One-Pot Wonders

Chicken Thighs With Tomato, Orzo, Olives, & Feta

March  4, 2015
4.7
35 Ratings
Photo by Bobbi Lin
  • Serves 2 to 4
Author Notes

Last night, when I came up with this easy one pot of goodness, I was pretty excited and super satisfied. It’s a perfect, easy meal to throw together during the work week and there are leftovers for the next day’s lunch to boot. —onetinyspark

Test Kitchen Notes

I really liked the technique of toasting the orzo before cooking—it might be a gem of a trick for other pasta recipes. This is an all-around solid one pot meal, and especially nice using in-season tomatoes and basil (though it's best eaten day of). —emily olson

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 1/2 pounds boneless chicken thighs
  • 1 teaspoon dried oregano
  • 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika
  • 1/4 teaspoon red pepper flakes
  • 1 cup orzo
  • 3 garlic cloves, minced
  • 8 ounces grape tomatoes, halved
  • 1 1/2 cups low-sodium chicken broth
  • 1 tablespoon capers
  • 2 tablespoons Kalamata olives, halved
  • 1/4 to 1/2 cups crumbled feta
  • Fresh basil, chopped
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste
  • Drizzle of finishing olive oil
Directions
  1. First, toast the orzo. It’s a bit of a pain, but it really improves the flavor. Heat a large skillet or a Dutch oven if you’re so inclined (I find a reason to use my Staub cocotte for everything) over medium-high heat. Toast the orzo until it is lightly browned, but before it gets too fragrant. Spoon the orzo into a bowl and set aside.
  2. Next up is the chicken. Pat the thighs dry and season with oregano, paprika, salt, and pepper. Heat 1 tablespoon of olive oil in the skillet or Dutch oven on medium-high heat until it is nice and hot and beginning to smoke. Brown the chicken for roughly three minutes on each side, then remove it and set it aside. Turn the heat down a notch and add in the other tablespoon of oil and the minced garlic. Cook for 30 seconds, until fragrant, but be careful not to burn it. Then pour in the broth and throw in the tomatoes and orzo. Give the mixture a good stir and bring it to a boil.
  3. Finally, add the chicken back in, cover the skillet/Dutch oven, and let it sit on medium-low heat until the orzo is tender and the chicken is cooked through. This will take 15 minutes or so. Be sure to check on the dish from time to time as you don’t want the orzo to become mushy and overcooked.
  4. When ready, turn off the heat and add in the red pepper flakes, capers, Kalamata olives, feta, and basil. Top it all off with a drizzle of nice finishing oil, give it another good stir or two and you’re ready to serve!

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Rachel Jean Easton
    Rachel Jean Easton
  • Gluttonforacause
    Gluttonforacause
  • Joan Thompson
    Joan Thompson
  • Bethany
    Bethany
  • Michelle
    Michelle

77 Reviews

galsmu April 18, 2024
Love this! Pretty much stuck with the recipe. Just let each person add feta and red pepper flakes.
 
maggiesara June 13, 2023
Delicious, even (improbably enough) made with low-carb orzo. Only thing? Triple the tomatoes.
 
pamela May 27, 2023
What a treat! Toasting the orzo first gave this dish depth of flavor. I did add an extra cup of orzo (with appropriate extra broth) and some artichoke hearts I had leftover in the fridge. Absolutely delicious! This is a keeper.
 
Rachel J. October 23, 2022
I have consistently made this recipe every few months since I found it online during the pandemic and it is a hit every single time. My husband asks for it. 10/10. Thank you!
 
onetinyspark October 24, 2022
Love to hear it! Thank you for sharing. :)
 
Gluttonforacause August 22, 2021
This recipe is delicious and it always works. Full Stop.
 
onetinyspark August 22, 2021
So glad you enjoyed it!!
 
Quinn January 7, 2021
Thoroughly enjoyed this dish. Adding the last ingredients after taking pot off the flame creates little bombshells of flavor. Will definitely be making again. Especially good for an easy and delicious weeknight meal.
 
KathiCville December 29, 2020
Wow! I chose this dish to inaugurate my new Staub cocette! Fabulous! I made two small changes—substituted one cup of diced tomatoes for the grape tomatoes, and I skipped the olives (but only because I didn’t have any in the cupboard). Amazing flavor! Thank you!
 
