Join The Sandwich Universe co-hosts (and longtime BFFs) Molly Baz and Declan Bond as they dive deep into beloved, iconic sandwiches.
Listen NowPopular on Food52
44 Comments
Kate V.
August 23, 2017
Thank you for the beautiful, nostalgic recipe. I've made mine vegetarian and it takes just like my aunties' would have made.
kissy28c
February 11, 2011
Hi I just wanted to let you know that since you posted this recipe, my husband and I have made it twice and we plan to make it again tonight. We mostly stick to your recipe (adding fresh tomatoes and just a touch more bacon - Applegate organic sunday bacon is awesome - for smokiness) and it's fantastic every time. Thanks so much for sharing your great ideas.
enthous
February 1, 2011
I'm a second generation Italian American and have always made my mother's version, which is much more strongly tomato-based. This was really delicious and a nice change for us. I also used pancetta, which doesn't overtake the subtle flavors, and threw in a small parmesan rind and a sprig of fresh rosemary. The rosemary added a beautiful aromatic layer that we enjoyed.
QueenOfGreen
February 1, 2011
Ooh! I like the sound of that! Might have to try your modifications myself soon!
rjoskow
January 24, 2011
I feel very silly asking, but do you cook the ditalini in the soup, or separately?
Jane E.
January 23, 2011
This is great; I will make it--and it looks like a real weeknight dish. Quite do-able. The first time I had this was in Naples forty years ago, and the hostess threw in great gouts of olive oil and raw garlic and hot red peppers by the handful. It was certainly a mouth explosion for me, who until then had never even put black pepper on my food. I have done my best to reproduce it at home. I think the original had a cheese rind in it as well. Thanks for the recipe.
mrslarkin
January 24, 2011
yes! parmigiano cheese rind! stash them in a ziploc in your freezer. don't ever throw them out. this is the perfect soup for a hunk o cheese rind.
Q: do you cook the pasta right in with the soup, or separately?
Q: do you cook the pasta right in with the soup, or separately?
innoabrd
January 20, 2011
Looks yummy. Maybe when it starts to get cold again here. If I was in the US, I'd use pancetta too. Most american bacon is crap. Too much artificial smoke flavour, not to mention sugar and brine. Unless you can find a good unsmoked, dry-cure bacon, pancetta gives you more of the essence of pork, IMO.
We have the same strangest food in our profiles! How about that?
We have the same strangest food in our profiles! How about that?
fearlessem
January 18, 2011
Just made this tonight and it was so good! Quick, easy, and flavorful. I used pancetta instead of bacon since I prefer it in this type of soup, but otherwise made no changes... Thanks for a great weeknight recipe!
Jestei
January 19, 2011
interesting -- what about pancetta do you find preferable, as i have pondered this many times. i am glad you enjoyed this dish!
fearlessem
January 19, 2011
I think I prefer Pancetta because in a dish with otherwise mild flavors -- celery, white beans, pasta -- I often find that bacon winds up dominating more than I'd like it to. Pancetta has the saltiness and the porkiness without the in-your-faceness! But again -- fabulous recipe -- my husband was raving about it all night.
mklug
January 18, 2011
Also check out Grobals--they're self-watering-ish mod looking little pots that have managed to save some herbs from my death hands...BTW, my New Year's resolution--one of many--was to refer to myself more often in the third person and such (love the movie "The Queen"). Have befuddled some of my clients, though, by saying things like, "Your attorney would suggest you take the plea" and having them want to know where that attorney is.
Rhonda35
January 18, 2011
I always have celery! It's a good kid-friendly snack and my vehicle for ingesting large quantities of blue cheese dressing.
I'm going to give this soup a try; I grew up around Italian-American families who made a big deal out of this soup - whose version was the right one, etc. I never really understood all the fuss. Yet, there must be something sublime or comforting about it to cause all the debate. So, I will give it a shot.
