Christmas
Soft & Fluffy Sourdough Pull-Apart Rolls
Popular on Food52
146 Reviews
Joey
November 2, 2023
What would be a good point to make the dough and freeze it for use another day? I’d like to make the dough before thanksgiving and then cook them off on Tgiving day. What would be the best way to do this? Thanks
shannon T.
November 24, 2022
These are really great. Be patient! Starter only can take some time to rise properly. I made a double batch and put in fridge for 24 hrs after first proof. Rolled up nicely and after about 3 1\2 hrs are ready for oven. Will make again.
Champagne
November 23, 2022
The dough was so soft at first that I could scarcely work with it, but it got better as time went on. Strangely, after baking for 25 minutes at 425, these were done; beautifully golden brown with an internal temp of 207. Any idea why they cooked so fast? They're cooling right now and look and smell wonderful. I am really looking forward to having these for thanksgiving dinner tomorrow. This looks like another great recipe.
Maurizio L.
November 24, 2022
Might have baked fast due to your location and/or oven. I'd reduce the baking temp by 25° next go! Have a wonderful Thanksgiving 🙂
DeeAnna R.
November 19, 2022
I would like to make these for Thanksgiving. Is it possible to do the bulk rise over night, in the fridge, with good results?
tkremer72
April 21, 2022
I just tried this recipe and I have to say I was very skeptical at first. During the mixing it looked as though the dough was way too wet and it was sticky to the touch but I proceeded as per the recipe. I live in the south and my house stays warm so neither of the proofing phases took quite as long as the recipe calls for and it was during the first proof I felt like maybe I was actually doing things right. Long story short, stellar recipe, outstanding bread! Definitely a keeper! Thanks so much.
Maurizio L.
April 22, 2022
Thanks so much for all the feedback and comments! Really happy you liked these. You're right, in a warmer, more humid environment, the dough will likely move along a bit faster than I've described above. Enjoy!
PattyP
April 11, 2022
Sooo good. My daughter said they were as pretty as Rhode's (frozen dough from the grocery store)...to be clear that is Rockstar status. Loved working with the dough, and the taste/texture was glorious. Easter Sunday these will be on the table. Thank you!
Malee
January 11, 2022
Both rises took ages in my ice cold kitchen, but these were worth the wait! I just went off of visual cues as opposed to the suggested times in the recipe, and they turned out perfect. Thank you Maurizio for sharing this delicious recipe! I can't wait to make them again.
Maurizio L.
January 12, 2022
Sounds like you made the perfect adjustments, Malee! So glad my recipe worked out well for you 🙂
Lgray
December 4, 2021
It turned out just as the recipe says..super easy..everyone loves them..it’s my go to roll recipe from now on. Thank you for the detail you put into your recipe..it works!!!
Maurizio L.
December 5, 2021
You're very welcome and so glad to hear they worked out well for you 🙂 Enjoy!
SPask
July 13, 2021
Hello!
I tried this recipe and think I went wrong somewhere. They ended up quite flat. In terms of troubleshooting, I think it could have been that my starter wasn't at its ripe stage, although the levain bubbled up nicely. I used unsalted Arla dairy free butter as lactose intolerant and lactose free milk, would that have affected it? I've used these items before in bakes and never had an issue. The other thing was perhaps my tray (I used a circular 9 inch cake dish, as I didn't have a square one the correct size) could have been too big or perhaps I didn't wedge them in enough! I just wondered if you have any advice, as I'd love to try these again!
I tried this recipe and think I went wrong somewhere. They ended up quite flat. In terms of troubleshooting, I think it could have been that my starter wasn't at its ripe stage, although the levain bubbled up nicely. I used unsalted Arla dairy free butter as lactose intolerant and lactose free milk, would that have affected it? I've used these items before in bakes and never had an issue. The other thing was perhaps my tray (I used a circular 9 inch cake dish, as I didn't have a square one the correct size) could have been too big or perhaps I didn't wedge them in enough! I just wondered if you have any advice, as I'd love to try these again!
