Chocolate
Ultimate Chocolate Cake
Popular on Food52
111 Reviews
Love I.
March 23, 2024
Like @susandana69, I had a runny whipped ganache. What is a good fix for a runny whipped ganache? Is adding more chocolate a good fix? But I also wanted another option than adding more chocolate. I weighed everything, even the wet ingredients.
I usually do a practice run, but decided to make this cake for a bday dinner after reading all the great reviews of the taste. I did use 9" cake pans to avoid the overflow many wrote about. I checked often after 40 min and waited more than 50 min for the toothpick to come out dry from the center. Perhaps it was too long as the cake was then on the dry side. I waited for the whipped ganache to cool down to room temperature and whipped it but it was too runny. I whipped it much longer than 2 min hoping that would make it thicker. I got anxious as I needed the cake by dinnertime so I added cream of tartar to try to thicken/stabilize it as you would for a stabilized whipped cream. Maybe it would have thickened it enough if I waited a bit longer, but as I started to get anxious, I also added some cornstarch. It did thicken the whipped ganache, but then it also took on a slightly different taste.
I thought the taste of the whipped ganache before I added the stabilizers was good. The filling also tasted good. I think with the great reviews, I would try baking this cake again, but would like to have a fix in case I have a problem with a runny ganache again.
Gave it 4 stars for the runny ganache and based on the taste of the different parts. And hoping the dryness of the cake was due in part to my cake doming so much and throwing off the cooking time.
I usually do a practice run, but decided to make this cake for a bday dinner after reading all the great reviews of the taste. I did use 9" cake pans to avoid the overflow many wrote about. I checked often after 40 min and waited more than 50 min for the toothpick to come out dry from the center. Perhaps it was too long as the cake was then on the dry side. I waited for the whipped ganache to cool down to room temperature and whipped it but it was too runny. I whipped it much longer than 2 min hoping that would make it thicker. I got anxious as I needed the cake by dinnertime so I added cream of tartar to try to thicken/stabilize it as you would for a stabilized whipped cream. Maybe it would have thickened it enough if I waited a bit longer, but as I started to get anxious, I also added some cornstarch. It did thicken the whipped ganache, but then it also took on a slightly different taste.
I thought the taste of the whipped ganache before I added the stabilizers was good. The filling also tasted good. I think with the great reviews, I would try baking this cake again, but would like to have a fix in case I have a problem with a runny ganache again.
Gave it 4 stars for the runny ganache and based on the taste of the different parts. And hoping the dryness of the cake was due in part to my cake doming so much and throwing off the cooking time.
Susanadana69
March 5, 2024
I made this cake for my granddaughter’s 20th birthday. She wanted chocolate, and she got chocolate! As I didn’t have 8” cake pans and not sure about my skill at slicing a layer in half; and after reading the many reviews, I used three 9” pans and made a triple layer. I was the perfect amount. I also struggled with the genache. I waited forever for it to cool and was still too runny, so added a little heavy cream in while whipping. That worked great. I read one review that said remember to never make a new recipe for a special occasion if you’ve never tested it before. I wish I’d read that before I started. Good advice! I was however committed. It took an entire day. But in the end it was beautiful, delicious and a big hit. I wish I could upload a photo. Erin, you are amazing.
Jill L.
October 29, 2023
First time making this cake and it is truly delicious. I used 9” pans and they were plenty big enough for the amount of batter. I did cut back on the sugar and used 2 cups instead of three and it was the perfect amount for our taste. I struggled with the ganache a bit but managed to pipe it after refrigerating. Definitely would make it again.
Trishington
September 15, 2023
First off: I haven't made this cake yet. But I'm reading all these reviews about how there's too much batter vs. the size of people's cake pans and "raw in the middle and dry on the outside" issues. At first I was going to suggest using 3" deep, straight-sided pans but then I scanned the ingredient list and see that there are 3 cups of flour, 3 cups of sugar and 1.5 cups of cocoa and half a pound of butter in this recipe. Whoa! There's no way all that stuff is gonna fit in two 8" pans without overfilling, even 3" deep pans. Based on those measures, I'm guessing this is a bundt or tube pan recipe. And even then there might be some extra to make a few cupcakes with.
Rob G.
September 15, 2023
This is a 9 or 10-inch cake, do not use 8-inch pans as specified in the recipe!!
Formerly a professional baker and a current serial cake baker, I am waiting for the oven to cool so I can throw out the two 8-inch volcanos that continued to spew cake batter over the bottom of my oven - both still liquid after 35 minutes - and clear the smoke from the house. This said I accept the situation is on me as it was apparent the pans were excessively full. Fix the pan size on the recipe!
