Popular on Food52
9 Reviews
Michael
December 16, 2019
I've made this soup several times and you'd think I'd have figured it out by now. With this recipe, I think that timing is everything! The soup becomes mush if you follow the directions implicitly. Personally, I think adding the carrots and cabbage at the end of process would yield more satisfactory results. I mean, who likes soggy carrots or cabbage, or a soup with the consistency of oatmeal anyway. Mrs. Thorrison is most certainly holding back some of her year of experience on this one. I do love the flavor though so, I’ll likely give another go, perhaps using instinct instead. I just wish I could nail the timing, find the perfect proportions and have a lovely clear broth in abundance instead of oatmeal. Having toothsome carrots and just wilted cabbage, and not to many beans, would be a wonderful thing too.
Matilda L.
November 11, 2014
I found that my ham hock was tender in 2 hours and 1 hour 15 minutes was ample time for the beans and potatoes. I assume the pig's tail will add gelatin (and therefore more body, or a richer, silkier mouth feel) to the broth.
Lisa M.
November 1, 2014
what does the pigs tail do for the recipe? what will be different about the soup without it?
Stunwin
October 31, 2014
So where does one find 2 lbs of smoked ham hock in the average grocery store? Is it just a matter of asking for a giant chunk-o-boar's head?
chris
October 30, 2014
This sounds delicious. Not a glamorous soup, but I'm looking forward to making it, this weekend. I'll be sure to raise a glass of Bordeaux, to Bernard.

See what other Food52ers are saying.