Serves a Crowd
First Night in Florence Spaghetti
Popular on Food52
225 Reviews
Erin B.
February 26, 2024
This is a staple in our house, especially during the week. Everyone I have made this for has loved it. I usually order Ortiz tuna from Amazon, they come in a 4 pack and I use 2 per recipe. I have even used diced canned tomatoes in a pinch and it was still delicious. It tastes like you spent a lot more time on dinner than you did!
Karen
October 5, 2023
Looking forward to trying this.
I grew up eating spaghetti and tuna sauce every Friday, but the addition of spinach and lemon sounds divine!
(and my very Italian family loves
Pecorino on tuna sauce!)
I grew up eating spaghetti and tuna sauce every Friday, but the addition of spinach and lemon sounds divine!
(and my very Italian family loves
Pecorino on tuna sauce!)
boulangere
October 6, 2023
Thank you for your story of spaghetti with tuna sauce, Karen. It's always the story that makes food interesting.
Nancy M.
July 19, 2023
This. Is. Good. Make it. I used a jar of tuna fillets but it would have been good with canned anyway. Do have bread. The sauce needs to be mopped up.
karmaya
January 4, 2023
never would have thought 'tuna with pasta', but this is delicious. i use a can of Tonino tuna in oil for this.. the only tuna i buy now. Now and then I have used arugula when i had no spinach.. and it's not a bad substitute. i prepare "first night in florence" about once every 6 weeks and I've passed on the url to many friends. (oh and the story is a delight to read!) Thanks!
boulangere
January 5, 2023
How kind of you to share your story! I'm so glad you've enjoyed it. I make it as often as you do - just last night, in fact. Thank you, and Happy New Year!
Therese
April 27, 2021
Lovely! Really really good. Made just as written. My whole family enjoyed. Will definitely make again!
boulangere
April 28, 2021
Thank you, Therese! It always makes me so happy to hear this makes others happy.
Michelle
March 14, 2021
Love love love this recipe, which is more than the sum of its parts. However, one thing confuses me. The instructions mentioned garlic, but the ingredients do not. Can anyone solve the mystery of the missing garlic? thank you!
Reagan P.
January 9, 2021
Cannot recommend this recipe more! I've been making it at least once a month and sometimes more for the last 2 years and it truly never gets old. It's incredibly quick, simple, but the flavors are so so good. Don't skip this one!
Emily S.
July 17, 2020
I made this tonight, exactly as written, and we were not disappointed! I am amazed that a dish that came together in under 15 minutes could have such good, complex flavor! Mallory B stated my thoughts exactly: this recipe takes really humble ingredients and makes them into something exceptional. This was a great use for the cans of tuna that we stocked up on early in the COVID lockdown! :)
NXL
July 14, 2020
Thank you for giving me permission to use all of that delicious olive oil! The sauce was fantastic. I think it would be just as good without the tuna.
boulangere
July 14, 2020
Oh, you are so very welcome! I have made it without the tuna, and you’re right, it’s delicious. Thank you so much.
Hollyo1224
July 7, 2020
I made this last night. It was heaven. I doubled the recipe because my fam loves pasta, and I had enough to save for another time. I used fresh escarole instead of the spinach for more bite, and I also added a Vidalia onion for its sweetness. Definitely will make again!
Heather B.
June 20, 2020
I made this one last night, with spaghetti, and it was So good. Lots of olive oil, and prep. everything beforehand so that you’re ready to go. A useful recipe if you have a glut of tomatoes, and spinach growing in your garden. This is one that I will do again soon.
boulangere
July 14, 2020
Using what is on hand is always a good idea, especially these Covid days. I’ve even made it with bow ties. Thank you, Heather!
Jennifer P.
May 16, 2020
I followed the recipe exactly, using high quality ingredients, but this was just not for us. The delicious dish was ruined by (relatively expensive) canned tuna. I love fish, I love Italian pasta, but the fishy taste of catfood was just unbearably off-putting. It also needed more vegetables, so I quickly sauteed some zucchini and eggplant I had on hand.
One thing to those making it... Do NOT skip the lemon.
We'll go back to making the same style tomato sauce with fresh basil and cheese. Sorry!
One thing to those making it... Do NOT skip the lemon.
We'll go back to making the same style tomato sauce with fresh basil and cheese. Sorry!
boulangere
May 17, 2020
One size doesn’t fit all. You make a good point, though: don’t skip the lemon; it’s what brings all the flavors together. Good for you for trying something new, and thanks for giving the recipe and its story a go.
Mary J.
May 10, 2020
I think I was drawn to the story and am actually surprised by how much I enjoyed this. Thanks for sharing!
Regine
April 28, 2020
Delicious pasta and sauce. My only comment is to say that salting this dish properly further heightens flavor. I found myself adding more salt after mixing the pasta into the sauce. I had no bread to
eat with the remaining sauce so I stored the little bit that was left. Also, this dish was barely enough for the 2 of us so next time I may double it. Thanks for recipe.
eat with the remaining sauce so I stored the little bit that was left. Also, this dish was barely enough for the 2 of us so next time I may double it. Thanks for recipe.
boulangere
May 17, 2020
You prove the cooking rule: always taste everything! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
Mm
April 18, 2020
Had to use penne and baby kale and it was still wonderful! Topped with freshly ground black pepper and red pepper flakes.
Thank you boulangere!!!
Thank you boulangere!!!
Laura R.
April 16, 2020
This dish holds a special place in heart. It always takes me back to Italy as it was a staple for a cheap and quick meal any night of the week or “pranzo.” And now during these unprecedented and difficult times, it has brought comfort and true joy to make and eat, if only to bring me to a happier (more delicious) place. Its also oddly more delicious eaten room temp. Thanks for sharing, Stay Safe!
Laura R.
April 16, 2020
This dish holds a special place in heart. It always takes me back to Italy as it was a staple for a cheap and quick meal any night of the week or “pranzo.” And now during these unprecedented and difficult times, it has brought comfort and true joy to make and eat, if only to bring me to a happier (more delicious) place. Its also oddly more delicious eaten room temp. Thanks for sharing, Stay Safe!
boulangere
May 17, 2020
It is! I’ve even turned leftovers into a next day panzanella with lots of fresh greens. Good to know we share similar memories.
Deb
April 10, 2020
As much as we looovved this recipe, it would be nice if you could print it without the (great) backstory included. It takes up almost a page!
Thanks for the recipe!
Thanks for the recipe!
boulangere
April 10, 2020
I agree, Deb, and thank you. I’d suggest you pass your comment along to the editors .
Alyson C.
April 15, 2020
I loved the backstory. Brought back memories of trips to Italy and inspired me to want to make it!
carswell
April 17, 2020
The backstory brought back memories of my first jet lagged meal in Italy with the friends I was travelling with. I enjoyed reading it and remembering how sublime simple food in Italy can be.
See what other Food52ers are saying.