Maurizio L.
July 13, 2021
If your levain was very active when you mixed the dough, it should be just fine. I don't think the dairy-free butter would cause an issue, I've used these in the past with no problem. If the pan was too large, they'd spread instead of stay together and rise, but my feeling is it had to be something else as long as the pan wasn't excessively large. Be sure to use the levain when it's very, very bubbly and has risen significantly—it needs to be very ripe! If you used your starter a little early, it might have meant more time for that levain to ripen. That's my guess here!
Denver M.
October 29, 2021
I always check my starter to see if it is ready to use. I take a teaspoon of starter and drop it into lukewarm water. If it floats it is ready. If it sinks it is hungry… works for me.
tinatangos
December 1, 2020
I have just made these, and am absolutely thrilled!
I'm afraid, however, I might eat the whole batch before sharing them. :( Well, I suppose then I'll have to make more. :)
I'm afraid, however, I might eat the whole batch before sharing them. :( Well, I suppose then I'll have to make more. :)
Maurizio L.
December 1, 2020
That's the risk with making them... But it's a good risk, right!? Thanks for the feedback and enjoy 🙂
Kerynn F.
November 28, 2020
These are amazing! The dough was very soft and somewhat sticky. The first stretch and fold with my hands was a sticky mess. I used a bowl scraper for the subsequent ones and that worked perfectly. I made them for my solo Thanksgiving (thanks, 'Rona) and froze half - they're equally delicious toasted after freezing. Definitely a keeper.
Maurizio L.
November 30, 2020
It's always amazing how the dough comes together, smooths, and strengthens during bulk fermentation! Glad to hear they worked out so well for you, Kerynn! Thanks for reporting back, and happy baking 🙂
PhillipBrandon
November 24, 2020
Tell me about "ripe" starter.
I have a starter I've maintained for several years. I consider its stages "bubbly" and "not bubbly."
When it is "not bubbly" and I pull some out, call this "discard" I use it in waffles, and crackers. Then I feed it, and in several hours it is "bubbly." If that "bubbly" starter floats, I consider it ready to use in bread dough.
Could you let me know where in this pattern I would find starter appropriate for using in this recipe's levain?
I have a starter I've maintained for several years. I consider its stages "bubbly" and "not bubbly."
When it is "not bubbly" and I pull some out, call this "discard" I use it in waffles, and crackers. Then I feed it, and in several hours it is "bubbly." If that "bubbly" starter floats, I consider it ready to use in bread dough.
Could you let me know where in this pattern I would find starter appropriate for using in this recipe's levain?
Maurizio L.
November 24, 2020
When I say "ripe" I mean a starter that's well-fermented: bubbly, has a sour aroma, has broken down some. It's an indication that the mixture has high populations of bacteria and wild yeast, which is what seeds our dough and kickstarts fermentation. For yours, I'd say when it's "bubbly" 🙂
Carolyn
November 12, 2020
Delicious as-in. Thank you! Do you think this dough could stand up to incorporating caramelized onions or another fold-in?
Maurizio L.
November 13, 2020
Glad to hear that, Carolyn! I think these could, especially since they're baked in a pan (which helps add structure).
CaptainGroovy
November 7, 2020
I am just starting to venture into baking rolls and breads that use milk and butter (up until now I have been baking "skinny breads and rolls" except for the occasional batch of pretzels. The first is why "warm water" and "Cold Milk" in the recipe dough ingredients list. It would seem to me that they should both start off at the same temperature because they will be once mixed. The next is I do not own a stand mixer so what is the best technique for adding in the butter, would it be best if I incorporated in the dough after mixing "the wet" and "the dry" together or should I turn my dough out and start kneading it and add it a couple pieces at a time whilst I am kneading it. Additionally you gave a recommendation for temperature for the proofing of the shaped dough in the pan (second rise) but none for the bulk fermentation and what are your thoughts on retarding the second rise overnight in a 38-40 degree F cold box and if one was to retard the dough overnight would you recommend it be warmed up an hour or two before baking it or baking it cold right out of the cold box. Look forward to hearing your thoughts and ideas. Have a great day and StaySafe-n-StayHealthy
Maurizio L.
