Clobster Grilled Cheese with Everything Sauce

October  4, 2022
4 Ratings
Photo by Slapfish
  • Serves 2
Author Notes

This simple, crave-worthy, gooey sandwich can be served as a meal or an appetizer sliced into small pieces and drizzled with sauce. The sweet, spicy, smoky and rich “everything sauce” can be used on, well, everything. Always have some of this in your fridge ready to be slathered over grilled fish, chicken, veggies, beef, or even toasted bread. —Benny's Chop House

What You'll Need
  • Grilled Cheese
  • 4 ounces Maine Lobster meat picked
  • 2 ounces Dungeness crab meat
  • 2 tablespoons shredded aged white cheddar
  • 1 tablespoon shredded mozzarella
  • 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
  • 1 ripe tomato, sliced
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 1 lemon, sliced in half
  • 4 slices high quality sandwich bread
  • Everything Sauce
  • 1/2 cup mayonnaise
  • 1 tablespoon chopped pickle
  • 1 tablespoon pickle juice
  • 1 teaspoon sriracha
  • 1 teaspoon ketchup
  • 1 tablespoon tomato juice
  • 1 tablespoon minced chipotle
  • 1 lemon, zested and juiced
  • 1 teaspoon honey
  • 1 teaspoon dijon mustard
  1. Toast the Bread: The key to a good grilled cheese is toasting the bread on both sides to double that delicious and buttery golden brown flavor. Be sure to toast the bread on the outside first, flip over, then build the sandwich onto the toasted bread.
  2. Start cooking the inside of the sandwich: Spread the mayo evenly over the toasted inside of each piece of bread. Set aside. In a non-stick pan add the lobster, crab, a touch of butter and a dash of lemon juice. Toss until warm and slightly melted. Place atop the toasted bread with the tomato.
  3. To cook the sandwich: Place 1⁄2 the butter in the pan and heat until melted. Add the sandwich with the melted insides and toast over medium heat (it may take a few minutes on lower heat, but it is well worth the melted crunch). Before you flip the sandwich, add the remaining butter, then flip. Place the entire pan in the oven for 5 minutes.
  4. For the Everything Sauce: Combine all the ingredients in a bowl with a whisk and set aside.
  5. To serve: Slice the sandwich in half and serve alongside the everything sauce for dipping. Squeeze the lemon juice over the sandwich at the last minute to add a touch of acid. For a messier, sloppier, finger-licking good time, drizzle the sauce right over the sandwich. Garnish with fresh sliced chives.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • mikedalena
  • Bill
  • JudyD

3 Reviews

mikedalena November 25, 2018
What should the temperature of the oven be or did I just miss it in the recipe?
Bill September 13, 2018
Question about the chopped pickles: sweet or dill?
JudyD January 4, 2020
Because honey is an ingredient in the sauce, I think I would use sweet pickles. Just my preference really.