Recipe Trophy

Bell-less, Whistle-less, Damn Good French Toast

Your Best French Toast Contest Winner!

Bell-less, Whistle-less, Damn Good French Toast

Photo 1 of 3
by Sarah Shatz

Bell-less, Whistle-less, Damn Good French Toast

Photo 2 of 3
by Sarah Shatz

Bell-less, Whistle-less, Damn Good French Toast

Photo 3 of 3
by Kayb

Slideshow
  • This recipe was entered in the contest for Your Best French Toast
  • A&M's Testing Notes: There's nothing to making this French toast. But there is one thing that makes it exceptional: cream. KayB cuts to the chase, forgoing spices and extracts, and focussing instead on eggs, cream...

    Expand Collapse
  • Chef

    Kayb's Notes: There are things in life that just ought to be simple, and to my taste buds, French toast is one of them. Mine has only three ingredients, depending on the quality of the bread to carry the...

    Expand

Serves 4

  1. Slice challah into 3/4 to 1-inch thick slices.

    Ask a question about this step
  2. Whisk together eggs and cream.

    Ask a question about this step
  3. Heat a griddle or flat grill pan over medium high heat, and add 1 tbsp butter for every two pieces of French toast it will accommodate; swirl butter around to cover surface.

    Ask a question about this step
  4. Dip slice of bread in egg and cream; flip and repeat. Add to griddle, and grill until golden (approximately 90 seconds) on one side; flip and repeat.

    Ask a question about this step
  5. Serve with additional butter, if desired, and good quality maple syrup. The experience is enhanced with the addition of good quality smoked bacon.

    Ask a question about this step

43 Comments on Bell-less, Whistle-less, Damn Good French Toast

Dsc_4978 Reply

I love french toast, but have never used challah bread until today - I may never go back!!! Thanks for the simple and AMAZING recipe!

Reply

I found this recipe and made it for breakfast this morning - I used Texas Toast bread instead of challah bread. The bread was thick and was able to absorb the cream & milk without turning soggy or falling apart. It turned out awesome! :)

049 Reply

Made this for Saturday breakfast and it was delicious! I normally do french toast with eggs and a splash of milk but never again. I didn't use challah bread as I had no idea where to get it but I got a lovely tin loaf that I cut into thick slices and it worked a trick.
Thanks for the recipe :)

149130_100440840028137_100001866631527_1389_855041_n Reply

I'm going to need a recipe for real challah bread. There isn't a bakery in town who makes it. Anyone have one they like? I love french toast, carbs and all.

Reply

Excellent recipe: simple and outstanding! Made this today on a very cold NYC morning! My 4.5 yr old and I LOVED it!

Kay_at_lake Reply

So glad you enjoyed! I also just recently learned you can cook a whole loaf, then heat it up in the toaster oven for a quick breakfast for snack!

S1051882 Reply

really great challah is indeed crucial for an awesome french toast. this is a great easy recipe. definitely bacon on the side!!

Tarte_tatin Reply

I just started making this recently and it has already become the go-to French toast recipe in our house.

Reply

My favorite French Toast combo, however: i like a well-soaked, slow-cooked result so i use many more eggs, more cream and lots of butter (and require a patient family!!)

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

We're crazy about this, too! I actually bought some bread (challah) to make this for my sons' Christmas morning breakfast. We served the French toast with lingon that a dear friend (a fellow food52 cook who I met here!!) brought back from Sweden for me. Really outstanding! We love this recipe and are looking forward to enjoying it again . . . . and again. ;o)

Reply

May I just say YUM! I made this for breakfast with the bread I had on hand, brioche, and the result was outstanding. Thank you for this delicious recipe!

Reply

This recipe yields the perfect french toast. I tried the same recipe with brioche and challah. I liked the brioche version better, the bread had a natural sweetness to it.
I used to include all the bells and whistles like vanilla essence, cinnamon etc in my french toasts. But now I am a convert - there is no better way to make french toasts ! Thanks.

Reply

Very good recipe. I tried it today. I substituted heavy cream for mascarpone. Might try it with Creme de la Gruyere in the future...

