Make Ahead
No-Mayo Peperonata Pasta Salad
Popular on Food52
29 Reviews
Erika H.
May 29, 2023
This was fantastic. Everyone loved this and the nuts were a hit. Be sure to season with salt and pepper generously. I love vinegar's bite and probably more than doubled it. I used sherry vinegar. This will be on repeat. Thanks for this!
Taylor S.
April 13, 2019
This is amazing! I used some sharp + salty grana padano and a little goat's milk cheddar, both superb. Super easy with fairly simple clean-up too (I made this in a small 250 sq ft studio apartment kitchen).
EmilyC
April 14, 2019
Hi Taylor! So so happy that you tried and liked this! I love goat's milk cheddar--nice call, bet it was delicious here! Thanks so much for your note!
Cheryl
August 24, 2018
So glad I made this! The capers really add to it too. I eat vegan and all I had for cheese was vegan Parm, so used a good amount of that; I'm sure the (vegan) mozzarella would be a great addition, but I didn't miss it. I can't wait for leftovers. Thanks!
keithcancook
August 2, 2018
made this just as the recipe calls for..it was great.
next time I might add artichokes
next time I might add artichokes
Deirdre R.
July 27, 2018
Curious. I have to make this ahead so will be serving it cold or coldish. Do the veggies/dressing do alright when chilled or do they firm up too much?
EmilyC
July 27, 2018
Hi Deirdre: you can definitely make this salad ahead of time. It holds up well in the fridge for several days. (Hold back the basil, though, until serving so it doesn't brown.) I prefer the flavors and textures of the salad at room temperature (vs. straight from the fridge) so I'd recommend just setting the salad out about 30 minutes before serving. Hope this helps!
Deirdre R.
July 27, 2018
Thanks, Emily, for your quick response, it certainly does help. Good point on the basil. I'll remember that.
Deirdre R.
August 3, 2018
The pasta salad was a party hit. I added some zucchini and doubled the vinegar. I like the idea of adding artichokes as suggested by keithcancook. Didn't add nuts in case someone had allergies. Doubled the recipe so brought some home. Turned the leftovers into a pasta dish with ground lamb and a little basil pesto -- another hit.
EmilyC
August 6, 2018
Wonderful--so glad you liked this Deirdre! Thanks so much for trying it and circling back!
Paulaob
July 6, 2018
Very good recipe. I had some smoked mozzarella and finished with a smoked sea salt. Don’t skip the toasted nuts. They add an interesting texture. I used walnuts because I had them, but I would like to try pine nuts.
Josh
July 3, 2018
Very solid and easy choice! I’d rank it second all-time after the Zakarian recipe which is a bit more assertive. This has a wonderful balance and is a great base to further augment.
EmilyC
July 9, 2018
I'll have to look up the Zakarian recipe! : ) So glad you liked this--thanks Josh!
Jennifer H.
June 30, 2018
Unbelievable great salad!!! I almost got a marriage proposal from this one!!! I added more capers since I love them! 5 Stars
EmilyC
June 30, 2018
Haha, this may be the best comment ever! Thanks for putting a big smile on my face! : )
Carol D.
June 20, 2018
Looks really good! I'd appreciate having the Nutritional Info posted with the recipe, please :-)
EmilyC
June 21, 2018
Thanks Carol! I don’t have the nutritional info for this pasta salad or any of my recipes.
Felicia N.
June 22, 2018
Try this website to plug in the ingredients and amounts and adjust to serving size for nutritional info:
https://www.verywellfit.com/recipe-nutrition-analyzer-4157076
https://www.verywellfit.com/recipe-nutrition-analyzer-4157076
Meghan
June 17, 2018
I made this today for our Father's Day dinner, and it was a hit! Very flavorful and all the ingredients complement each other well. It was easy to make and I think would be difficult to mess up - this recipe is a keeper. Thank you!
meganvt01
June 17, 2018
This is my new go to pasta salad. Made it for a tailgate and it held up beautifully. Even enjoying it today a day later. The flavors are so bright.
EmilyC
June 18, 2018
Megan: so so happy to know that you made and liked the salad! It seems perfect for a tailgate, too! Thanks for letting me know!
See what other Food52ers are saying.