Even with rolling it very thin I couldn't get it to cover the bottom of the pan, let alone hang over the sides. I had to double the recipe and then had a little extra dough.
Joy H.
May 29, 2017
Hmmm, I don't remember having that issue, and I've made this multiple times. Were you using a 9 x 13" pan or a larger pan?
Amanda B.
October 23, 2016
Okay, I agree with everyone else that this is a top-notch recipe. Just made it for my husbands birthday and it was SUCH a crowd pleaser. Yeah, the filling leaked a little on the corners but that made it all the more rustic and charming. I will be exploring other flavors, including Montana huckleberry.
Val F.
September 10, 2016
I made this tonight and my family and I just finished eating it. I was joking that my final result would be like the nailed it memes but I really did nail it! It was easier than I thought-perhaps the hardest part was the crust but I've never been great at pastry. Despite my inexperience this turned out so absolutely delish! And it was sooooo cute! I love everything about this recipe. It made us all nostalgic for a food that has been a guilty pleasure, something we hate to love...pop tarts. This pie is what you wish pop tarts tasted like. Wonderful! Great idea, delicious desert!
KellyDC
September 6, 2016
How sturdy is the final product? I'm wondering if this should be baked on the back of a pan. I can see it breaking during the transfer to a cutting board, even with a parchment sling, so maybe sliding it off would help preserve the size/shape.
Joy H.
September 6, 2016
I haven't had any issues with transferring the pie once it's cooled. If anything, the biggest issue I've had is with the filling leaking out of the pie, in which case baking on the back of the pan probably wouldn't be a great idea.
Janelle
September 4, 2016
How long do you allow the pie to cool on the pan before removing? Is it fully cooled or still a little warm?
Joy H.
September 4, 2016
If you have the time and patience, I would go for fully cooled to room temperature. This is mostly so that the glaze can set. If you're not as worried about aesthetics though, slightly warm is probably fine.
ageekymom
May 31, 2015
This looks amazing! Do you think it would hold for a day before serving? I want to serve it for the 4th of July, but I will be staying at a motel, so I would have to make it ahead 1-2 days. Thanks!
Joy H.
May 31, 2015
I don't think it would go bad, but the crust might get a little soggy. Let me know how it goes!
See what other Food52ers are saying.