Sheet Pan

Chubby Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

January 29, 2011
5 Ratings
Author Notes

Sometimes in my kitchen, mistakes lead to creative inspiration. Case in point, this cookie, which started out as my usual all-time favorite NY Times chocolate chip cookie recipe. On one of the snow days last winter, Sconeboy had a couple of his buddies over. So I, being the bestest mom in the world, decided to make cookies for the boys. Seeing as the first batch was quickly being scarfed down, I moved on to batch #2 and somehow got mixed up with how many cups of flour I had added – I think after one of the boys came in to ask for another glass of milk. I hedged my bets and added what I thought was the last cup of flour, but turned out really to be an extra cup of flour. Anyways, since the “mistake”, I’ve been tweaking this fat-cookie recipe and have decided it’s really good and worth sharing with you all. Oh, and here's the link to the original NY Times recipe. —mrslarkin

  • Prep time 20 minutes
  • Cook time 18 minutes
  • Makes about 20 cookies, depending on how much cookie dough you eat
  • 2 sticks unsalted butter (1 cup), softened to room temp.
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 cup packed DARK brown sugar
  • 1 tablespoon molasses (optional)
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
  • 3 large eggs
  • 4 cups all-purpose flour (1 1b. 2 oz., or 509 g.) Weigh the flour!
  • **It's important to weigh the flour for proper chewiness,
  • or if spooning flour into measuring cups, remove about a tablespoon of flour from each cup**
  • 2 3/4 teaspoons Diamond Crystal kosher salt (be advised, some other kosher salt brands are saltier)
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 3 to 4 cups semisweet chocolate chips
  • flaky sea salt, like Maldon, for topping the cookies
  • a cold glass of milk
In This Recipe
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line 4 heavy-duty cookie sheets with parchment paper.
  2. Cream together butter, sugars and molasses in mixer bowl fitted with paddle attachment.
  3. Add vanilla and beat for a minute or two.
  4. Add eggs one at a time, and beat until combined.
  5. Add flour, salt and baking soda to the egg mixture, and pulse until flour is just incorporated, then beat on medium speed for a minute or two. Stop the mixer, and using a spatula or plastic bowl scraper, check for pockets of flour underneath, and mix in.
  6. Add chocolate chips and mix on medium-low speed until combined. Cookie dough will be very thick and stiff, and will try to escape if you've got a small Kitchenaid mixer. Push it back down into the bowl if it does that.
  7. Using a large cookie scoop, place balls of dough about 2 1/2 inches apart. My balls of dough are about 3 ounces each. Smaller than a tennis ball, but bigger than a ping pong ball.
  8. Roll balls gently to smooth out the edges, if you'd like a neat cookie. Press balls gently with the back of a fork, or your fingers, or the bottom of a glass, or whatever, to ever so slightly flatten. (OK, I've recently started baking the cookies WITHOUT PRESSING THEM. And I think I like them better this way. You decide.)_
  9. At this point, cookies can be frozen and baked off at a later time. Place them in one layer on a parchment-lined sheet pan and stash in the freezer overnight, or for several hours. I prefer this freezing method, and I'm convinced it produces a chewier cookie, but I could also just be imagining it all. In any event, proceed with the freezing. You won't be sorry.
  10. Sprinkle tops with flaky sea salt (this is totally optional, but so so yummy.) Bake for 16 to 18 minutes (depending on if you like super chewy cookies or well done cookies), rotating back-to-front and top-to-bottom at mid-point. Don't over-bake, or you'll lose the chewiness.
  11. Cookies will be pale and won't brown very much on top, but will be lightly golden brown underneath. Slide entire parchment onto a cooling rack. You want your cookies to bend as you are sliding the parchment to the cooling rack - this is where those attractive grooves and cracks happen.
  12. Get your cold glass of milk. Taste a warm cookie. Mmmm...Isn't it good?
  13. Store cookies in an air-tight cookie jar or sealed plastic bag. Cookies reheat nicely in the microwave for about 15 seconds.
  14. Alternatively, for a small cookie, roll dough into 1" balls. Place on parchment-lined sheet pan about 1" apart. Slightly flatten balls. Bake for 10 - 12 minutes. Makes about 5 dozen small cookies. Small unbaked cookies can also be frozen and baked off at a later time.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • CassyB
  • Naomi
  • littlechef16
  • CarlaCooks
  • TheWimpyVegetarian