Bake
Extra Chocolatey German ChocolateĀ Cake
Popular on Food52
62 Reviews
Yiannis P.
May 30, 2023
After 3 years together, I finally made my BF's favourite type of cake for his birthdayāin previous years, I'd purchased one from a bakery because my kitchen was smaller & German Chocolate cakes just seemed too labour-intensiveā& it was a hit. The instructions were clear & straightforward &, as promised, the outcome was a moist & delicious cake. Unless he changes his birthday cake order, I'll be making him one of these ever year.
Jenna M.
May 8, 2023
LOVED this recipe. Jessie, you are a national treasure. I hope you get the joy back tenfold that you give to so many of us. This was our dear neighborās favorite cake, Mrs. Black. She loved to make it on Valentineās Day in a heart shaped pan. I made it for my sisterās birthday, and it took us both back to happy childhood memories. Thank you for this treasure, Jessie! (Mrs. Black didnāt do it with frosting, but I canāt wait to try it with the frosting too! I never say no to more chocolate :)).
Jenna M.
May 8, 2023
Thank you for taking the time to reply! Loved it and am making it again today as a thank you for our neighbor (who I conveniently invited over so that I can eat the cake as well LoL). Sending you hugs and sunshine!
Dean M.
September 4, 2022
Jessie, congratulations on both your cake and your good humor in the face of cranky critics. At the risk of seeming cranky myself, could I gently suggest you clarify that this style of cake has nothing to do with Germany? It was born in the U.S., and it was originally Bakerās Germanās chocolate cake, named in honor of Samuel German, who developed the recipe for sweet chocolate marketed by the Baker Company. Pity they didnāt call it Samās chocolate cake. Would have saved us a century of confusion.
Smaug
September 4, 2022
That was pointed out in the article. Us cranky critics are objecting to the use of the name for a different cake, not to that cake itself.
TomC
March 4, 2021
I made two out of three parts of this cake this weekend- the cake and frosting. For the filling, I used a caramelized sweetened-condensed milk recipe from Bon Ap's site that I've been making for years. It includes toasted coconut and pecans. The cake and frosting are both exceptional. The cake is delicate and difficult to frost but it is worth the extra care. The frosting replaced the ganache that I normally make. The frosting is sweet but less rich than the ganache. I look forward to trying the filling. This go-round I decided to save some time and stick to what has worked in the past. I still spent over four hours prepping and cleaning.
Jessie S.
March 4, 2021
i am happy to hear you were pleased and hope you will try the filling at some point, too. happy baking.
charles
February 27, 2021
My wife and I followed this recipe and liked parts but did not love it. We got the thin batter like it says to have but we saw all three cakes sink in the center and were ridiculously crumbly. We had to be really delicate with applying the frosting because of how much the cake was just falling apart. Speaking of the frosting, it was just intensely sweet, I ended up just scraping it off.
I will admit the cake itself did have a nice rich chocolate flavor and the filling was really good. Honestly, the filling is the one part of this dish I know I would make again, but I would not put it in the fridge. We put it in the fridge and ended up having to do a double boiler style thing to get it back down to a viscosity that could be applied to the cakes.
Overall, I would call this a really good cake idea, but not final product. There is always a chance that I screwed it up and/or me living in elevation a messed up the cake, but that still leaves the frosting being intensely sweet.
I will admit the cake itself did have a nice rich chocolate flavor and the filling was really good. Honestly, the filling is the one part of this dish I know I would make again, but I would not put it in the fridge. We put it in the fridge and ended up having to do a double boiler style thing to get it back down to a viscosity that could be applied to the cakes.
Overall, I would call this a really good cake idea, but not final product. There is always a chance that I screwed it up and/or me living in elevation a messed up the cake, but that still leaves the frosting being intensely sweet.
Jessie S.
