Popular on Food52
22 Comments
Nanda G.
September 29, 2016
First off, I'm very appreciative of this piece. I have many alternative flours and sometimes don't understand how they behave differently...you saved me having to bake and eat so many batches of cookies!
Question: my experience with Teff hasn't been great to date, and I've been using recipes (vs. winging it on my own). The texture comes out sandy. The only time that didn't happen was with a brownie recipe. Do these really avoid the sandy texture, and if so, how?
Question: my experience with Teff hasn't been great to date, and I've been using recipes (vs. winging it on my own). The texture comes out sandy. The only time that didn't happen was with a brownie recipe. Do these really avoid the sandy texture, and if so, how?
Alanna
October 3, 2016
Hi Nanda! What brand of teff flour are you using? Sometimes the grind varies by brand (I use Bob's Red Mill). I didn't find these teff cookies sandy at all, so maybe it has to do with the ratio of liquid in the dough. Letting the dough stand also allows the flour to absorb moisture and soften. The tapioca probably helps smooth things out, too!
Anabel
October 12, 2016
I made this recipe as written twice using a scale to make sure all the measurements would be accurate. The first time I used oat flour, and the second time I used teff flour. I, like you, found the texture of the teff cookies to be pretty sandy (I used Bob's Red Mill brand of teff flour).
Another issue I had with both types of cookies was that they kept spreading too much while baking. Freezing the dough and then baking at a higher temperature helped a little, but the cookies did not have a uniform texture (ie edges were super crispy and centers were gooey), and the centers of the cookies sank.
Another issue I had with both types of cookies was that they kept spreading too much while baking. Freezing the dough and then baking at a higher temperature helped a little, but the cookies did not have a uniform texture (ie edges were super crispy and centers were gooey), and the centers of the cookies sank.
Alanna
March 2, 2017
Hi Anabel, I think I know the answer! I recently bought a new bag of Bob's teff flour, which is now certified GF, and noticed it had a more coarse texture than their previous, non-certified-GF bag. I baked the teff cookies from my book, and sure enough, they spread a ton. I think the mystery is solved - they must have different facilities that grind the grain differently. The more coarse grind doesn't absorb moisture as well or have as much surface area, and baked goods made with it bake up with a sandier texture. So frustrating! Anyway, I'm planning to reformulate these to work with their coarser grind - I'll try adding 2 T more tapioca flour and see if it helps. Fingers crossed.
When I first started working on Alternative Baker, I was using the teff flour from the bulk bin of my co-op, which is made by The Teff Company and ground powder fine. It was a dream to work with, but hard to find, which is why I switched to Bob's. But if you wanted to order some Teff Company flour to play with, I bet you'd love it!
When I first started working on Alternative Baker, I was using the teff flour from the bulk bin of my co-op, which is made by The Teff Company and ground powder fine. It was a dream to work with, but hard to find, which is why I switched to Bob's. But if you wanted to order some Teff Company flour to play with, I bet you'd love it!
Anabel
March 8, 2017
Hi Alanna, Thanks so much for this information! I will see if I can track down Teff Company teff flour at my co-op. I think for now I will make my favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe, and substitute some of the AP flour with teff to get some of that teff flavor. Thanks again!!
nycnomad
September 21, 2016
Perhaps I missed it but how long did you bake at 375?
Sarah M.
September 21, 2016
If you click the "recipe" link it'll explain the entire process. Looks like she says to "Bake the cookies until the edges are golden and set and the tops are pale golden but still soft and underbaked, 8 to 12 minutes, rotating the pans back to front and top to bottom after 8 minutes for even baking." Hope this helps!
RENEE
September 16, 2016
WOW THIS IS A GAME CHANGER!!! I can't believe how detailed this is. I love the section all about how using different flours changed the flavor quality in the recipe. Obviously TEFF RULES. Teff is life. So stoked to try this out in all of the variations.
Anabel
September 16, 2016
This is such a wonderful and helpful post, and I can't wait to try making some oat flour cookies. If I already have a chocolate chip cookie recipe that I like, do you have any recommendations for how much oat flour and tapioca flour to use for every 1 cup (125 gm) all purpose four? Thanks!
Alanna
September 19, 2016
Hi Anabel, that's a good question. It's a bit tricky since the flours have to match up by weight as well, but it's pretty close to my recipe here: 3/4 c + 3 T oat flour and 6 T tapioca, for 145 grams. I'd just us a bit less than this to equal 125 g in your recipe. Let me know how it goes!
Two T.
September 16, 2016
What a great post! I have to ask-- is subbing tapioca flour a possibility? Would cornstarch work? (I am guessing no!)
Alanna
September 16, 2016
Hi there! Hm, I'm not sure about cornstarch, as it tends to make things crispy rather than chewy. Potato starch could potentially work, though it tends to make baked goods soggy since it's hygroscopic (meaning it likes to grab water molecules out of the air). You might also try sweet white rice flour (Mochiko). Please let us know if you experiment!
Join The Conversation