Bake
Italian Easter Pie
Popular on Food52
5 Reviews
skehias
April 11, 2023
This was a showstopper on Easter. I read other's notes and these were key: adding water to the dough (just a couple Tablespoons), using jarred peppers and thus skipping the time consuming roasting part. Starting two days ahead was key for all the resting/cooling time involved.
Nancy
March 10, 2023
Haven't made this recipe by Elaine Lemm, but the deep dish pie looks great!
Have another similar recipe which I've made often, which tastes very good and has a bit more flexibility - in addition to cold, it can be served hot or room temperature.
By Anita Sheldon, first appeared in NYT 1972, then reprinted in 2010 in Amanda Hesser, ed,, Essential New York Times Cookbook.
see also
https://www.familycookbookproject.com/recipe/698214/easter-pie--anita-sheldons-torta-di-spinaci.html
Have another similar recipe which I've made often, which tastes very good and has a bit more flexibility - in addition to cold, it can be served hot or room temperature.
By Anita Sheldon, first appeared in NYT 1972, then reprinted in 2010 in Amanda Hesser, ed,, Essential New York Times Cookbook.
see also
https://www.familycookbookproject.com/recipe/698214/easter-pie--anita-sheldons-torta-di-spinaci.html
Karen D.
April 5, 2021
Made this for Easter 2021. It was excellent! But a few comments:
1- the pastry was dry. I was able to push the bottom pastry into the shell, but no-way was I going to be able to roll the top part. Needed to add water (I use the wet-your-hands-as-you-knead method).
2- with procuitto and salami, I left out the ham, there was enough meat!
3- could've used even more spinach
4- salt & pepper in the ricotta, never a bad idea!
5- I did all the cooling steps, but then reheated in the oven before serving. It came out hot and perfect, no slide or puddle. Stayed together as you'd expect a lasagne. Much nicer to have a hot dinner in the northern latitudes in April!
1- the pastry was dry. I was able to push the bottom pastry into the shell, but no-way was I going to be able to roll the top part. Needed to add water (I use the wet-your-hands-as-you-knead method).
2- with procuitto and salami, I left out the ham, there was enough meat!
3- could've used even more spinach
4- salt & pepper in the ricotta, never a bad idea!
5- I did all the cooling steps, but then reheated in the oven before serving. It came out hot and perfect, no slide or puddle. Stayed together as you'd expect a lasagne. Much nicer to have a hot dinner in the northern latitudes in April!
Darian
April 5, 2021
Excellent! We usually do pizza Sundays, so this was a perfect Easter meal. I found I needed to add a few tablespoons of water to the dough in order for it to come together. It was extremely dense to work with after the first chill, and I was worried it would be tough in the end, but it was tender and light after baking. I used bottled roasted red peppers as a shortcut, and a little less sausage as it was left from another recipe (more like 8oz). I let it cool for 3 hours before unmolding and it held together very well for slicing/serving. The finished pie was so flavorful and satisfying! We offered a little marinara sauce on the side for dipping. This easily made 6 hearty servings.
See what other Food52ers are saying.