Joan T. October 18, 2020
This is a great one pot meal any time of the year. It’s flavorful, simple, and relatively quick. I’ve used quinoa in place of the orzo at times.
 
cosmiccook September 23, 2020
This dish really lends itself to additions. Just made it again. In addition to chix stock, had bone-in thighs so cooked longer in broth before adding orzo. I added the feta brine & wine. To the pot I added some 'shrooms. frozen chokes & 1/2 preserved lemon I needed to use up. Used Trader Joe's Chili Crunch & Mushroom umami for additional flavoring. EXTRA garlic, dried basil & onion as too tired to cook and just wanted an easy dish.
 
onetinyspark September 23, 2020
Yesss! Make it work for you. Love it!
 
cosmiccook September 24, 2020
My first preference is with shrimp--but due to all the storms in t he gulf, shrimpers are not out.
 
Carolyn K. September 20, 2020
Made this last night (with a few tweaks) and it was a hit! Added artichoke hearts as suggested by another reviewer. Substituted white wine for chicken broth (added a bit of Knorr boullion powder). Just used half as much orzo (and half as much liquid) as I wanted more chicken than pasta. Simmered the thighs in sauce for 30 or so minutes. Then, right before serving heated back up and added orzo to finish.
 
Bethany September 14, 2020
Flavorful! Don’t be shy with the spices and add a bit more garlic
 
Michelle July 6, 2020
Loved this recipe and it was so easy to make.
 
sarala D. June 27, 2020
excellent! Had chicken thighs with bones, so I used them, No difference that I could see. I used Israeli couscous ( which is really a kind of pasta) , which I toasted and then used as the orzo in the recipe. Didn't have capers, but hardly missed them. I used my le cruset dutch oven, on top of the stove. Perfect! I will certainly make this again. 5 stars!
 
Outi April 13, 2021
Orzo is pasta as are both kinds of couscous - so not a big difference.
 
Rachel J. February 29, 2020
We just got a Dutch oven so I’ve been scrolling through recipes to try. I made this last night and let 👏🏼 Me👏🏼Tell👏🏼You👏🏼! I would make this again and again and again. Five stars. LOVED it. I don’t even write reviews on recipes but I had to share! Thank you!
 
onetinyspark February 29, 2020
So happy you love the recipe!
 
Dennis B. December 7, 2019
This is a wonderful recipe and has become one of our regulars! It's fun to make and very rewarding afterwards. A one pot dish and very easy cleanup in 45 minutes or less.
 
gardenchickens October 11, 2019
Ditto the raves; I made it as written with BI-SO thighs and olives to taste, results perfect. Indeed it is a very satiating dish, to be filed as a keeper, repeater, company-worthy, week-night rotation, and favorite. Spinach is not necessary, might be too much. If another side dish is desired, anything green would work.
Yum!
 
Liz C. October 8, 2019
I made this on Saturday evening and my husband and I loved it. It was the first dish that sprang to mind when planning dinner for friends this weekend. I might add some spinach at the end as suggested in some reviews. Very bright- and clean-tasting.
 
Tammy R. October 1, 2019
I should really be on a show called "World's Worst Cooks" because I have absolutely zero talent in the kitchen - I prepared this recipe tonight and it was pretty simple and very tasty - the only thing is that I didn't let enough of the juice cook out - was too afraid of letting the Orzo over cook - I will definitely make this again - very tasty!
 
onetinyspark October 1, 2019
So happy you enjoyed it!
 
Jennifer August 7, 2019
Again to repeat- amazing!!!
I skipped the orzo and chicken broth and served over polenta.
Thank you for the recipe.
 
Christine G. June 24, 2019
This recipe is amazing! I embellished by including shallot after I browed the chicken, then I added the tomatoes and the garlic and sauteed it for a little longer then called for. I deglaze the pan with a glug of white wine. I added the olives and capers as the chicken braised in the sauce. In addition to fresh basil, I added a handful of fresh thyme from my garden. Love, love, love this.... make sure you have plenty of warm crusty bread!
 
onetinyspark June 24, 2019
Thanks so much for your review! I love your additions - I'll be sure to try them. Glad you enjoyed the recipe.
 
SCalabretta December 13, 2018
Even without most of the ingredients (tomatoes, olives, capers--I know, I know), this was delicious. Toasting the orzo kept it from becoming mushy. I added spinach and a squirt of lemon at the end.
 
KitchVega October 15, 2018
I made this tonight because by some miracle I had all these ingredients on hand. I also added half a tablespoon of nduja for more of a spicy kick. I thought it was great with chicken but I think really amazing with shellfish such as shrimp or lobster. Well done and I will make again!
 
BahtHarim October 7, 2018
Lovely recipe, I will definitely try it. However, I would use bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs, and brown them first. They have the best flavor as compared to boneless skinless thighs, and the Browning will add some lovely fond to the pot and add much deeper flavor to the entire dish.
 