November 9, 2020
Hey there! I call for warm water to offset the cold milk, which is typically cold since it's coming straight from the fridge (to make things easier). This way, the temperature will approximately end up around warm room temp or so. For adding the butter by hand, I'd first knead the dough for several minutes until smooth, then add the butter a pat at a time while continuing to mix and knead. Proofing overnight at 39F or so will work well—I'd stick them into the fridge right after shaping. You won't have to bring them up to room temp unless they look very under proofed (dense, not well risen), bake straight from the fridge. Happy baking!
bina
November 4, 2020
This is one of the best "Milk Rolls" recipes I've tried, and the sourdough makes them even more flavorful and more digestible in my opinion. I have one question - could they be made even fluffier and softer by using tangzhong? And what would the proportions look like? Thanks so much
Maurizio L.
November 5, 2020
So glad to hear that, Bina! Yes, they can be made fluffier, coincidentally, I just posted a recipe for sourdough tangzhong rolls at my website: https://www.theperfectloaf.com/super-soft-sourdough-rolls/ 🙂
WoodgroveChef
September 21, 2020
Made this yesterday and it’s wonderful, will definitely keep this recipe for good! My husband and son loved it, finished the first batch that I baked and ask me to do another again, today!
Maurizio L.
October 23, 2020
So glad to hear that! Be careful, you might find yourself making them every week (like I do 🙂). Enjoy!
dipity
September 20, 2020
I would like to retard because I like my sourdough really sour. And also I almost always find myself making the bread late into the night and retarding really helps with the scheduling. Question please: After shaping do I put it into the refrigerator right away or should I let it proof in room temp for a while and if so for how long? Also after retard, do I let it sit in room temp before baking and if so for how long? Thanks in advance for your response.
Maurizio L.
September 21, 2020
That'll work fine with these rolls. I would put them into the fridge right away after shaping, then in the morning, take them out and let them sit out until they meet the criteria I outline in the post when they're fully proofed: very soft to the touch and well-risen.
hannahrmoser
November 24, 2020
I'm making 10 batches of this today and am almost ready to shape. Is there a maximum amount of time to keep them in the fridge? I was hoping to bake right away in the morning, but that means they'll be in the fridge for at least 12 hours. The only other time I baked these I baked same day and they were phenomenal. I'm ok with some more sourness after retarding in the fridge, but I'm worried they'll be overly sour at 12+ hours in the fridge.
beccaainsley
September 19, 2020
Would love to make these but am cooking for two! Any thoughts on freezing either finished buns or prepared dough?? Thanks!
sheepdog55
September 19, 2020
I've made them several times and have frozen the baked buns. They turn out fine! I haven't tried freezing the dough.
Cathy G.
September 19, 2020
We cook for 2 and they were half eaten in one evening and gone by day 3. Stored them in a plastic locked container on the counter. Split them in half and heavily buttered the rolls and a skillet. Heated on low with a lid on the skillet. Oh yeah......
Vida
September 19, 2020
I freeze bread I've made all the time. I find it easier to just make a full batch and freeze whatever we won't eat quickly.
Maurizio L.
September 20, 2020
I haven't tried freezing these yet, they are usually gone so quick. I'd imagine if they were wrapped very well they'd do just fine! As far as the dough, I always prefer freezing the final baked loaf/rolls rather than the dough itself, as freezing could compromise some rise in the oven.
Karinlerew
December 8, 2020
Maurizio, I was wondering if I could bake the rolls to the point they have risen to their max and just started to brown. Then let them cool and then wrap well and freeze? I’d love to give these as Christmas gifts and want the recipients to enjoy the fragrance of the bread.
Also, I live in Santa Fe and didn’t know if your recipes needed high altitude adjustments? Thank you in advance!
Also, I live in Santa Fe and didn’t know if your recipes needed high altitude adjustments? Thank you in advance!
See what other Food52ers are saying.