Christmas
Chocolate Cake with Cranberry Buttercream
Popular on Food52
24 Reviews
cheryl E.
November 29, 2020
I didn't have nearly enough frosting, and I whisked it for over ten minutes. It tastes like butter. Are you sure there shouldn't be more sugar than butter?
Yiannis P.
November 27, 2020
I made this cake for Thanksgiving (b/c my sister's birthday always falls near Thanksgiving) and, while it is a delicious chocolate cate, the buttercream frosting tasted way more of butter than cranberry. I'd definitely make the cake, again, but would likely use a different frosting or figure out a way to get more cranberry flavor up in that frosting.
Yiannis P.
November 27, 2020
I made this cake for Thanksgiving (b/c my sister's birthday always falls near Thanksgiving) and, while it is a delicious chocolate cate, the buttercream frosting tasted way more of butter than cranberry. I'd definitely make the cake, again, but would likely use a different frosting or figure out a way to get more cranberry flavor up in that frosting.
Nyasha
June 29, 2020
No idea how this does not have a higher rating. This is, bar none, my all time favorite cake. Brava Merrill Stubbs! I also coat the cake in left over glaze. Makes for an eye popping centerpiece on the Thanksgiving dessert table. 10/10
Lisa R.
December 8, 2019
The water is not listed in the ingredients list. Could not understand why my sugar and chocolate was so thick until I saw the water in the directions!
Regine
January 3, 2017
Dina, first thing, I have not yet made this cake, but if you do not abide by the exact list of ingredients and instructions, you should expect not to get the same results. This being said though, it appears that using stevia instead of sugar in cake recipes can result in loss of volume in the final product. I have not really listened to this youtube but check it out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QAN_rCFc2Q
Nati, I bake all the times and successfully so with either "cups" measurements or "weight" measurements. You should be able to find in a store in Germany measuring cups for baking (with marks on the cup for i.e., 1/4 cup, 1/2 cup, 1 cup).
I look forward to making this cake soon myself and provide some comments.
Happy New Year!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QAN_rCFc2Q
Nati, I bake all the times and successfully so with either "cups" measurements or "weight" measurements. You should be able to find in a store in Germany measuring cups for baking (with marks on the cup for i.e., 1/4 cup, 1/2 cup, 1 cup).
I look forward to making this cake soon myself and provide some comments.
Happy New Year!
Nati W.
December 21, 2016
Hello everybody,
I have made unsatisfying experiences using "cups" instead of exact amounts. I have the feeling that I never get the right mixing ratio. In Germany (where I am from) recipes are mostly with exact weight indications. What type of cups with which filling quantity shall I use? Thank you very much.
:)
I have made unsatisfying experiences using "cups" instead of exact amounts. I have the feeling that I never get the right mixing ratio. In Germany (where I am from) recipes are mostly with exact weight indications. What type of cups with which filling quantity shall I use? Thank you very much.
:)
marcella F.
February 14, 2017
Nati, you can find online converters to turn cup and spoon measurements into weights. I always use this one http://www.traditionaloven.com/conversions_of_measures/butter_converter.html and never had a problem (don't be mislead by the link title, it offers conversion for flour and sugar too)
Dina S.
November 25, 2016
Hello,
Anyone else have a problem with the cake? It did not rise at all! I used 2 9 inch pans, I weighed the batter to have equal amounts in both & my layers look half as high as each of the layers in the photo. I now made a 3rd layer (using half the recipe) - same story. I'll make the buttercream tomorrow & hopefully the cake will look like something but with thinner layers.
One change that I did make & I doubt this changed the rising issue was sugar - I didn't use sugar, I used stevia.
If anyone can venture to guess what I did wrong, I would appreciate it greatly. Thank you.
Anyone else have a problem with the cake? It did not rise at all! I used 2 9 inch pans, I weighed the batter to have equal amounts in both & my layers look half as high as each of the layers in the photo. I now made a 3rd layer (using half the recipe) - same story. I'll make the buttercream tomorrow & hopefully the cake will look like something but with thinner layers.
One change that I did make & I doubt this changed the rising issue was sugar - I didn't use sugar, I used stevia.
If anyone can venture to guess what I did wrong, I would appreciate it greatly. Thank you.
K N.
May 20, 2017
Hi Dina, tinkering with the sugar will affect the rise. I found this article to have a helpful explanation.
http://www.finecooking.com/article/what-every-baker-needs-to-know-about-sugar
I hope this helps!
http://www.finecooking.com/article/what-every-baker-needs-to-know-about-sugar
I hope this helps!
Delia
November 23, 2016
Any suggestions on how to adapt this to use bittersweet chocolate (70-85% cacao) in place of unsweetened? I can't find good quality unsweetened chocolate right now.
Synky
November 18, 2016
I made this today but with a few adjustments. I put one cup of sugar into the cake dough instead of two, thinking two cups was too much sugar. It turned out sweet enough, bringing out the chocolate quite nicely. Also, since there was so much cranberry sauce left over, I covered the top of the cake with a thin layer. Not only did it look amazing (dark red over pink!) but the addition of the tart glaze was a great contrast to the mellow taste of the cake. It also made me think of the holidays coming up since cranberries figure so prominently in both Thanksgiving and Christmas. I think next time I would put a cranberry glaze in between the layers as well as on top of the cake. Everyone loved it! Thank you for a great (and simple and relatively quick) cake recipe!
bobbie J.
November 22, 2016
Thanks Synky - I was thinking along those lines as well. Glad you gave this a test drive!
thi
November 18, 2016
Thanks. I am a newbie. Would you be able to recommend some brands that would be considered high quality or what I should look for in a high quality chocolate?
Jeff P.
November 19, 2016
Hi Thi,
I'd use any major brand your store carries for unsweetened chocolate in bar form. Which specific brand would depend on where in the world you are located.
Because the chocolate is being melted, things like tempering of the chocolate won't matter. And, because the chocolate is being used in a baked good, the exact flavor profile won't make as much of a difference either.
With bitter/semi-sweet chocolate, there are variations in cacao fat to cacao solid ratios between different brands, as well as differences in sugar percentages. With unsweetened chocolate, those aspects won't differ.
Happy Cooking!
-Jeff
I'd use any major brand your store carries for unsweetened chocolate in bar form. Which specific brand would depend on where in the world you are located.
Because the chocolate is being melted, things like tempering of the chocolate won't matter. And, because the chocolate is being used in a baked good, the exact flavor profile won't make as much of a difference either.
With bitter/semi-sweet chocolate, there are variations in cacao fat to cacao solid ratios between different brands, as well as differences in sugar percentages. With unsweetened chocolate, those aspects won't differ.
Happy Cooking!
-Jeff
eileen
November 17, 2016
confused on the buttercream - making 2 cups of fruit puree, but only using
1/4 cup to create the frosting?
1/4 cup to create the frosting?
Merrill S.
November 17, 2016
Yes -- you'll have extra. It freezes nicely, works as a cocktail ingredient, or you can make less of the puree. (I assumed most people won't have access to smaller amount of cranberries.)
Susan C.
January 6, 2017
I added almost all of the puree to the frosting. It made for a lovely contrast with the chocolate cake. Really yummy. Next time I'm going to try Synky's glaze suggestion. That sounds great!
Nancy R.
January 30, 2017
I am curious about why you would make extra sauce if you don't need it for the frosting? While the sauce might be good for something else, I think I would rather make less.
See what other Food52ers are saying.