Bake
1 Fruity Cake, 3 Ways
Popular on Food52
3 Reviews
corawiec52
January 29, 2022
I had the exact same issue as the other two reviews. The cake took 30-40 minutes longer to set in the middle than what was recommended in the recipe. I too had to tent the cake to keep it from burning on the top and sides before the center was set. I haven't cut into yet, but I am a little concerned that it will have some unevenly baked pockets and it seems oily to me as well.
Monica
September 30, 2021
The batter makes a delicious cake but I had the same issue with the cake being super soggy in the middle. I ended up baking it for almost 2 hours and tried to tent the edges to prevent further browning as they were cooked way before the middle was. I used halved plums in a single layer. The plums weighed approx 600g raw (pits removed).
Joshua
August 31, 2021
Made this cake this weekend as an upside down cake with fresh peaches.
The good news is that the batter is very easy to make and absolutely delicious. The parts of it that baked properly were also very moist with a great texture.
The bad news is that it did not bake through evenly - I think the root of the problem is the amount of butter and fruit called for in the bottom of the pan. I should have gone with my gut that 3tbsp was a lot of butter, and that I should have only used enough fruit to cover one even layer, which is far less than the amount of fruit called for in the recipe. Between the butter and fruit, I think there was too much extra liquid, so the middle of the cake that was in contact with the fruit came out relatively unbaked (though still very tasty). After 50 minutes the top (bottom?) of the cake was thoroughly baked, as were the sides, so I don't think leaving it in any longer would have been a solution as it was just too uneven.
I will definitely make this again, but go with my instincts rather than following the recipe so closely.
The good news is that the batter is very easy to make and absolutely delicious. The parts of it that baked properly were also very moist with a great texture.
The bad news is that it did not bake through evenly - I think the root of the problem is the amount of butter and fruit called for in the bottom of the pan. I should have gone with my gut that 3tbsp was a lot of butter, and that I should have only used enough fruit to cover one even layer, which is far less than the amount of fruit called for in the recipe. Between the butter and fruit, I think there was too much extra liquid, so the middle of the cake that was in contact with the fruit came out relatively unbaked (though still very tasty). After 50 minutes the top (bottom?) of the cake was thoroughly baked, as were the sides, so I don't think leaving it in any longer would have been a solution as it was just too uneven.
I will definitely make this again, but go with my instincts rather than following the recipe so closely.
See what other Food52ers are saying.