Christmas
Best Fruitcake
Popular on Food52
15 Reviews
Kristin S.
December 7, 2023
My fruitcakes are in the oven as I write this and they look and smell heavenly. I want to alert readers and the author to one small, but significant typo in the directions. The initial 45 minute baking temp reads 150 c/265 f. It should be 305 F.
lizziemom
November 29, 2022
Before I make this I want to know what 2 1/2 C "luxury dried fruit" means. Is this in addition to the candied citrus, cherries, apricots and figs? Thank you.
Rebecca
November 29, 2022
I'm making a guess - there's junky dried fruit, cheapy stuff with day-glo food coloring, and then there's the better stuff, made with care, without food coloring and artificial flavors. I'd call them luxury too because they're quite 'spensive.
Kitchen B.
December 22, 2022
The Luxury dried fruit refers to a mix that typically has currants, raisins, and sultanas. Some have candied citrus and cherries but really small proportions. This is separate from the other listed ingredients. I hope this helps.
Nicholas
November 29, 2022
As I write this, I have two fruitcakes reposing in parchment paper, plastic wraps, and tins. Both were made in early October using Fiona Cairn's, Royal Wedding Fruit Cake recipe, published following William & Kate's wedding, for which she supplied the wedding cake. I have made these annually since the wedding, and they are pretty spectacular. No day at the beach either -- they have their demands. All of this said, I question whether this cake written up here is worth the bother. Seriously. The ingredients are tempting and appropriate, but the technique leaves me cold. Just sayin'.
Kitchen B.
December 22, 2022
:) - you'll have to try it to figure out for yourself, I guess. I've been making this for 10 years, and I haven't looked back.
What about the technique leaves you cold?
It's similar to many dump all cake recipes, many of which have fantastic outcomes. Enjoy, whatever choice you make.
What about the technique leaves you cold?
It's similar to many dump all cake recipes, many of which have fantastic outcomes. Enjoy, whatever choice you make.
jpriddy
November 29, 2022
When I married in 1974 I served fruitcake at my wedding. Until WW1, that was typical. Rationing replaced the traditional fruitcake with the "bride's cake" and in my childhood at even at the time of my wedding, tiny chunks of fruitcake were wrap and sent home as "groom's cake" not to be eaten, but to put under your pillow and dream.
My 1915 original Boston School of Cooking Cookbook has two wedding cake recipes. BOTH are fruit cake. I used a traditional wedding cake recipe in my New Fanny Farmer Cook Book. In those days it was still possible for me to go to the Pikeplace Market in Seattle and purchase candied fruit as half-peels of oranges, lemons, and citron, and also several kinds of raisin and real currants. I aged the fruit for a few weeks and then aged the cakes themselves even longer wrapped in cheesecloth, regularly brushing them with brandy.
My 1915 original Boston School of Cooking Cookbook has two wedding cake recipes. BOTH are fruit cake. I used a traditional wedding cake recipe in my New Fanny Farmer Cook Book. In those days it was still possible for me to go to the Pikeplace Market in Seattle and purchase candied fruit as half-peels of oranges, lemons, and citron, and also several kinds of raisin and real currants. I aged the fruit for a few weeks and then aged the cakes themselves even longer wrapped in cheesecloth, regularly brushing them with brandy.
Ehac1980
November 29, 2022
This sounds like a great cake, but with the number of typos in the description, I am dubious about the content of the recipe.
Smaug
January 10, 2023
I detect no typos- the author is Nigerian educated in England, and her syntax is a bit different from what you'd expect from Kansas.
elizabeth C.
December 27, 2017
I also love fruitcake, mostly because it reminds me of my grandmother, but also because its warm, scented goodness fills my house with memories and love. Most Americans have missed out on this Christmas treasure and turn up their noses thinking of the Johnny Carson joke of there only being one fruitcake in the world that makes rounds to everyone. I call this "my nan's boiled cake" when I present it to friends and smile as they savor every bite.
Kitchen B.
June 21, 2020
Happy to meet you, fruitcake friend :). That warm, scented goodness and the memories - that's amazing
See what other Food52ers are saying.