Bake
Whole-Wheat Sourdough Sandwich Bread
Popular on Food52
35 Reviews
angi
January 18, 2023
Can I make this with bread flour instead of all purpose, and if so, would the measurements be the same?
Fritz L.
January 5, 2023
Do you have advice on how to adjust this recipe to a larger Pullman pan? Is it just a matter of scaling all ingredients up by 50%?
Maurizio L.
January 5, 2023
That should work, I usually like to use about 1300g in those larger Pullman Pans!
Berger
March 23, 2023
Hi there, love your recipes. I'm just trying to sort out weight measurements for my 13x4x4 Pullman Loaf Pan. I see you said you like to use about 1300g in those larger Pullman Pans. But I can't figure out how you get 1300. My math, if I add up each of your ingredients (=999g) and add 50% of each ingredient, I get 1,498? Maybe there's another size pan in between small and mine? Thanks!
Britt W.
August 24, 2022
Can I put in the fridge to ferment for a while instead of on the counter for an hour and a half? Also if I want to add oats to the top is that before or after fridge proof?
Maurizio L.
August 24, 2022
Yes, absolutely! After shaping, cover the pans and place in the fridge. Bake next day in the morning or early afternoon. Add the oats right after shaping.
Britt W.
August 25, 2022
Thank you so much the loaf turned out beautifully! My husband said it’s the best I’ve ever made so thank you!
mchavez
May 8, 2022
This came out great! Excellent rise and a nice soft crumb. Any thoughts about increasing the honey or substituting the honey with molasses?
I love your recipes (here and on your website).The timing guidelines that you provide are key. Can’t wait for more recipes!
I love your recipes (here and on your website).The timing guidelines that you provide are key. Can’t wait for more recipes!
Maurizio L.
May 8, 2022
So glad it worked out well for you! Molasses would work just fine in lieu of the honey. If you increase the honey drastically, it may affect fermentation (slow it). If you increase the honey, just be aware of this and adjust the fermentation time as needed (increase bulk and/or proof). Enjoy and thx for the comments!
wrightc0812
January 29, 2022
This bread is delicious! Mine also did not rise as much as yours. How much should it rise in the pan before baking? I used a pullman loaf pan and it was about halfway up the side when I baked it, but it was light and airy. Maybe I should have let it rise further? Also, is the honey 100% necessary for the dough or is it more for flavor? Thanks for another great recipe! I will definitely be making it again.
Maurizio L.
January 29, 2022
Glad to hear that! I would let it rise more, it likely needed more time. It should fill most of the pan. The honey does add a bit to the fermentation (at low %), but you can omit, just be sure to give it a bit more time, especially if you leave out the honey.
liltrukr
October 31, 2021
Whole-Wheat Sourdough Sandwich Bread! I made two loaves and they came out good 👍thank you @maurizio for this lovely recipe. P.S. made them with just starter...🥪🍞 100%
liltrukr
November 1, 2021
Thank you so much Maurizio, have posted the pictures on then pictures on Instagram if you wanna look you can see them out of the 🍞🥪
Jeremy M.
October 23, 2021
Hey! I just baked my first loaf. I’m super excited to try it and it smells so good (still cooling), but it definitely did not rise as much as yours or as much as I expected. My (most recent) starter is very new (I’ve used TPF recipes for about two years of on and off baking), but it’s been very powerful, usually tripling it’s volume in 12 hours. Any ideas where this loaf could have gone wrong?
Maurizio L.
October 25, 2021
Hey, Jeremy! Do you think it might have been under proofed? Usually that results in huge rise, but it's possible that might have been the cause. Additionally, it could be over hydration, if the dough felt excessively wet.
Jeremy M.
October 25, 2021
I proofed right on mark with your timing in the recipe. I do use a proofing mat for heat. Could too high of heat been the issue? Dough tends to proof around 84-85° on that mat. It did feel on the wetter side. What increments would you adjust water by for testing? Thanks!
Maurizio L.
October 25, 2021
Wetter for these pan loaves is usually better--you get a more tender interior! But at some point it will compromise rise. I'd try holding back maybe 25g water and see how that bakes up.
bdejong
October 23, 2021
I've been on the lookout for a good whole wheat sandwich bread, and this one did not disappoint! I started it late in the day and put it in the fridge overnight after shaping to bake the next morning. The first time I added sesame and sunflower seeds (about ½ cup total) and it was great, although I didn't score it so the side burst out. The next time I did pumpkin and sunflower seeds and did score it, and it was perfect. This time I added a LOT of chopped dates and about ½ cup of walnuts and it is delicious! Thank you for this!
Maurizio L.
October 23, 2021
Awesome, happy to hear it when well both times! If you're seeing a lot of blow outs on the side, try proofing for a bit longer to tame that oven spring a bit, it'll result in a tenderer loaf, too. Have fun and enjoy!
liltrukr
October 21, 2021
Hi Maurizio, I decided to double the recipe and made two loaves, so glad that I did, absolutely delicious 🤗😷🙏🥪
Liz S.
October 5, 2021
LOVED this!! I did sub 30 grams of spelt for 30 grams (trade) of whole wheat because I like a bit of spelt or rye when I make a whole wheat anything.
