This variation of a Hot Toddy gets an earthy citrus flavor from Peychaud's Orange Bitters, a sweet twist from the sweet vermouth and a nice round finish from the bourbon. - NWB —NWB
Test Kitchen Notes
Manhattans and Old Fashioneds are winter staples around our house. This drink, once mixed up, reminded me more of the latter than a Manhattan. I missed the sweetness usually present in a toddy, but the mister thought this version was perfect — a toddy for a non-sweet tooth. —emmanation
good Bourbon (I like Maker's Mark)
dashes Peychaud's Orange Bitters
strip of lemon zest
strip of orange zest
In This Recipe
Rub rim of glass with lemon and orange zest.
Mix bourbon, bitters, and sweet vermouth in glass.
Add hot water to bourbon mixture.
Squeeze lemon juice into the water and bourbon and let cool for a minute before drinking.