Fall
Tomato Soup and Saint-André Waffled Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Popular on Food52
12 Reviews
Ruth
January 29, 2023
I have not made this but I read the recipe through 3 times. Based on the ingredients and the methodology, this recipe will produce a lackluster and disappointing meal. The volume of some of the ingredients are off, i.e. cream and bread slices. This supposedly serves 4, yet makes 8 sandwiches. I really wanted to like this recipe but I'll stick with my tried and true homemade tomato soup recipe and grilled cheese.
Shines
January 23, 2023
Love the concepts in this recipe. Based on the recipe pic, I was concerned about the amount of cream and half and half, and I’m glad I read the reviews. I ended up doing half the dairy, adding two cans of diced tomatoes (drained), and doing the lightest pinch of clove. Was plenty flavorful and rich. I tend to agree that the St. Andre didn’t add much in flavor profile, but quite a lot in cleanup. I added a sliced mild cheese that I had on hand (Muenster) just to hold things together.
Arthur G.
May 25, 2020
I really don't think the St Andre grilled sandwiches can possibly work. Has this recipe even been tested?
Karen
January 8, 2019
I wanted to love this recipe - the reviews were so nice, but it is bland and tasteless. After making it, I thought I must have missed something or mis-measured, but I went back and checked and nope, I did not. Perhaps it was my tomatoes, but the amount of dairy just dulls down the flavors and all you end up tasting is milky clove. The Saint Andre was also pretty flavorless and my waffle iron was drowning in oil. Love the suggestion of using gruyere instead. Sorry but no!
Bri L.
December 9, 2018
Oh dear...a beautifully ripe St André is butter around a just slightly solidified (and funkier tasting) cream. Nothing will keep this beauty from running—freezing or cooking it is tantamount to cheese abuse. Use a good 7 yr old cheddar...or a 1 yr raw milk, or a gruyere...but one that is better suited to the job at hand.
Courtney C.
February 11, 2016
These were quite good. I loved the soup though I had some difficulty with the sandwiches. The cheese completely melted out of them in the waffle iron. Any suggestions to keep that from happening next time? The cheese was St. Andre and it was chilled prior to cooking. Thanks!
Feed M.
February 11, 2016
could you try freezing the cheese for 20 minutes beforehand? Enough to get it really cold. I had some leakage, but most of the cheese stayed in, some cheeses are more ripe and liquid than others. Hope that helps! (jessica)
Courtney C.
February 11, 2016
Thanks so much for the quick reply! I'll definitely try freezing next time. The cheese that I bought was very creamy, so that was probably the issue. Still delicious though - thanks!
See what other Food52ers are saying.