Bake
Noma-Approved Do-It-All Cake
Popular on Food52
15 Reviews
panga
April 15, 2018
My cake sank in the middle as well. I baked for 50 mins and it was cooked all the way through. Thinking maybe a full hour would have done the trick. I loved that the cake had s nice crust that contracted with the moist inside. Next time I will add 1/2 cup less sugar as it was a bit too sweet for me. The vanilla flavor was great with subtle saltiness of the Maldon flaky sea salt.
Sophie H.
March 1, 2018
Why so much sugar ? If I put just half of it, do you think It would still work ? I would like to add 2 lemons and their zest. Please tell me.
soleilnyc
January 24, 2018
Baked in the recommended pan for 70 mins. At 60, the cake was still wobbly. Not sure what texture I was aiming for with the butter and sugar as, after 7 minutes in the kitchen aid, it still kind of looked like wet compacted sugar.
The flavor is lovely, especially since I went all out with pastured eggs, grass fed cream and butter, Madagascar vanilla beans and Maldon salt. But I wouldn't say it's a mind-blowing cake. It's really best as a base or vehicle for something else-- add nuts or fruit as suggested or top with something to serve. Alone, it's just a pretty good pound cake.
The flavor is lovely, especially since I went all out with pastured eggs, grass fed cream and butter, Madagascar vanilla beans and Maldon salt. But I wouldn't say it's a mind-blowing cake. It's really best as a base or vehicle for something else-- add nuts or fruit as suggested or top with something to serve. Alone, it's just a pretty good pound cake.
Gloria G.
January 7, 2018
how would this do in a 9 inch round pan, do you think?
Millicent
January 7, 2018
I made it in a 10 inch springform, and the cake rose up quite high as it baked. I'm not a super-experienced baker and would love for someone else to weigh in, but I suggest trying two 9 inch pans if they're the regular kind with lower sides than a springform.
Saffron3
December 11, 2017
I do become sad when a cake so simple, and with such potential for me, has a method that requires a mixer. I don't have one, half the world doesn't have one. Darn.
KR
December 11, 2017
1. have you checked out the non-electric beaters? (no, not a joke...I have one, have to spin a little handle on the side which turns the two beaters)
2. people made cakes long before electric appliances came to be...just requires a good wooden spoon and whisk, more time, and a very strong arm! (I've also done this when I lived in Asia and didn't want to re-invest in one).
2. people made cakes long before electric appliances came to be...just requires a good wooden spoon and whisk, more time, and a very strong arm! (I've also done this when I lived in Asia and didn't want to re-invest in one).
witloof
December 11, 2017
Do you mean that you don't have a stand mixer or you don't have a handheld mixer? I own both and tbh rarely pull out my stand mixer, almost always opting for the hand version. They can be purchased very inexpensively, especially with a Bed Bath coupon, and are well worth the investment.
Wilnette
December 10, 2017
Hi I have made this cake twice and both times it sanked in the middle. Also the outer crust was hard even after I baked second cake 25 degrees lower. Please help!
Nancy M.
December 11, 2017
I had the same experience. It is even a little underdone in the middle while the edges and top are almost too crusty. The flavor is nice, but I have other recipes I like as well. I do like the salt on top and will try it on my favorite pound cake, but I think this one is not a success for me.
Wilnette
December 11, 2017
Nancy yes, my first was undergone but top and outer crust was overdone as to why I lowered the temp. Would you share "your favorite pound cake" recipe? I would love to try it with the salt on top😀.
Nancy M.
December 11, 2017
On Allrecipes look for Grandma's Sour Cream Pound Cake by LVJOANNE. I cut it in half, add a little lemon zest and bake it in a loaf pan at 325 for 80 min.
Millicent
December 10, 2017
Delicious! I made this as written, using our local organic butter (not European style), and the flavor was rounded, complex and vanilla-y, not too salty at all. The salt sprinkled on top was a really nice touch, but fine to skip if you prefer. The texture was great too, but we needed the oven so I took it out at 50 minutes, and it was a bit underbaked. This cake would pair well with fruit or dark chocolate, but it's so rich and luscious that it doesn't need anything else. I would suggest trying it plain before serving with whipped cream or frosting, which could be too much.
Regine
December 8, 2017
Looks tasty. I will definitely try recipe. However, I am seing cake asks for more salt than usual. Salted butter, salt in batter plus salt also sprinkled on batter in pan.
See what other Food52ers are saying.