New Classic Buttercream

October 16, 2014


Author Notes: This is real French buttercream reorganized to eliminate the trickiest steps. Traditional French buttercream requires pouring hot sugar syrup over eggs while beating steadily -- without scrambling them or splattering most of the syrup around the sides of the bowl. Then the mixture is reheated (to be sure that the eggs get cooked but not scrambled) and beaten again to cool before beating in the butter. Pastry chefs make this all the time, but home cooks are at a disadvantage because small batches are trickier than large batches. This recipe produces classic results with fewer, easier steps. Recipe from Flavor Flours: A New Way to Bake With Teff, Buckwheat, Sorghum, Other Whole and Ancient Grains, Nuts, and Non-Wheat Flours (Artisan, 2014).Alice Medrich

Makes: 3 cups, more than enough for one 8- or 9-inch layer cake

Ingredients

  • 4 large egg yolks or 2 whole large eggs, at room temperature
  • Large pinch of salt
  • 1/4 cup water
  • 2/3 cup sugar
  • 3/4 pound unsalted butter, slightly softened but not too squishy
In This Recipe

Directions

  1. Set a medium-fine strainer over the bowl of a stand mixer with the paddle attachment.
  2. In a medium stainless steel bowl (because glass bowls are too slow to heat), whisk the egg yolks (or whole eggs), salt, and water together thoroughly. Whisk in the sugar.
  3. Set the bowl in a wide skillet filled with enough hot water to reach above the depth of the egg mixture. Over medium heat, with a heatproof silicone spatula, stir the egg mixture, sweeping the sides and bottom of the bowl constantly to prevent the eggs from scrambling. Adjust the burner so the water barely simmers and continue to stir until the mixture registers between 175° F and 180° F on an instant-read thermometer. Swish the thermometer stem in the hot skillet water to rinse off the raw egg after reading the temperature each time.
  4. Remove the bowl from the skillet and scrape the mixture into the strainer. Rap the strainer to coax the mixture through it, but do not press on any bits that are left in the strainer. Turn the strainer and scrape the mixture clinging to the underside into the bowl of the stand mixer. Beat with the paddle attachment on high speed for 3 to 5 minutes, or until the mixture is cool and resembles a fluffy, foam-like soft whipped cream.
  5. Beat the butter into the foam a tablespoon at a time. The foam will deflate as you add the butter. If the butter is a little too cold, the mixture may curdle or separate at first, but it will smooth out as you continue to beat, and if it doesn’t you can set it in the warm water in the skillet for a few seconds and then continue to beat. If the foam is still warm or the butter too soft when you combine them, the buttercream will seem a little soupy instead of thick and creamy. If it doesn’t come together and thicken with beating, set the bowl in a bowl of ice and water or in the refrigerator for 5 to 10 minutes; then resume beating until the mixture is creamy and smooth.
  6. Use the buttercream right away or refrigerate it until needed. Buttercream keeps in a sealed container in the refrigerator for several days or in the freezer for 3 months. To soften, break chilled or frozen buttercream into chunks with a fork. Microwave on low for just a few seconds, then stir with a rubber spatula. Or set the bowl in hot water until some buttercream melts around the sides of the bowl. Remove the bowl and stir. If the buttercream is not smooth and spreadable, repeat the gentle warming and stirring steps until it is.

More Great Recipes:
Cake|5 Ingredients or Fewer|Summer|Fall|Winter|Fourth of July|Memorial Day|Valentine's Day|Spring|Dessert

Reviews (9) Questions (0)

9 Reviews

Jo August 26, 2017
Thank you for this recipe! I added some cooked sweetened berry purée at the end to frost my daughter's birthday cupcakes.
 
maggiesara April 29, 2017
This recipe is so good that it worked even when I made it for a Seder and had to substitute Earth Balance for the butter. It's fantastic, and I don't even LIKE buttercream. I don't think I'll ever use another recipe.
 
cybelesreverie January 25, 2016
I guess it's my fault for trying to halve the recipe, but I followed all the directions exactly except for that, and I ended up with a greasy, curdled mess.
 
runtothetable September 13, 2015
This is a fantastic recipe! So happy to have a go to buttercream recipe that's easy and tasty. I made it for the first time and doubled the recipe using only the egg yolks. I also added a dash of vanilla extract and a bit more salt. The doubled recipe iced the outside of three cakes - 12" round, 9" round, and 13 X 9". So good!
 
Michi September 13, 2015
Can you pipe this onto cupcakes or is it only for spreading on cakes? (I'm not really experienced with any form of cake decorating and don't know if there is a difference.)
 
just found this and wanted to say thank you for giving so much detail! i know many folks like short, "simple" recipes, but in my opinion, the more detail the better! leaving stuff like "rap the strainer but don't press bits" out of a recipe does not simplify things in the long run. <br />thanks for taking the time to develop this easier buttercream recipe! and sharing it in it's full glory! i've always been put off by the traditional buttercream method before, so i can't wait to try this one.
 
KH January 9, 2015
I have been eyeing this recipe for weeks now as I search for a good frosting for my baby's first birthday cake. She does fine with both eggs and butter so something like this in small amounts should be ok. I wanted to whip up coconut whipped cream because I'm making a gluten-free cake for her with coconut flour and she likes coconut. However I really cant get the coconut cream to whip despite all the tips I've read online. (Mind you I am absolutely a novice and have only ever made cake frosting once ever!) Well I like this recipe because egg yolks are very healthy and nutrient dense and will make a nice rich frosting without having to add a lot of sugar. Do you think I could replace the water with coconut milk to get a coconut type buttercream? I might try but do you imagine that might work ok?
 
Mary B. August 11, 2015
How about coconut water instead? Coconut milk has a totally different texture than water. Happy 1st Birthday to your girl!
 
mcs3000 October 22, 2014
Love Alice Medrich. James Ransom's picture is magnificent.