Profile Reply

This is pretty close to my favorite french toast recipe... one difference is to add about 2T honey, and make the custard the night before and let it sit in the fridge. Mmmm. Make it this weekend for guests and got rave reviews. Congrats on the win for this classic!

Reply

We made it for dinner Saturday night and my daughter declared it the best french toast she'd ever tasted. I, too, loved it... and it coated my stomach well for the Corpse Reviver 2 that followed a few hours later. Don't think I'll be making french toast any other way from here on. Oh yum.

Raquel4 Reply

This is exactly the same as my grandmother's recipe, except she would sprinkle with sugar after dipping in the egg/cream for a little brulee action. Heaven!

Junepr05 Reply

Growing up, Mom made French toast many Sunday mornings, because Dad loved it so much. This version was always the best! and he never put anything on it except granulated sugar.

Reply

Recipe looks great! Sorry I can't turn off the editor I me :),...the ingedient list calls for heavy cream, but step 4 of the instructions says to dip bread in "egg and milk" mixture. Should this be 'egg and heavy cream' mixture? Just want to be sure I am not missing an ingedient... Thanks!

Kay_at_lake Reply

It should indeed be egg and cream mixture (or half and half) when I don't have heavy cream on hand. It is but a pale imitation of the real thing.... :)

Kay_at_lake Reply

Oops. meant to write "I use milk when I don't have heavy cream on hand." Nothing like an afternoon poolside, drinking sangria!

Ss041609hs761 Reply

All fixed -- thanks for pointing it out!

Landing Reply

Family french toast-making this morning... and all three girls declared that it was the best french toast they ever had... and so easy to make!

Rimg0130 Reply

Question from an american who's lived in Paris too long to know her ingredients : crème fraîche would be too heavy ?

Kay_at_lake Reply

H'mm. I think it would. All you can do is try and see!

Reply

Steffanie,
Use what they call "cooking creme".
Cheers
irina

Reply

Steffanie,
Use what they call "cooking creme".
Cheers
irina

Reply

This was brunch today. No need to make it any other way.

Dsc_0028 Reply

I made this today for Sunday breakfast served with a choice of fresh (real) maple syrup or a strawberry-blackberry-rhubarb compote. Rave reviews from my family who called it the best french toast ever!

Kay_at_lake Reply

Thanks, everyone! Excited to be a finalist, and anxious to have this French toast for breakfast tomorrow, since I've been thinking about it for the last 24 hours!

Steve_dunn02 Reply

There is nothing better for french toast than Challah...period! Congrats on making the finals, love the purity of this dish.

Logo-fb Reply

This is a great recipe. You keep it simple, but you tell us how to make it shine - the challah bread and cream and a drizzle of maple syrup. This sounds just wonderful.

Img_0423 Reply

This looks just delicious. Looking forward to trying it this weekend.

Reply

Fabulous french toast. This is it!

Dsc_0019_2 Reply

I love the simplicity of this. Prepared perfectly this will make a wonderful, elegant breakfast any day of the week. And my daughter will love it, too!

Monkeys Reply

Ring the bells and blow the whistles! Congrats!

Gaby_by_sarah Reply

This is exactly how I make my French toast! I used to put a little cinnamon in the batter until I started cooking for my beau who likes his french toast savory, served with eggs bacon and hot sauce....I still eat mine with powdered sugar and cinnamon, yum. Congrats Kayb!

Kay_at_lake Reply

Thanks, all. I love the "fancy" French toasts as well (see the other recipe I just posted), but this is the one I keep coming back to.

Reply

Pure French Toast...I love the austerity of your ingredients!

Cheese_for_twitter0001 Reply

Love the name.

Dsc_0382 Reply

elegantly simple!

186003_1004761561_1198459_n Reply

Indeed!! a very honest french toast!!

Reply

We had the same idea as far as recipes go, but I use a different technique for "grilling."

Mrs Reply

Perfectly simple!

Meet our Hotliners:

Steven Raichlen

Steven is the author of the best-selling Barbecue Bible and the host of two grilling TV shows: The Primal Grill and Barbecue University.

Steven Raichlen answered What are the best fish/wood chips to use in a stovetop smoker? 9 months ago