Sarah September 30, 2018
Would spinach be good added into this?
 
onetinyspark October 1, 2018
I think so! I’d add it in towards the end so it can wilt with the heat of the other ingredients.
 
ellen E. January 14, 2018
Can this be frozen?
 
Abbey November 12, 2017
Love this recipe--full of flavor, and really easy!
 
jon407 September 23, 2017
We just made this last night and loved it. we didn't hav any orzo in the house so I ended up using quinoa and it was fantastic. We'll definitely make this again and might incorporate some of the suggestions already listed.
 
cosmiccook September 22, 2017
M--that is EXACTLY what the problem is. Orzo is a pasta, Arborio a rice. You'd need about 5 times or more of liquid using Arborio.
I've made this dish several times--with chicken AND shrimp. I add frozen artichokes quarters, lemon slices and wine. When doing seafood I used seafood stock. Do try it again w Orzo--you won't be disappointed.
 
Valerie September 22, 2017
Have made this twice now. I actually cook the thighs for a little while to tenderise them a bit more (it's just that I prefer them a tad overdone!) and added the orzo for the last 10 - 15 mins so that it didn't get overcooked! However, with the amount of orzo in the recipe my dish certainly looked a little different to your picture - much more orzo in mine. However, I didn't mind as I love orzo. All around a great and tasty dish. The final addition of olives, capers, feta and basil makes all the difference. (I probably increased the amounts a tad if I'm honest - love those flavours) Delicious!
 
M September 13, 2017
I made this the other night, but it did not work well for me. We didn't have orzo, so I subbed arborio rice - maybe that was the problem? The thighs + arborio rice made it too fatty/creamy and the feta just melted in, too, adding to the problem. I would be willing to try again, but definitely with orzo and with a different protein. Also, I would save the feta for a sprinkling on top. I have leftovers sitting in my fridge, and sadly, they'll go in the garbage.
 
Katherine September 12, 2017
Have done an almost identical dish with shrimp. Love it. Don't know why I haven't tried the base with chicken. Can't wait!
 
Gail August 31, 2017
Loved this! It came together quickly, and clean up was a breeze. Didn't have capers in hand, so finished with a squeeze of lemon. Thank you for sharing!
 
kim May 11, 2017
Made recipe twice now and while all the flavors are so delicious the chicken thighs seem to turn out too fatty for this. I will use chicken breasts next time for this. Has anyone made this with chicken breasts?
 
Marisa February 6, 2017
Made it with farro instead of orzo. I toasted the farro according to the instructions for the orzo and it was nutty and delicious.
 
suzanne October 1, 2016
This was incredible. Will definitely make it again!
 
FJT September 8, 2016
Delicious and easy - I'll definitely be making this again! I used gluten-free orzo. I also cut each chicken thigh into three pieces and added the paprika, oregano and seasonings a few hours before I wanted to cook. Don't know if it made any difference, but I figured it as I had the time it couldn't hurt!
 
Tisa September 8, 2016
Made this last night, and it was AMAZING!! This is a perfect week night dinner that is packed with flavor and easy to pull together. Toasting the orzo was such a great suggestion. We will definitely add this to our repertoire.
 
Tracy Y. September 8, 2016
Would this work with rice instead of orzo? Maybe arborio?
 
onetinyspark September 8, 2016
I think it's worth a shot - would love to try it with arborio!
 
Tracy Y. September 10, 2016
So the arborio rice worked well. I increased the chicken stock to aprox 2 cups and cooked it for around half an hour. Delicious!
 
Jamie W. September 6, 2016
Can't wait to try this....it sounds awesome.
May have to try it for my book club!
 
javafiend September 6, 2016
Are you sure about the amount of kalamata olives being 2 Tbs? Because that's like 2
 
onetinyspark September 6, 2016
Use as many kalamata olives as you like!
 
Ali W. August 16, 2016
I cannot sing enough praise for this recipe, it came together so quickly and it was so flavorful! I went the Moroccan way and added some barista and preserved lemons. A weeknight must!
 
Ali W. August 16, 2016
*harissa! Damn autocorrect!
 
onetinyspark September 6, 2016
I'm so glad you enjoyed! I'm going to have to try it with harissa, it sounds fabulous!
 
