5 Ingredients or Fewer
Brown Butter Stuffing
Popular on Food52
26 Reviews
Renée R.
December 3, 2020
I made this for Thanksgiving using only 1 pound of challah. I used a little less butter and only 2 eggs. It's fantastic!!!! In fact, so good that I just made it again to go with the last of our leftovers. It's lighter and crispier than any stuffing recipe I've ever made, and I've made a lot. The browned butter is the star of this show. It's flavor comes through strongly. Love this recipe. Thank you, Emma!
bonnie R.
November 11, 2020
i made this last night ahead of thanksgiving to see if i liked it. i loved it. but i loved it even more this morning with over-easy eggs on top. WOW, game changer for the eggs! so if you have any left over it's a great treat for day-after-thanksgiving breakfast.
bonnie R.
November 11, 2020
sorry for the duplication -- computer issues and a techo-challenged person.
bonnie R.
November 11, 2020
i made this ahead of thanksgiving to see how i like it. i loved it. but i loved it even more this morning with over-easy eggs on top. WOW! game changer for the eggs.
Kristin J.
November 4, 2020
I'm looking forward to trying this, as I'm hosting my first Thanksgiving dinner this year. I was hoping to utilize the turkey giblets. Does anyone have insight if that would be a good addition? Don't want to ruin a good recipe! Thanks in advance.
sunkisst22
November 23, 2020
Use your giblets to make the best gravy. https://food52.com/recipes/7453-mom-s-turkey-giblet-gravy
Carol
November 24, 2020
I make my grandmothers old southern cornbread dressing which includes giblets. It does add a lot of flavor...I picked them out as a kid and still do as I don’t care for them but they do add flavor.
Linsay M.
November 30, 2019
I added 1/2 c of sauteed onion & celery (each) and had to cut back on some of the ingredients since my challah loaf was only 1 lb, but I still used 3 whole eggs. My family couldn't stop talking about how good this was! I ended up baking it at 350 for closer to 50 minutes since that's where all of my other sides needed to be and it came out bubbly and delicious. This will be a staple for future Thanksgivings.
Fred N.
November 30, 2019
Made this for Thanksgiving this year and it was really fantastic! A few additions I made that worked out well:
- Added some browned sweet Italian sausage
- Added toasted pine nuts
- I added half a loaf of torn-up french country bread. Having both the rougher texture and the moist challah worked really well
- Added some browned sweet Italian sausage
- Added toasted pine nuts
- I added half a loaf of torn-up french country bread. Having both the rougher texture and the moist challah worked really well
don
November 29, 2019
Not my favorite stuffing recipe. My guests seemed to like it, but I found it kind of flat and bland, despite all that sage. I definitely would not make this again.
eluu
November 28, 2019
Very tasty, but also very sweet though I suppose that depends on the challah you buy. The tip for drying out bread is so handy, and brown butter is always such a winner. It would be nice to have a sharper and more savory element added next time, but this is such a wonderful base for a stuffing.
NAIOMI H.
November 28, 2019
Absolutely delicious. I had to ratio down a little as my loaf was only 1lb but other than that no tweaks.
Heather K.
November 26, 2018
This stuffing is perfection... Everyone at our friendsgiving loved it, first thing gone! About to make a small second batch tonight to go with my leftovers.
Roxanne
November 24, 2018
This was amazing! I always use french bread for stuffing and was hesitant to branch out, but man, challah! New fave! I did add about a cup each of sautéed onions and celery, didn't have quite enough sage, and added some thyme. Thank you!
Emma L.
November 25, 2018
Thanks, Roxanne—yay to branching out! If you liked challah here, definitely give it a try with some French toast sometime :)
Janet K.
November 24, 2018
This is dangerously good. I made it for a Thanksgiving dinner I had for my husband and I in South Africa. He's Dutch and oblivious to the holiday. I made a slightly reduced version of the dish, about two thirds and ended up nearly eating the whole dish myself! The only critique is that I would have put in at the maximum amount of sage even for 2/3 and maybe more. I love sage. The challah here is not very "eggy" at all but even so this was excellent. There was some left but I forced myself to throw it out as my diet would suffer too much otherwise. I think you could use almost any soft bread for this actually.
Emma L.
November 25, 2018
Aw, so glad you enjoyed! I also ate a looooot of this myself during recipe testing!
Jo A.
November 18, 2018
I am obsessed with browned butter but I really want to include the other herbs and aromatics like parsley, celery and onion. I think I'm going to try a hybrid. I like the technique of sizzling the herbs with the butter!
Lisa
November 14, 2018
Can this be assembled one day and baked the next with good results? I am guessing yes, but wanted to make sure.
Thanks!
Thanks!
Emma L.
November 15, 2018
Hi Lisa! I haven't tried that with this particular recipe—but it should work! Touched base with some coworkers and we've all done this make-ahead method with stuffings at one point or another. Just assemble, refrigerate, and check the bread saturation before baking. If it looks at all dry, just add a little more stock, then bake.
Chrismax42!
December 25, 2022
How was it? Lol, 4 years later.... I'm trying to do Christmas dinner and I have no room in my oven. I want to do potatoes at 425° but I need the bird out of there and I'm just thinking I can just warm the stuffing through while my potatoes are in and the bird rests. This will be for next year now, as I'm in too deep at this point.
See what other Food52ers are saying.