Make Ahead
Caramel Banana Pudding with Amazing Sauce
Popular on Food52
5 Reviews
Rebecca C.
June 10, 2015
I might now know why no one has commented in four years. Even though, I checked this recipe against other banana pudding recipes and my elementary knowledge of pudding making, I went with it, anyway. The work became a series of rescue attempts. In the end, it'll turn out pudding shape, form, and consistency (waiting for it to set, now) and will taste more like caramel pudding with hints of muddy banana than the refreshing raw banana flavor with hints of caramel, I thought it might. Nonetheless, not bad for a first time.
Ann M.
March 12, 2011
Made this today for a dinner party. I used potato starch instead of cornstarch due to gluten allergies in the group and it didn't set up well. I was wondering if I shouldn't have put it through the strainer a second time? Or if I had the potato starch - cornstarch ratio off. The flavor, however, was great! Will try it again with corn starch.
lizb
March 12, 2011
Ann, I've never tried substituting potato starch for cornstarch, so I can't speak to that, but you could make this without the cornstarch by increasing the eggs to four yolks and two whole eggs. I prefer a little less egg flavor so I suggested a little egg and a little cornstarch, but I love how creamy the extra egg makes the pudding if you go the all egg route. I hope it sets up better next time!
warholamm
March 8, 2011
beautiful! instead of discarding the bananas, they were added to the cookie mixture and baked for 15 minutes. this turns into more of a bread pudding consistency, so if you prefer to have a crunchy topping this wouldn't be suggested. my family licked the bowls clean. thanks for the recipe!
lizb
March 10, 2011
What a cool idea with the bananas, I bet that's good on it's own! Glad you enjoyed it.
See what other Food52ers are saying.