Formerly a professional baker and a current serial cake baker, I am waiting for the oven to cool so I can throw out the two 8-inch volcanos that continued to spew cake batter over the bottom of my oven - both still liquid after 35 minutes - and clear the smoke from the house. This said I accept the situation is on me as it was apparent the pans were excessively full. Fix the pan size on the recipe!
cocoquette
April 23, 2023
Hello Erin! Pants < Fun, 100%! Watching your long-form vid Frostings, Icings, Glazes... excellent! Thanks for this info and in such a digestible delivery.
Murjana
April 3, 2023
Hi Erin! I made this for a wedding and it was a huge smash hit (I did leave out the the ganache this time (it’s my second time making it) cus I did Swiss meringue buttercream instead). Everyone kept coming up to me to say that it was the best chocolate cake they’ve ever tasted! Thank you so much!
DiVent
November 13, 2022
Absolutely love this recipe and love watching you bake Erin!
I’ve made this 4 times now and each time my technique improves. Absolute crowd pleaser :-)
I’ve made this 4 times now and each time my technique improves. Absolute crowd pleaser :-)
Bertha
September 29, 2022
This was amazing I soaked my milk in vanilla flavoured coffee beans for a couple of days and used it in the recipe along with coffee as the liquid. Thank you for your this site and your easy explanations of the hows and whys. I am going to bake it a second time for my husbands birthday. Love your page awesome 🥰
[email protected]
September 28, 2022
This cake is delicious! Question- If I have Dutch chocolate on hand do I eliminate or reduce the baking soda?
BrigidBakes
April 1, 2022
This cake was EVERYTHING! My husband's family loves chocolate, so I made this for his birthday and everyone really enjoyed it. I topped it with the dark chocolate Ferrero Rochere chocolates atop circles of chocolate whipped cream. So pretty, so decadent, so delicious. Will be making again.
RachelKay
February 28, 2022
This cake was absolutely FANTABULOUS! The recipe, along with the video, was easy to follow and made for a beautiful birthday cake. Thank you, Jeanne!
nothanks
January 17, 2022
Anyone know the HEIGHT of this cake? Daughter & I planning to make for a friend and need to order approp size box. Thank you so much!!
Helen
January 1, 2022
Loved the cake, it was easy to make. I couldn't get the icing to work. It turned hard and was impossible to use.
LoveBaking
December 26, 2021
I absolutely love this recipe. Made a birthday cake for a friend’s birthday. Used two 10” pans and they came out amazing. Thank you so much, Erin.
Beloo
December 26, 2021
I had the same issue as Riab. I am very disappointed that the cake is crumbling. Could I have mixed it too much at the end? I needed to bake it for 45 mins + to get a clean toothpick and now the sides are falling off! I'm hoping I can save it somehow to use it for the "Black Forest" cake I want to make for my family gathering tomorrow. I sure hope I don't need to bake up something new at the last minute.
Riab
December 24, 2021
Made this twice, thinking that I made a mistake the first time. Nope. Both cakes are going in the garbage. By the time the center of the cake bakes, the edges are dry. It's just not fit to serve to guests. If my kids were still at home, I'm sure they'd eat it.
el A.
December 8, 2021
It is disappointing that the issue of the amount of batter vs. the size of the pans has not yet been addressed.
Sharmeen
October 16, 2021
Omg I cant tell you how delicious this cake was. I followed the recipe and had no trouble at all. The cake is so moist, the pudding filling is so delicious, the whipped ganache is also yum. But i think this cake is more for adults than for kids. It has a strong chocolate taste that adults would love. I baked this in 2 tall 8inch cake pans...for about 45 mins. For those who want to see the inside of the cake you can see it on my instagram page the_flourgirlz it was so beautiful. Its a huge cake. I didn't make it for any occasion. I JUST WANTED TO TRY IT...AS i was eyeing it for a few days. A must make for all cake lovers. And not too sweet...and ofcourse it tastes better as it ages... Yummmmmyyyyyy
Gypzi
July 12, 2021
This cake was so delicious and I LOVE how even and flat the tops were. The only thing was that the batter came right to the very edge of my 9" cake tins as it baked (and a little bit over). I was a bit nervous about it spilling over, but it worked out. Just a note if anyone is using the 8" pans the recipe calls for.
Gypzi
July 13, 2023
Note to self - fill pans to 1411g and put the rest in a loaf pan. ALWAYS USE PARCHMENT ON THE BOTTOM!!!!
See what other Food52ers are saying.