Also, I baked in an oblong clay baker (with cover). I noted that you specified steam and it was late for me ... so instead of a bread pan, I decided to do the clay baker. My baker is 13 x 5 x 4 so my loaf was long and not as tall, but that works for me. Instead of steaming the oven, I allowed the baker to handle that. I did slash the dough and I want to try again without a slash. The loaf did have an ear, and looked artisanal, but the crust was soft and the crumb perfect for a sandwich loaf. I am curious to see what happens without a slash, i.e. will the crust "hold" vs breaking ?? At any rate, it is an easy and delicious sandwich loaf. Thank you, Maurizio!
Also, I baked in an oblong clay baker (with cover). I noted that you specified steam and it was late for me ... so instead of a bread pan, I decided to do the clay baker. My baker is 13 x 5 x 4 so my loaf was long and not as tall, but that works for me. Instead of steaming the oven, I allowed the baker to handle that. I did slash the dough and I want to try again without a slash. The loaf did have an ear, and looked artisanal, but the crust was soft and the crumb perfect for a sandwich loaf. I am curious to see what happens without a slash, i.e. will the crust "hold" vs breaking ?? At any rate, it is an easy and delicious sandwich loaf. Thank you, Maurizio!
Maurizio L.
October 21, 2021
That's awesome to hear, Liz! I'd love to see what that would do with out a score too.. Probably a nice domed top. Either way, delicious!
Liz S.
October 23, 2021
Yesterday I made a variation(s) ... I wanted a bit larger amount to fill my oblong clay baker ... and I wanted a rye loaf. I decided to try 120%. With rye, I knew I wanted my white flour to be at least 50% of the flour total. Anyway, I did this: 132 g starter, 403 g water, 330 g white, 190 g rye, 80 g spelt, 32 g olive oil, 32 g honey, 11 g salt, 1 tsp caraway (I ground the caraway seeds with the salt). The rye flour was KAF whole rye, white is WheatMT AP (but it is 13% protein aka bread flour), spelt is a sprouted spelt. I do the "throw all in the mixer" vs overnight levain: water, then starter, then flours, then the rest. Mix until combined, let rest for 30ish minutes, mix to "whap-whap-whap" and then into an oiled bowl for the bulk. I started about 6:30 a.m. and called the bulk about 4 p.m. (very cool house: 64F). After shape ... baked at 7:30 p.m. And this time, no slash. I had some blow out. I read your comment above so will try a longer rise next time, but except for appearance, it was a wonderful loaf with a soft crust and beautiful crumb. It ended up what I wanted which was a kind of deli-sandwich-rye.
So ... another argument for weight measuring as that makes it so easy to scale up or down, even just a little bit. AND, sticking to overall % while trying different flours ... although the baker needs to understand that some flours, like rye, need some special consideration.
So ... another argument for weight measuring as that makes it so easy to scale up or down, even just a little bit. AND, sticking to overall % while trying different flours ... although the baker needs to understand that some flours, like rye, need some special consideration.
palin52
October 5, 2021
Interesting recipe. Since you have a lot of American readers, did you consider using parallel measurements for the ease of your consumers (cups, tablespoons, etc.)?
palin52
October 5, 2021
By the way, this is really directed at Food 52, not the Italian whose recipe it is; he knows the measurements he’s used to, but Food52 might want to be a little more inclusive.
Maurizio L.
October 5, 2021
No worries, it's a great question. With baking, I prefer weighing ingredients instead of using volume--it's far more accurate. Scooping/tamping/leveling off flour in a scoop can lead to inaccuracies depending on how it's done and the flour itself, and this is also seen with every other ingredient (especially salt). So in the end, it's not about region or excluding an audience, it's just a move toward accuracy (and it's what most bread bakers do in bakeries, too!).
Liz S.
October 5, 2021
As an American that has measured by weight and not volume ... for years ... and if you go to any of the "bread specific" sites .. mostly U.S. persons ... serious bread bakers measure by weight for all of the reasons that Maurizio state.
Writing a "bread" recipe in volume leads to a LOT of failures in my experience because of the inaccuracy in volume measures. It has nothing to do with being inclusive ... and I will admit that that word provokes a knee jerk reaction for me even though the complaint about weight comes up often ... it should not among those who want to bake successfully.
And an example. I made this recipe. I wanted to add a bit of spelt flour as I like a little spelt in with whole wheat. Additionally, I use a local to me flour that is 38 g = 1/4 cup vs many AP flours that are 30 g = 1/4 cup. When I measure all flours by weight and keep to the overall weight for the recipe, I have zero issues.
Writing a "bread" recipe in volume leads to a LOT of failures in my experience because of the inaccuracy in volume measures. It has nothing to do with being inclusive ... and I will admit that that word provokes a knee jerk reaction for me even though the complaint about weight comes up often ... it should not among those who want to bake successfully.
And an example. I made this recipe. I wanted to add a bit of spelt flour as I like a little spelt in with whole wheat. Additionally, I use a local to me flour that is 38 g = 1/4 cup vs many AP flours that are 30 g = 1/4 cup. When I measure all flours by weight and keep to the overall weight for the recipe, I have zero issues.
FrontRangeBaker
October 2, 2021
Just baked this loaf today and it is wonderful - smells and tastes heavenly. I liked how easy it was and the overnight levain (only 5 grams of starter?!)
Maurizio L.
October 3, 2021
So glad to hear you liked it! And yes, that's the power of our starters!
See what other Food52ers are saying.