Regarding herbs in the Midlantic area: you can plant everything except basil in April. By May, it is pretty hot and hard for the roots to get going. Basil can go in once there is no worry of frost. I kill everything I plant, too, but I have managed to keep my herbs going - knock on wood.
I'm going to give this soup a try; I grew up around Italian-American families who made a big deal out of this soup - whose version was the right one, etc. I never really understood all the fuss. Yet, there must be something sublime or comforting about it to cause all the debate. So, I will give it a shot.
Regarding herbs in the Midlantic area: you can plant everything except basil in April. By May, it is pretty hot and hard for the roots to get going. Basil can go in once there is no worry of frost. I kill everything I plant, too, but I have managed to keep my herbs going - knock on wood.
Rhonda35
January 18, 2011
P.S. Good luck with the puppy - crate train and you won't have too many messes. I was completely against getting a dog two years ago. I lost the battle and we got a lab. Now I have two because I love them so much! So, there is hope.
Jestei
January 18, 2011
I love food52 precisely for tips on celery and gardens and crating and the like. It's just the best community! xx oo
TheWimpyVegetarian
January 18, 2011
What a perfect comfort soup! Made this for dinner tonight but made a couple changes based on what was in my kitchen. I had a couple carrots and some dino kale I really needed to use for something, so they got thrown into the mix. And I made a fresh vegetable stock for it since I didn't have any chix stock around. Everything else I kept the same as the recipe. Love, love, love it. Can't wait for leftovers for tomorrow's lunch! Thanks for spotlighting such a perfect winter-time recipe!!!
Jestei
January 18, 2011
I think kale would be a FANTASTIC addition and a great use of what is in the markets.
ronpots2
January 17, 2011
I made this for supper tonight and it was delicious! My wife came home from work and said, "Something smells good". She loved it. I ended up using 2 cans (28 oz total) of chicken broth. Wonderful w. the red pepper flakes and cheese added at the end. This will be going into our 'favorite recipes' for sure. Thanks!
Jestei
January 18, 2011
nothing makes me more thrilled than reading comments from food52ers who feel inspired to go ahead and actually make the dish THAT NIGHT! thank you so much; i am thrilled you enjoyed it and i am sure queenofgreen is too.
tom_miller
January 17, 2011
This looks wonderful Jen always been a fan of comfort soups. I'll have to try this one out..If you like one for a crock pot I did one using my slow cooker. http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1628079016111&set=a.1437362848326.217860.1060648114
tom_miller
January 17, 2011
http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=10150123359539305&comments&ref=mf
Soozll
January 17, 2011
Holy moly! SoCal to Wash. DC? When you make a change, you really make a change, no wonder you have a hard time adjusting! I made the reverse change..DC metro to NorCal, and have never looked back longingly, though many do (I can't even imagine that!)
I've heard a lot of love spoken about this pasta dish, but have never tried it. Will now! Thanks.
I've heard a lot of love spoken about this pasta dish, but have never tried it. Will now! Thanks.
mcs3000
January 17, 2011
Love dishes like this where no shopping is needed (will just skip the celery). Gentle goodness indeed. And hang in there - cherry blossoms are coming - and even our beloved California can't match that grandeur.
@mrslarkin - thanks for the celery foil tip!
@mrslarkin - thanks for the celery foil tip!
TheWimpyVegetarian
January 17, 2011
Thanks for profiling this recipe! It's perfect for tonight's dinner! What kind of puppy? We're between dogs right now and am having mixed emotions about starting all over again. I love them so much but don't miss some of the ownership responsibilities....
Jestei
January 17, 2011
cockapoo. the issue in this house is the LACK of mixed emotions: the kids want it and i don't. so. guess who won. one more mouth to feed. i am sure i will be in love.....eventually.:)
TheWimpyVegetarian
January 17, 2011
I'm sure you will be too - just takes a little while through the whole puppyhood thing. But it's worth it when you end up with a dog that's just a great companion :-)
Lizthechef
January 17, 2011
Glad you have adjusted to life in DC but we miss you here in SoCAL - 75 degrees...
See what other Food52 readers are saying.