Banana
Banana Cream Pie with Macadamia Nut, Honey & Cardamom Brittle
Popular on Food52
37 Reviews
Kathyw
December 1, 2021
My go-to banana cream pie recipe!! I don’t do the brittle on top, just some toasted almonds are plenty.
kristenh
February 8, 2015
I have made this pie twice now and preparing to make it a third time. It is a absolutely lovely recipe. I used local organic whole milk and I had no idea how much flavor milk really should have. I make this recipe for the birthdays of friends and families. Highly Recommend!
Daniella P.
September 5, 2013
The closes pie dish I have it 24cm. If I used that one, would I have to make a bigger quantity for the biscuit base?
Ta! X
Ta! X
ZombieCupcake
February 16, 2013
Want to say thank you for this recipe made my grandfather and my birthday a great one! Think I ate 1/3 of it myself this will definitely be a birthday present to myself every year!
me B.
January 14, 2012
I have never tasted banana cream pie (yes, I know!) but this is going to be the next dessert I make for my family. WIth the delicious brittle and homemade whipped cream, I believe this will be my new sinful treat!
rhubarb_season
June 23, 2011
this was my first attempt at banana cream pie and most definitely the tastiest one i've ever had. i made it for a birthday and everyone raved about it. my brittle turned out perfect too (i used the water test) but i did substitute macadamia nuts for walnuts because of cost and it still tasted great. thanks for a fantastic recipe!
Stockout
February 5, 2011
I couldn't pass up this recipe. Hands down my favorite pie, I haven't been able to buy a decent one for as long as I can remember, but at least 30 years. This recipe gives me no excuse anymore. What I wouldn't give to be able to lay on a layer of whipped cream the way you did but I will not let that stop me. Thanks for the inspiration. Excellent execution.
thirschfeld
February 6, 2011
thank you Stockout. I had not had banana cream pie in a long time either and this one really hit the spot. Let me know if you try it.
monkeymom
February 3, 2011
lucky lucky girls you have! banana cream pie is a fav around here. I love the easy crust and the brittle comb here. So good!
Constrained C.
February 3, 2011
love this update on banana cream pie. the brittle sounds delicious and is so beautiful sprinkled on top!
edamame2003
February 3, 2011
this is the most perfect looking pie i've ever seen. drooling...thank you sharing the recipe; though sadly i don't bake.
nannydeb
February 1, 2011
Yummy and beautiful!
thirschfeld
February 1, 2011
thanks nannydeb, thanks for sending the ice storm our way or I probably wouldn't have made this.
Aliwaks
February 1, 2011
OH MY GOD! ...thirschfeld, I feel like I say that about all your recipes..but really wow!!!!
drbabs
February 1, 2011
Love. I was thinking about the combination of banana and cardamom today, too. Stay warm!
thirschfeld
February 1, 2011
Thanks drbabs and I hope to see a banana cardamom post from you. We will be plenty warm.
hardlikearmour
February 1, 2011
Gorgeous photo! Hope the castaways don't get too stir crazy.
hardlikearmour
February 1, 2011
Come to think of it, I loved snow days as a kid growing up in WI. We'd go out sledding or just play. Have fun with the monkeys!
mrslarkin
February 1, 2011
Yum.
thirschfeld
February 1, 2011
Yep, diner counter, a cup of Joe, some bell bottom blues and your day would be set right
mrslarkin
February 1, 2011
Guess what's for dessert tonight? I can't stop eating the pudding, though, so there may not be a pie at all.
thirschfeld
February 1, 2011
there is definitely a little more pudding than needed, both girls had a little warm vanilla pudding for lunch, let me know how you like it
mrslarkin
February 1, 2011
Holy smokes, this was good. Truth be told, my pie looked like a sad, pathetic attempt at replicating your pie perfection. Mine looked fugly, but it tasted damn fine. My brittle was delicious but not chop-able. More like stretchy. Maybe I didn't let the honey foam up enough?
The pudding alone is outstanding - and I must thank you thirschfeld, as I've been on a mission to find a good custard for the past 2 weeks. (Long story involving Dr. Who.)
We will be enjoying leftovers for breakfast, with a cuppa joe, and definitely will make this again in the future. Thanks!
The pudding alone is outstanding - and I must thank you thirschfeld, as I've been on a mission to find a good custard for the past 2 weeks. (Long story involving Dr. Who.)
We will be enjoying leftovers for breakfast, with a cuppa joe, and definitely will make this again in the future. Thanks!
thirschfeld
February 2, 2011
I have been a little worried about the brittle. It worked perfect when I did it but there is so little honey you can't really get a candy therm. into it. I am thinking the plate test might be good. I am going to look into it and maybe do a little editing later. I am so glad you liked it though. Dr. Who being that time travel show?
mrslarkin
February 2, 2011
Going to have a slice right now with my coffee, sit and enjoy the rain in my living room. :) Yes, that show - big ScyFy fans in the house.
See what other Food52ers are saying.