Fall
Pan de Muerto (Day of the Dead Bread)
Popular on Food52
14 Reviews
Nina W.
December 18, 2022
I gave this 5 stars because I was able to adjust the recipe to come out perfectly, at least for me. I increased the milk to 3/4 cup, maybe a little more, increased the yeast to 2 1/2 teaspoons, added 4 tablespoons of softened unsalted butter, and added a third large egg. I mixed ground vanilla with sugar for the sprinkle. We could not stop eating the bread.
Christine
November 3, 2020
I made this yesterday for Dia de los Muertos and came into the same issue as a few other commenters - was glad I read the comments. I ended up using approximately 1 cup of milk, but that was too much so I think the 3/4 cup commenters are likely spot on. I will say we loved the texture of the bread and the crust and will likely use this for a rosca de reyes base come January. :)
Christine
November 3, 2020
Ugh, my bad... just realized this did have sugar in it. I put in about half... so no wonder I wanted it to be a bit sweeter. :)
Christine
November 3, 2020
I made this yesterday for Dia de los Muertos and came into the same issue as a few other commenters - was glad I read the comments. I ended up using approximately 1 cup of milk, but that was too much so I think the 3/4 cup commenters are likely spot on. I did also question the absence of sugar (my Mexican husband had told me it wasn't a super sweet bread, but when he tried it his feedback was that it was usually a little sweeter than how it turned out). I will say we loved the texture of the bread and the crust and will likely use this for a rosca de reyes base come January. :)
Christina
November 2, 2020
This recipe worked out just fine for me but then, I weighed my ingredients so I was sure I had just 361 grams of flour no matter the humidity or measuring method. I used 2 duck eggs so they were slightly over sized (135g) but 1/4 of milk seemed enough to make a smooth and supple dough with good rise. I don’t care for anise seed so I omitted since I don’t have any in the house. The vanilla sugar is the perfect end to this (I keep spent vanilla beans in a jar of sugar =vanilla sugar, for the reviewer who asked how to make it).
CailynS
November 1, 2020
Sadly this recipe was just wrong. My first dough was dry and hard as a rock. I luckily looked at the comments and tried again. I added almost triple the milk. I probably needed another egg as well. Next time I'm reading the comments first!
LULULAND
October 8, 2020
I read that the measurements are wrong for the milk. Please fix Erin. I've seen your video on making bread, you are really knowledgeable. This has to be a mistake.
CalamityintheKitchen
October 26, 2019
Why is this recipe still up and still wrong? This is a mean trick for newbie bakers, who won't know that 1/4 c milk is never going to moisten 3 cups flour (2 eggs notwithstanding) and will just think it is their fault and they can't bake.
Please fix this recipe.
Please fix this recipe.
Alex T.
November 2, 2018
I'm wondering what's up with this recipe!! I followed it exactly, and it's super dry and crumbly...I'm definitely thinking there needed to be more milk.
MN
December 28, 2017
1/4 c milk must be a mistake. Maybe for 3/4 c? I needed to use a cup of milk for the dough to bind. (And 114g doesn't match up...)
The flavors of this bread are fantastic. I'm glad that I made it.
The flavors of this bread are fantastic. I'm glad that I made it.
See what other Food52ers are saying.