Harry F. August 16, 2016
Are the pepper flakes not used?
 
cosmiccook April 17, 2016
Threw in mushrooms and frozen artichoke quarters. Doubled the olives used a variety of heirloom grape tomatoes--had all the ingredients. Threw in a parm rind, prosciutto end piece and one anchovy which I minced w the garlic. Did NOT add any extra salt. Lovely!
 
onetinyspark April 17, 2016
This sounds great! I love the addition of the artichoke hearts!
 
Brussels S. April 14, 2016
Such a great recipe and overall great idea to cook the orzo in the cooking liquids. Can't wait to give it a test!
 
onetinyspark April 14, 2016
Thank you! I hope you enjoy the recipe!
 
deb January 26, 2016
Finally tried this recipe. Loved it! Thanks! Worked perfectly, no substitutions.
 
onetinyspark September 6, 2016
So happy you loved it!
 
CanadaDan January 5, 2016
great recipe, though i made a bunch of changes...added mushrooms and sauteed a few minutes before adding the garlic, then added canned (and chopped) san marzano tomatoes instead of cherries, and used 1 cup of stock + cup of the tomato juice and cooked uncovered about 15 minutes instead of covered. came out really well, not soupy or mushy at all.

so yeah lots fo changes but it came out really well, would make this again and again
 
onetinyspark January 5, 2016
Your changes sound great! That's what I love about this recipe - you can mix and match pretty much any ingredients you like. And I'll definitely give your uncovered technique a try. Thanks for the tip!
 
MBE January 5, 2016
Yum! Not sure about all of the comments of rubbery thighs, for me it's breast that usually comes out dry and tough. Because of the season I also substituted a can of diced, fire roasted tomatoes for the fresh grape. I drained them but ended up adding the reserved liquid because we like our food on the saucy side. The only adjustment I would make would be to hold back on adding the orzo for 5 minutes or so. I had a nice sear on the chicken but wanted to make sure it was cooked through which made the orzo a tad overcooked. Will definitely be making this one again when tomatoes are in season but it sure made for a bright flavor on my table on a cold January evening.
 
onetinyspark January 5, 2016
I love the idea of substituting grape tomatoes for the fire roasted; sounds delicious! Thanks for your comments and I'm glad you enjoyed the recipe.
 
RLuxford December 30, 2015
This is a fantastic recipe. It goes together in no time, and it's forgiving. I was out of grape tomatoes, so I threw in a can of well drained diced tomatoes.

Also, my local grocery had given so much pasta space over to gluten-free and high-protein options, they don't stock orzo, so alphabet pasta was the least worst option.
 
onetinyspark December 30, 2015
So glad you enjoyed it!
 
Mitsue F. October 25, 2015
I love the idea of this however, I had SO much liquid left it was like soup. I carefully removed everything from the pot and then added the cheese, olives, etc. Still, it was super tasty. I loved it and I'm certain it'll be delicious to everyone else.
 
galsmu October 18, 2015
Love this! Great weeknight dish. Did not have any issues with the chicken. Bought boneless, skinless. Cleaned them up then cut in half. Quick brown on both sides. Took them out before they were cooked through then added back at the end for a few minutes to finish off. Turned out great.
 
Leslie G. October 14, 2015
I found this recipe had all the makings of a delicious entree. Unfortunately, I too found the thighs a bit rubbery; I prefer a crispier skin. However, due to loving the ingredients, I took the uneaten chicken, broke it down into pieces, made the sauce, adjusting for smaller quantities, and tossed it with gluten free pasta. Problem solved!
 
onetinyspark October 14, 2015
Hi Leslie! Yeah, chicken thighs can get rubbery quickly so it the cooking time might need to be adjusted depending on the stove. I'm glad you were able to make it work though! I've also made this recipe with shrimp - luckily the rest of the ingredients and flavors go with a lot of different proteins. Thanks for the feedback!
 
Sherry November 5, 2016
Did you put the same seasonings on the shrimp? Also, I assume you just put them back in the pan to warm up at end?
 
Jaxmccaff October 11, 2015
Made this last night. It was very easy and the flavours were amazing. I didn't love the chicken thighs (found them a bit rubbery) and would make it with chicken breast next time instead ... but there will be a next time! Thanks for the great recipe!
 
onetinyspark October 11, 2015
Thank you for the feedback! I'm glad you enjoyed the recipe!
 
Alice S. October 11, 2015
Can you recommend a gluten free substitute for the orzo? I am allergic to wheat but would really love to try a variation of this recipe. Thank you ahead of time for your suggestions.
 
onetinyspark October 11, 2015
Alice, DeLallo makes a corn/rice Orzo that would be a good substitute. You can read about it here: http://www.saveur.com/article/one-good-find/one-good-find-gluten-free-orzo