February 27, 2021
I am so sorry to hear that you were not. 100% pleased with the cake. not sure why the layers were so crumbly and sunken - maybe the elevation? as for the filling in the refrigerator, i am going to modify the recipe, as i did not intend you to chill the filling in the fridge, i only suggested the fridge to help it come to room temp more quickly. but you're right - once it is colder than room temp, it is impossible to work with. as for the frosting, i do have a sweet tooth and apologies that u found it too sweet, but that is the way i tend to make frostings.
leighanne
February 25, 2021
Making next week for my grandmotherās 100th birthday! Iām so excited, it looks amazing and Iām sure she will love!
Yiannis P.
February 15, 2021
Just so I knowā¦where exactly am I meant to be spending my SIX HOURS of prep time?
Jessie S.
February 15, 2021
such a good question - hmmm. will try to inquire as to where that number came from . . .
Smaug
February 15, 2021
In the kitchen, where else? Back to work- this ain't no party, this ain't no disco, this ain't no foolin' around...
Jessie S.
February 16, 2021
just changed the prep time to 2 and a half hours, which includes 25 or so minutes to assemble the cake, 30 or so minutes to assemble the filling and frosting, 45 to so minutes to cool the cake, 20 or so minutes to assemble the cake and 30 or so minutes to chill before serving.
Smaug
January 19, 2021
If nothing else, this recipe inspired me to make the real thing. Surprisingly, I had to do some searching for the recipe- the current box just has the cupcake recipe, and the internet is full of "improved" versions- some kindly blogger posted the original (a xerox of an old Baker's chocolate box, actually). I very seldom make anything that sweet, but occasionally you have to have a pecan pie, or caramel or butterscotch, or German's chocolate cake. The rest of that sweetened coconut will likely die in captivity, and the toll in eggs and butter was not inconsiderable, but worth it- like most classic recipes, it really is much more than the sum of its parts.
Jessie S.
January 19, 2021
great to hear! glad you were able to track down the original recipe and that you enjoyed.
Mrs W.
December 30, 2020
My husband requested this cake for his birthday and I made it today after narrowing my selection to this recipe. We enjoyed making it together. I have only had German's chocolate cake once many years ago, made from a box I'm sure and only remember the coconut in the filling. He has had it several times and never with frosting. I am not a baker but found this recipe super easy to follow AND absolutely delicious. Due to my lack of experience, the cake layers were not consistent in size and it seemed to me that something like a spring form pan or no parchment might have made the layers smoother. Also, because of a nut allergy of someone we wanted to share it with, we left the pecans to add later. Thank you for this. We loved making it together and nearly ate it deconstructed, sooo luxe!
Jessie S.
December 30, 2020
Yay! So glad u found the cake easy and delicious. That makes my day!!!! XO
Cassandra B.
December 15, 2020
I personally think this recipe sounds like the bomb! I've always loved German Chocolate cake, but mostly for the coconut-pecan topping. You've added enough chocolate to make it a real chocolate cake :) My only issue is that I prefer smaller cakes...I might try to scale this one down for a single layer.
Smaug
December 15, 2020
Not really difficult; also, I believe the German's chocolate package gives a recipe for cupcakes.
Smaug
January 19, 2021
PS- if you have a couple of 7" pans, half the recipe will make a 7" two layer cake.
Rose F.
December 13, 2020
Question: is the cake recipe for one cake or for all three cakes?
Jessie S.
December 13, 2020
hmmm . . . did you read the recipe? forgive me if it was not clear, but the recipe calls for preparing three cake pans and then pouring batter into three pans . . . which means yes! the recipe makes all three layers!
Rose F.
December 23, 2020
Instead of asking if I read the recipe you could've just answered my question. You can't control peoples' reading experiences and I'm kind of astonished that you responded to my very simple question in that way. Clearly I did not read the recipe fully. No need to be rude. I only have two cake pans, so when I first looked at the recipe that was immediately on my mind. Try to understand where people are coming from. Thank you for eventually answering my question in your response. Your cake looks delicious.
Rose F.
December 23, 2020
My response was deleted! Thanks food52! Rude, middle-aged recipe writers get to continue their reign! Love that!
Jessie S.
