Bake
Butternut Squash Pie-Cake
Popular on Food52
20 Reviews
Laura
November 20, 2016
So, I made this and...I wasn't that excited about it. While I do absolutely love butternut squash, in the end, it tasted like a(n excellent) gooey sugar cookie with butternut squash in the middle.
Yayita
October 24, 2016
I made this, and although I liked it I felt that it would have been even better if I had roasted the butternut squash with some salt over the honey and brown butter. This suggestion is definitely a personal one as butternut squash in my opinion is at its best when it's sweet and savory at the same time. Next time I bake this I will forgo the honey and brown sugar for a little bit of salt when I am roasting the the squash.
Louise
November 27, 2015
I saw the comment about how it would keep - not a problem in my house since it was gone the night I made it! It was a hit. I made it in an 8" springform because it is easier to cut and serve - pushing the dough from the bottom up the sides. It was beautiful and delicious.
chez_mere
November 9, 2015
Does anyone have thoughts about how well this would keep? I'd love to bake it the day before Thanksgiving... Good idea, or is it really better eaten the day it's made?
Trees
November 10, 2015
I think it's best when warm, so if you do make it ahead of time, I'd heat it up before serving it.
Jonnie
November 3, 2015
Wondering if doubling this recipe would work if I choose to bake it in a
38cm X 25cm X 4cm glass dish or a typical 9.5in X 13.5in X 2in glass Lasagna dish?
38cm X 25cm X 4cm glass dish or a typical 9.5in X 13.5in X 2in glass Lasagna dish?
melissa
November 2, 2015
it was like a pie in that there were two separate crusts, but when it baked together, the consistency was more like a cake (sweet, with crumbs) and less like a flaky pie crust.
Sarah J.
November 2, 2015
Yes, exactly! It's got more heft and crumb than a traditional pie, and the crust is more akin to a sugar cookie.
melissa
October 31, 2015
made this tonight since i wanted to use up the butternut squash in my CSA and i love cardamom. i found the dough to be sticky, so i rolled it flat in between two pieces of plastic wrap. the dough/crust is delicious! reminds me of strawberry shortcake. this will pair awesomely with a cup of coffee.
Trees
October 29, 2015
In case anyone was wondering, 2 pounds of squash is about one average-sized butternut after it's skinned and gutted.
See what other Food52ers are saying.