Bake
Lemon Chiffon Layer Cake
Popular on Food52
16 Reviews
VivianF123
May 26, 2023
Make it a few times. I say that because it gets easier every time. I actually doubled this recipe and it was perfect for 3 12inch cake rounds.
qwerty
May 25, 2022
Difficult to make with many parts but if you have a basic understanding of what a chiffon cake is, and italian meringue butter cream - then this recipe will work exactly as it's written. One star off just for the confusion regarding the lemon syrup (I didn't use it) - and I cheated (or did it properly ... this is debatable) and used a chiffon pan, baked 1 single cake and cooled it upside down - then sliced it into three but it turned out fab so... I highly recommend if you have 14 or so hours of time and want to bake something that is really special: this is the cake for your occasion.
kelly
May 13, 2022
I like to try challenging cake recipes and for somebody that bakes a cake maybe 2-3 times a year, this was challenging. Definitely worth it though. It was delicious and I learned new baking skills through the experience like how to make Italian meringue.
Thecook4u
August 2, 2021
Please correct recipe to reflect “baking powder” instead of “making powder”!
ellent124
August 2, 2021
Is the technique for piping the frosting in that detail that is shown in your book, or where to find it? Beautiful!
Fran
April 5, 2021
Made this for Easter dinner and it was a HIT! I did it over 3 days, firstly the lemon curd, then the cake and of course lastly the frosting. It is very rich,and you only need a little slice, but MAN OH MAN Is it lemonly! Which is a wonderful thing! Itmade a special occasion more special! Thank you!
Flowers
January 17, 2021
This recipe looked amazing! We were so excited to make a luscious lemon cake for my daughters birthday. However, something went very amiss. What did we do wrong? It’s hard as a rock!
It seems that when making the first part of the Cake batter it needed a lot more moisture, before adding the egg whites it was a consistency of cookie dough, is that right? Seemed so heavy and then difficult to fold the egg whites into something so dense.
With no instructions for the simple syrup and the hint that it would help with the dryness, I poured it over the cakes but it seemed a very insufficient volume to make much of a difference. I worry about adding more and making it soggy.
So disappointed with not enough time to redo...
It seems that when making the first part of the Cake batter it needed a lot more moisture, before adding the egg whites it was a consistency of cookie dough, is that right? Seemed so heavy and then difficult to fold the egg whites into something so dense.
With no instructions for the simple syrup and the hint that it would help with the dryness, I poured it over the cakes but it seemed a very insufficient volume to make much of a difference. I worry about adding more and making it soggy.
So disappointed with not enough time to redo...
Bakedaddy
January 3, 2021
I wanted a fluffy, sophisticated lemony cake. The cake itself went perfect. Icing brutal! How can you whip up egg whites, then add butter? All or any stiffness disappeared, and I'm left with gloop. What a mess. And where does the lemon syrup come into play? It's never mentioned where to add it. Very ambiguous instructions. I'm sure you knew what you were doing, but couldn't convey it coherently. Try to rejig your instructions
Chocowagon
January 25, 2021
I would recommend brushing the cake halves with the lemon syrup after they are cut, layer by layer, before you add the curd. Careful not to drench them! This method is the typical use of a simple syrup when assembling a cake to help flavor it and keep it moist.
Chocowagon
January 25, 2021
Also, did you make an Italian meringue before adding the butter to the frosting? From your comment it seems you may have forgotten to add the hot sugar, this would stabilize/cook the whipped whites and would make it possible to whip in the butter properly.
Squirrel22
January 8, 2022
I am not a baker but it seems to me that your egg mixture was still too warm. It was mentioned in the recipe that the bowl can't be warm to the touch. There is a video on YouTube which Erin posted with different kind of buttercreams and you can find there how to make Italian buttercream.
Squirrel22
January 8, 2022
https://food52.com/recipes/41452-italian-buttercream?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=SocialMarketing&utm_campaign=Editorial
See what other Food52ers are saying.