December 23, 2020
gosh! i am so sorry. i did not mean to be rude at all - i was just asking - as a recipe writer you want to make sure your recipes are super clear and if what i had written that you had read was confusing, i wanted to change it!! am so sorry you were offended. not my intention at all. and thank you re: the cake looking delicious. that means a lot.
Jessie S.
December 23, 2020
i am so sorry about your response being deleted - but if i am the rude middle aged recipe writer, i want you to know it was not me!
Sinamen78
January 18, 2021
I didnāt have 3 pans either so I bought three 8 -8 1/2ā foil pans and it worked out great.
Sinamen78
January 18, 2021
Cake was excellent. Could easily have halved the chocolate frosting recipe. Had a lot left but will use it for something else. Delicious!!
Jessie S.
January 18, 2021
yes - there is a lot of frosting (i'm kind of a frosting fanatic š¤·āāļø
Paula F.
December 12, 2020
German chocolate cake made from scratch does not look like that
Jessie S.
December 12, 2020
Really? Hmmm . . . All of the components are homemade (ie:from scratch) - how is it supposed to look?
Jessie S.
December 13, 2020
I actually think the cake looks great! i did not style it, but i love what the food52 team did
Smaug
December 14, 2020
Looks unusual to me, too, because I've never seen a German's chocolate cake with chocolate frosting; generally the filling and frosting are the same coconut mixture. People will tinker, though- my mother couldn't stand coconut and used chopped pecans instead, and it was really good. German's chocolate (made by Baker's, which is no doubt now part of some huge conglomerate) is still available. As I recall it's pretty sweet- about 56%, I think.
Jessie S.
December 14, 2020
when developing the recipe, the research that i did revealed that a lot of folks actually DO lightly frost german chocolate cakes and so i decided to do that as well. as for the traditional, slightly gooey, german chocolate coconut pecan filling, the cake is filled with it and topped with it as well . . .
Prathima
December 14, 2020
I was scouring the web for a german chocolate cake recipe two weeks ago and found the same to be true. Some frost the sides with choc buttercream, and some don't. This filling seems to be universal -- and the evaporated milk improves the browning of the topping. Doesn't look like the cake I grew up with, because that one came from a Duncan Hines box, and we we only had a sheet pan. Seems strange to think there is one definitive recipe, as I'm sure no one wants to go back to what was actually printed on that box 100 years ago.
Jessie S.
December 14, 2020
agreed! i enjoy seeing how people have played with the recipe over the years and honestly love the addition of the frosting and the fact that i can add it to my recipe and yet still to be true to a beloved chocolate classic.
Smaug
December 14, 2020
No doubt- it's largely tilting at windmills (which can be more fun than you might think), but I do wish that when people come up with a new recipe they'd come up with a new name too. I understand that it's easier to market a familiar name, but it leads to a sort of semantic entropy that seems irreversible. At this point, "Beef Stroganoff" can be anything from a stew to a stir fry, "chili" can be pretty much anything red in a bowl, "pizza" can be anything flat, "Key Lime Pie" can be any sort of dessert with any kind of lime in it... This is not expanding or in any way improving the language, it's simply sending meanings to a vanishing point.
Jessie S.
December 23, 2020
when developing the recipe, the research that i did revealed that a lot of folks actually DO lightly frost german chocolate cakes and so i decided to do that as well. as for the traditional, slightly gooey, german chocolate coconut pecan filling, the cake is filled with it and topped with it as well . . .
Jessie S.
December 23, 2020
agreed Prathima! agreed! i enjoy seeing how people have played with the recipe over the years and honestly love the addition of the frosting and the fact that i can add it to my recipe and yet still to be true to a beloved chocolate classic.
Smaug
December 23, 2020
But it's not being true to a beloved chocolate classic. Unlike most well known dishes, German's chocolate cake is a very specific recipe from a very specific, known source. Pretty much everything in the arts, including cooking, is stolen from somewhere, and there's no reason why you can't steal the coconut frosting- which is pretty unique- and use it on a different cake. But different cake it is.
See what other Food52ers are saying.